supercharger

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Romer, you're an engineer, right? Do you happen to recall what the increase in air density is for each degree of temp drop? I'm curious how much boost your snorkel adds with its cooler (denser) intake air charge.

PV=nRT
 
Sumotoy,

What the hell is excess air as it applies to the sc setup in our cruisers? As far as I know there is no such thing in our cases b/c the sc is a closed system.

Karl
 
Sumotoy,

What the hell is excess air as it applies to the sc setup in our cruisers? As far as I know there is no such thing in our cases b/c the sc is a closed system.

Karl

Karl
Unless the supercharger puts out exactly engine demand, there is excess, to account for things like altitude for instance. My question is, what happens to that excess air in a supercharged application?

Or do you believe in a closed system, there is no extra available airflow? Karl, SC speed (air supply) is linear based on engine rpm. However, engine VE (air demand) is only somewhat linear, corrected by all factors that affect VE (from cams to intake manifold tuning).

For instance, at sea level running the 2.4 pulley ratio, the 1FEFZ engine demand for air at peak HP I have figured at ~420CFM (at 6.5psi). Yet, Eaton shows the 6.5psi supercharger with a 2.4 Pulley Ratio puts out 500cfm, what happens to the 80cfm extra? And more to the point, what happens to the 10% additional airflow from the SC vs Engine across the entire rpm band?

I'm not sure I disagree that the SC is a 'closed system', just working on defining that in absolute pressure terms vs altitude.

Scott J
94 FZJ80 Supercharged
 
1. You said my gauge isn't that accurate so any delta is probably just within the tolerance of accuracy. I get that you stated that as your opinion.

I don't know the nut behind the wheel well enough. I do know that relative pressure gauges are well ascribed as such. Absolute pressure gauges need only be calibrated. I can put a point of reference of .5psi.... I used a liquid filled 2 5/8 boost gauge on my 4Runner, that had altitude reset. I could barely just tell the difference between 10 and 10.5psi... Non liquid filled relative pressure gauges are not accurate, especially in superchargers, because of supercharger blade pulsations. You can tell me you saw more boost at 700ft lower altitude, I say your gauge isn't even calibrated to be that accurate. In my opinion.

2. no clue what your point is, but I don't recall anyone saying the output of a SC is fixed

The output of the SC is fixed based on rpm. However, I say compressor efficiency changes based on engine VE factors. IOW, if the SC ouput is fixed, and engine demand is always less than SC ouput (on a 6.5psi system), how do we account for that in a formula for airflow? Then how do we account for that in a formula for altitude changes?

3. That was suppose to make it simple? no clue what you are saying here either.

Working hard to have some thinking going on here Ken. According to Eaton you have 500cfm of air available at 2.4 Pulley ratio at 4350rpm, and the engine demand for air is 420cfm, what do/did you do with the 80cfm of excess air?

I think psfpilot is onto something here...

Scott J
1994 FZJ80 Supercharged
 
[/i][/b]

Ken
I use 3% for every 1000 feet in altitude on a normally aspriated engine. Problem, that applies only to normally aspirated engines. For supercharged and turbocharged vehicles, it's more correct to use the formula for Pressure Ratio, which shows how force induction has less of a loss for any given altitude gain....

Pressure Ratio = Pressure Atmosphere + Boost Pressure/Pressure Atmosphere OR PR = Pa + Pb/Pa

So for a super/turbo truck at sea level
PR = 14.5 + 6.5/14.5
PR = 1.45

For a super/turbo truck at 5000ft
PR = 12.2 + 6.5/12.2
PR = 1.53

Since we know that the density of air is 13% less at 5000 feet, we would expect the same decrease of 13% power output on a normally aspirated engine. However, when you apply force induction, the drop in power is less. However, that can actually be a lot less, since supercharger compressor efficiency will vary with engine demand, load, and volumetric efficiency at a given altitude.




Just differentiating between an absolute pressure guage, and a relative pressure gauge. What's on your truck, is a relative pressure gauge, so it should read higher. Whether it does or not is affected by all the other variables associated with absolute manifold pressure (and Density = temp). Most factory turbocharged applications are absolute pressure based. Since the advent of electronic wastegate control, most turbo applications are 99% of engine power up to 10,000 feet. Usually at 10,000 feet a barametric sensor switch shuts down altitude compensation to prevent turbo overspin.



That's a lot of efficiency Ken, I personally don't buy it, but maybe under ram air conditions only. I think you might see a slight difference at high speed (ram air effect) + low altitude. But I see problems at low speed and/or high altitude. If the air is less dense at higher altitude, you would need a larger pipe to create the same positive pressure at the inlet of the SC (or going slow enough, you would need a larger pipe to create less negative pressure). The slower the vehicle speed, the longer pipe friction surface starts to revert back to *more* negative pressure at the SC inlet than a stock air inlet.

Race car engineers like 'directiing' air vs ducting air when possible for this very reason. There is no mathmatical limit to air volume and pressure in a scoop or dam. There is an exact mathmatical limit to air volume and pressure (> temp) in any given size duct.

Remember your WWII era planes used supercharging to produce gains at much higher altitudes than we will ever drive....

Cheers

Scott Justusson
94 FZJ80 Supercharged

My head hurts;

I would like to know a few simple things from people who have installed these:

Horsepower increase?
0-60 times?
Change in gas mileage?
Increase wear on engine (or damage0??

Are the worth it, for some who does not live in the mountains?

Thanks
g
 
Working hard to have some thinking going on here Ken.

I hate that. If you can't explain stuff so it can be understood than don't post. It's not up to you to make me or anyone else here think. If you explained it so I could understand what you were saying then I may actually be able to have some thoughts about what you are trying to say rather than getting more pissed off:mad:

If you could actually explain stuff in a way that would make us think about it, then maybe that would be OK. When your explanations are unclear and maybe only understandable by a very very small % of members here than you are not doing anyone a favor. All your doing is pissing me off by talking down to me.

Go read the post psfpilot made a few back. I understood his explanation and what he was trying to say. He was trying to communicate to me and other forum members. You are trying to "make us think" I am sure you don't want me to say here what your posts have me thinking?

Does anyone else know what he is trying to say or have we just derailed another thread?



Disclaimer - this is my post as a mud member and not as a moderator. As a member I am trying to understand something here and am getting frustrated with some of the responses.
 
My head hurts;

I would like to know a few simple things from people who have installed these:

Horsepower increase?
0-60 times?
Change in gas mileage?
Increase wear on engine (or damage0??

Are the worth it, for some who does not live in the mountains?

Thanks
g

TRD catalog claims up to 52hp and 80ft-lb increase. You might want to do a search on your other questions, folks have posted regarding mileage/wear. Consensus seems to be that mileage won't get better, and wear is not a factor. Plus you'd be running premium 91/93 octane (depending on what constitutes premium in your neighborhood).
 
Sumo, once again you have successfully derailed a thread about SC's because you are an expert and can speak so far above everyone else's head that if most are like me we just scroll past your post due to it unreadability for a lamen. The original discussion of this thread I believe is the availability of the actual SC and a correction as to what is posted based on TRD's own specs. Not Sumo's spec's but TOYOTA'S.

Your on extremelly thin ice here and I for one am growing very weary of having to point it out as often as I seem to have to.

Disclaimer: This was posted as a moderator and should be taken as such.
 
I hate that. If you can't explain stuff so it can be understood than don't post. It's not up to you to make me or anyone else here think. If you explained it so I could understand what you were saying then I may actually be able to have some thoughts about what you are trying to say rather than getting more pissed off:mad:

Ken, I'm a nerd, and forced induction is a complex subject. Supercharging has even more black holes.... You put a post about how relative pressure gauges operate, and I attempted to present why that appears incorrect. You posted a 2.4 pulley ratio giving 8psi boost pressure, I attempted to present how TRD appears to show that as incorrect. I also summarized 4 points for you, understanding completely the complexity of the topic.

If you could actually explain stuff in a way that would make us think about it, then maybe that would be OK. When your explanations are unclear and maybe only understandable by a very very small % of members here than you are not doing anyone a favor. All your doing is pissing me off by talking down to me.

Ken, instead of sending me this, send me a PM, or an email. A lot of truly interested folks on this forum do. I don't mean to speak down to you, I intend to help tech lists be a resource. Here, I do this by pointing out some of the accepted theory and applications of Superchargers. And I own one, and I've owned a dozen turbo cars in the last 15 years, never blew one up at altitude either. Again, if there is something specific you don't understand, I'm available by PM or email, or pick up the phone. I'm willing to help wade thru this topic because I find it interesting.

Go read the post psfpilot made a few back. I understood his explanation and what he was trying to say. He was trying to communicate to me and other forum members. You are trying to "make us think" I am sure you don't want me to say here what your posts have me thinking?

I addressed psfpilot post. Isn't this the nature of a tech forum? There are nerds, then there are folks inbetween nerds and layfolk to help interpret? I think psfpilot grasps the concept fully, and I worked to attain the next step in understanding. There is a lot of good information here if there is interest in wading through it.

As a nerd, and a forum member, I understand if there is no interest too. No moderation necessary.

Cheers

Scott J
94 FZJ80 Supercharged
 
So am I reading this right to say that Sumo isn't debating the actual pressures, but rather the ability of the gauge to display pressures accurately at different altitudes?

If I am correct, I officially suggest we issue Sumo 40 lashes for making a simple discussion WAAAY overly complex. If I am wrong, I am just as lost as Romer :)

EDIT: Oh yeah, when will this SC be available...I might be able to get one next year...buying lottery tickets daily!
 
Ken, I'm a nerd, and forced induction is a complex subject. Supercharging has even more black holes....


Ken, instead of sending me this, send me a PM, or an email. A lot of truly interested folks on this forum do. I don't mean to speak down to you, I intend to help tech lists be a resource.
Cheers

I have sent you many PM's on your posting style in the past and youhaven't done anything about it.

Every expert I know is capable of taking a complex subject and explaining it in simple terms so the masses can understand. Forced induction is not that complex a subject. You make it complex the way you talk about it, I can make boiling water sound complex if I use the same level of explanation you do.

I am able to explain how a spacecraft work with all the systems so most anyone can understand, surely you can do that with a super charger. Here is a quick example I got from doing a google search. I know you are trying to explain a complex subject and be a resource, your not succeeding!

From how stuff works http://auto.howstuffworks.com/supercharger.htm


Since the invention of the internal combustion engine, automotive engineers, speed junkies and racecar designers have been searching for ways to boost its power. One way to add power is to build a bigger engine. But bigger engines, which weigh more and cost more to build and maintain, are not always better.

Another way to add power is to make a normal-sized engine more efficient. You can accomplish this by forcing more air into the combustion chamber. More air means more fuel can be added, and more fuel means a bigger explosion and greater horsepower. Adding a supercharger is a great way to achieve forced air induction.

A supercharger is any device that pressurizes the air intake to above atmospheric pressure. Both superchargers and turbochargers do this. In fact, the term "turbocharger" is a shortened version of "turbo-supercharger," its official name.


Supercharger Basics

An ordinary four-stroke engine dedicates one stroke to the process of air intake. There are three steps in this process:
  1. The piston moves down.
  2. This creates a vacuum.
  3. Air at atmospheric pressure is sucked into the combustion chamber.
Once air is drawn into the engine, it must be combined with fuel to form the charge -- a packet of potential energy that can be turned into useful kinetic energy through a chemical reaction known as combustion. The spark plug initiates this chemical reaction by igniting the charge. As the fuel undergoes oxidation, a great deal of energy is released. The force of this explosion, concentrated above the cylinder head, drives the piston down and creates a reciprocating motion that is eventually transferred to the wheels.


Getting more fuel into the charge would make for a more powerful explosion. But you can't simply pump more fuel into the engine because an exact amount of oxygen is required to burn a given amount of fuel. This chemically correct mixture -- 14 parts air to one part fuel -- is essential for an engine to operate efficiently. The bottom line: To put in more fuel, you have to put in more air. That's the job of the supercharger. Superchargers increase intake by compressing air above atmospheric pressure, without creating a vacuum. This forces more air into the engine, providing a "boost." With the additional air in the boost, more fuel can be added to the charge, and the power of the engine is increased. Supercharging adds an average of 46 percent more horsepower and 31 percent more torque. In high-altitude situations, where engine performance deteriorates because the air has low density and pressure, a supercharger delivers higher-pressure air to the engine so it can operate optimally.

Unlike turbochargers, which use the exhaust gases created by combustion to power the compressor, superchargers draw their power directly from the crankshaft. Most are driven by an accessory belt, which wraps around a pulley that is connected to a drive gear. The drive gear, in turn, rotates the compressor gear. The rotor of the compressor can come in various designs, but its job is to draw air in, squeeze the air into a smaller space and discharge it into the intake manifold.


To pressurize the air, a supercharger must spin rapidly -- more rapidly than the engine itself. Making the drive gear larger than the compressor gear causes the compressor to spin faster. Superchargers can spin at speeds as high as 50,000 to 65,000 rotations per minute (RPM).
A compressor spinning at 50,000 RPM translates to a boost of about six to nine pounds per square inch (psi). That's six to nine additional psi over the atmospheric pressure at a particular elevation. Atmospheric pressure at sea level is 14.7 psi, so a typical boost from a supercharger places about 50 percent more air into the engine. As the air is compressed, it gets hotter, which means that it loses its density and can not expand as much during the explosion. This means that it can't create as much power when it's ignited by the spark plug. For a supercharger to work at peak efficiency, the compressed air exiting the discharge unit must be cooled before it enters the intake manifold. The intercooler is responsible for this cooling process. Intercoolers come in two basic designs: air-to-air intercoolers and air-to-water intercoolers. Both work just like a radiator, with cooler air or water sent through a system of pipes or tubes. As the hot air exiting the supercharger encounters the cooler pipes, it also cools down. The reduction in air temperature increases the density of the air, which makes for a denser charge entering the combustion chamber.
 
Last edited:
See now that explains in a non complex way how the supercharger works

It tells me that the cooler air by using the snorkel increases power as it provides more air to mix with fuel.

It tells me that at higher altitude, the supercharger makes up for the loss of power a normally aspirated engine would see.

That wasn't quite the discussion we were doing, but in a 2 minute serach I wanted to find an example of how to explain a complex subject
 
[Unless the supercharger puts out exactly engine demand, there is excess, to account for things like altitude for instance. My question is, what happens to that excess air in a supercharged application? ]

There is a mechanical connection between the sc and the engine. The output of the sc does not vary wrt to altitude or temperature of the air, or its measured density. The ecu manages the fuel charge to account for all the air in the system. The ecu accounts for things like temperature and so on. There is no excess air in the system. If there was, the truck would run like crap and the o2 sensors would pick up a lean condition and add fuel.

The magnitude of the boost is however varied wrt to engine load via the bypass valve - less vacuum, more boost. The bypass valve lets air bypass the compressor stage and the sc spins idle; however, the measured volume of air remains the same after the MAF. The sc setup is very unlike a turbo where there may be excess air in a turbo system. For example, at high rpm between shifts - the driver lifts thier foot off the accelerator, the turbo is still spinning and boosting, but there is no need for boost according to the vacuum, so the "access air" is vented.

[Or do you believe in a closed system, there is no extra available airflow? Karl, SC speed (air supply) is linear based on engine rpm. However, engine VE (air demand) is only somewhat linear, corrected by all factors that affect VE (from cams to intake manifold tuning). ]

The operating rpm of the sc is a ratio of the engine rpm.

If one were to plot rpm vs. VE on a chart I suspect that the relationship would be nonlinear. VE has nothing to do with engine load though. Its a measure of how efficiently air is pulled into the engine at a given rpm. Some folks get the head on thier engines ported to improve VE or, in other words, intake air flow. One could use the term volumetric efficiency on an exhaust system too. An exhaust sytem with lots of bends in it has low VE because the air gets compressed in the system.

[For instance, at sea level running the 2.4 pulley ratio, the 1FEFZ engine demand for air at peak HP I have figured at ~420CFM (at 6.5psi). Yet, Eaton shows the 6.5psi supercharger with a 2.4 Pulley Ratio puts out 500cfm, what happens to the 80cfm extra? And more to the point, what happens to the 10% additional airflow from the SC vs Engine across the entire rpm band?]

There is no extra airflow. Consider two cruisers - one with an sc and the other without and both taking on the same hill at the same speed. The sc cruiser will operate at a different rpm than the no-sc cruiser because it has more base hp and thus operates at a different rpm to have the same hp output as the no-sc cruiser. In other words, the additional air is measured by the ecu and more fuel is added resulting in more heat and more hp.

[I'm not sure I disagree that the SC is a 'closed system', just working on defining that in absolute pressure terms vs altitude.]

I dont understand this comment. Perhaps you intended to make two comments, but merged the two thoughts? I suspect that you are contemplating the loss of horsepower with respect to elevation. I think that part of the loss can be explained by the partial pressure of oxygen. Take Mt. Whitney for example. The elevation at the top of Mt. Whitney is about 14497'. The partial pressure of o2 at the top is about 40% compared to the partial pressure at sea level. In my minds model of an engine it sees a lean condition at high altitude and decreases fuel and there is a corresponding decrease in hp. The higher up you go the worse things get. I think the change atmospheric pressure has little to do with the change in hp wrt to elevation compared to the change in partial pressure of oxygen.

Karl
 
Last edited:
Scott, your a smart guy with a lot to offer to this board. Please try and explain your concept using a simple explanation as I showed above in an example. Don't qoute theories or math just use simple language. Don't try and make me think just explain. I would like to know what your points were.
 
There is a mechanical connection between the sc and the engine. The output of the sc does not vary wrt to altitude or temperature of the air, or its measured density. The ecu manages the fuel charge to account for all the air in the system. The ecu accounts for things like temperature and so on. There is no excess air in the system. If there was, the truck would run like crap and the o2 sensors would pick up a lean condition and add fuel.

I don't agree. The output does vary, if you measure air in Mass not volume, that defines compressor efficiency (boost map). The engine will take in various amounts of air from the SC based on VE.

The magnitude of the boost is however varied wrt to engine load via the bypass valve - less vacuum, more boost. The bypass valve lets air bypass the compressor stage and the sc spins idle; however, the measured volume of air remains the same after the MAF. The sc setup is very unlike a turbo where there may be excess air in a turbo system. For example, at high rpm between shifts - the driver lifts thier foot off the accelerator, the turbo is still spinning and boosting, but there is no need for boost according to the vacuum, so the "access air" is vented.

I speak to the difference in air without lifting, supercharger or turbocharger. In a turbo, the excess air capacity is discharged via the wastegate. The SC has no wastegate. Bypass valves in turbo systems and supercharger systems vent all charge air pressure at manifold vacuum (throttle shut), not 'some' charge air pressure.


The operating rpm of the sc is a ratio of the engine rpm.

If one were to plot rpm vs. VE on a chart I suspect that the relationship would be nonlinear. VE has nothing to do with engine load though. Its a measure of how efficiently air is pulled into the engine at a given rpm. Some folks get the head on thier engines ported to improve VE or, in other words, intake air flow. One could use the term volumetric efficiency on an exhaust system too. An exhaust sytem with lots of bends in it has low VE because the air gets compressed in the system.

Karl, I don't agree with this statement. You need to remember, you have no boost (turbo or SC) with no load. So, I don't agree VE has nothing to do with load. It absolutely does! You can rev a supercharged or turbocharged motor to redline without boost. Even under load you can. Add boost = more load, VE changes infinite matrix based on load and boost level. By definition in excess of 100% VE of the same motor without boost.


There is no extra airflow. Consider two cruisers - one with an sc and the other without and both taking on the same hill at the same speed. The sc cruiser will operate at a different rpm than the no-sc cruiser because it has more base hp and thus operates at a different rpm to have the same hp output as the no-sc cruiser. In other words, the additional air is measured by the ecu and more fuel is added resulting in more heat and more hp.

There is extra airflow capacity. In a turbo application, this is varied by the turbo wastegate. In a mechanical supercharger, you can't do that.


[I'm not sure I disagree that the SC is a 'closed system', just working on defining that in absolute pressure terms vs altitude.]

I dont understand this comment. Perhaps you intended to make two comments, but merged the two thoughts? I suspect that you are contemplating the loss of horsepower with respect to elevation. I think that part of the loss can be explained by the partial pressure of oxygen. Take Mt. Whitney for example. The elevation at the top of Mt. Whitney is about 14497'. The partial pressure of o2 at the top is about 40% compared to the partial pressure at sea level. In my minds model of an engine it sees a lean condition at high altitude and decreases fuel and there is a corresponding decrease in hp. The higher up you go the worse things get. I think the change atmospheric pressure has little to do with the change in hp wrt to elevation compared to the change in partial pressure of oxygen.
Karl

I'm not clear on the difference. I guess we can summarize this to say that the Effective Compression Ratio (equals Static Comprssion Ratio + Boost) changes engine output at different altitudes. What I do see and propose is that any excess turbo/SC air capacity allows for changes in altitude without affecting performance at a given boost level above atmospheric.

Scott J
94 FZJ80 Supercharged
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom