supercharger

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Ken,
You are in my turbo world now sir! If you read higher readings at lower elevation, then my bet is either your gauge is not bleeding fully from your high altitude set point, it's just incorrect, or more likely, your ecu has not fully altitude compensated, causing poor Volumetric Efficiency (the less the VE, the higher boost you will read). Absolute pressure guages are really expensive Ken, I know the one you installed is NOT an absolute pressure guage. Which means exactly that increases in altitude will cause a higher boost *guage* reading. Absolute Pressure will decrease slightly because the pump (SC) efficiency falls off with increases in Pressure Ratio.

If Absolute Pressure = Guage Pressure + Ambient Pressure, then with a 2.4 pulley ratio (3.2in SC pulley)....

At 5000 ft
8psi + 12.2psi = 20.2 Absolute Pressure
at Sea Level
6.5psi + 14.7psi = 21.2 Absolute Pressure


So, your guage reads higher, mine lower, but Absolute Pressure remains constant, and with PR (actually really a density ratio issue) compensation, the 6.5 at altitude should perform better.

WRT altitude 'behavior' that's again a density ratio (compressor efficiency) problem, not a boost problem. Compressors work harder at altitude = less efficient.

WRT the differences in our trucks and TRD, the carb exemption order puts the same M90 SC on 1FEFZ motor from 1992-1997, with the same pulley diameter of 3.2in and the same crank pulley diameter of 7.7 inches = which means ALL engines so equipped should see 6.5psig (corrected to altitude). That is part and partial to EOD 425-7. Any claim of more psi than the 6.5 would be in violation of EOD 425-7, but more basic than that, would require a different SC pulley. OBDII can't change the output of the SC.

HTH

Scott J
94 FZJ80 Supercharged


I didn't know you had a turbo on your 80?

Oh back to the Turbo on an Audi and how you think that applies to landcruisers.

My bet is your wrong. I know what I see. I know from talking to other SC owners they see similar things (Spek up if you don't) I know when I talked with Toyota when I bought it, it is an 8lb boost.

I also know at higher elevations the air is less dense resulting in lower boost.
 
Great, my mods just went up to multiples of $4000.

I am redoing the top end and putting in a spanky AL radiator this winter, so the SC can go in next year...along with the 3-link, crawler box, and gold plating :)
 
I didn't know you had a turbo on your 80?

Oh back to the Turbo on an Audi and how you think that applies to landcruisers.

My bet is your wrong. I know what I see. I know from talking to other SC owners they see similar things (Spek up if you don't) I know when I talked with Toyota when I bought it, it is an 8lb boost.

I also know at higher elevations the air is less dense resulting in lower boost.

Ken, go here
http://www.arb.ca.gov/msprog/aftermkt/devices/amquery.php

Under "Select Executive Order" scroll to D-425-7 (take note of the PCV routing notation:)

A non-absolute automotive "Boost Pressure Guage" reading increases with altitude, turbo or SC, if the absolute pressure in the manifold stays constant.

You will find less dense air at higher altitude, causing changes in engine VE, which *can* cause a change in gauge readings and engine performance. That's a heat problem causing a lower absolute pressure.

If you have a 3.2in pulley, TRD already published the numbers in the EOD exemption of the same M90 in all years of the 1FEFZ.

Cheers

SJ
 
Last edited:

Power Loss due to Altitude​
Air Density decreases at a rate of 2.9% - 3.0% for each 1000 ft. of elevation above Sea Level. See Standard Atmosphere below for background information.
Naturally Aspirated: Atmospheric Pressure 14.5 psi (It's hard to ride at sea level 14.7 psi)
Atmospheric Pressure @ 9000 feet = 10.5 psi
Pressure Loss = (14.5 - 10.5) = 4.0 (4.0/14.5) = 27.58 % @ 9,000 feet


The Standard Atmosphere​
The standard atmosphere can be thought of as the average pressure, temperature and air density for various altitudes. It is useful for engineering calculations for aircraft & mountain sleds. It also shows in a general way the pressures and temperatures to be expected at various altitudes. The standard atmosphere is based on mathematical formulas that reduce temperature and pressure by certain amounts as altitude is gained. But, the results are close to averages of balloon and airplane measurements at various altitudes.
The table below uses metric units, which scientists use. Scroll down for a version using feet, fahrenheit temperatures and pressures in inches of mercury.
HeightTemperaturePressureDensity(m)(C)(hPa)(kg/m3)000015.010131.210008.59001.120002.08001.03000-4.57000.914000-11.06200.82

So the boost gauge reads how much pressure above the atmosphere. If the boost gives a constant pressure at seal level or elevation, then you would be correct. If the boost gauge gives readings relative to the 14.7 number then they would increase with altitiude and so I will give you that one.:beer:


The places I am comparing ar close to 700 feet within ecah other. The road to Moab outside Grand Junction is 4500 feet vs 5200 feet in denver. The differences I noted are likely due to driving conditions at the time whether environmental or driving style.

I still claim an increase of boost with the snorkel.
 
Power Loss due to Altitude​
Air Density decreases at a rate of 2.9% - 3.0% for each 1000 ft. of elevation above Sea Level. See Standard Atmosphere below for background information.
Naturally Aspirated: Atmospheric Pressure 14.5 psi (It's hard to ride at sea level 14.7 psi)
Atmospheric Pressure @ 9000 feet = 10.5 psi
Pressure Loss = (14.5 - 10.5) = 4.0 (4.0/14.5) = 27.58 % @ 9,000 feet


Ken
I use 3% for every 1000 feet in altitude on a normally aspriated engine. Problem, that applies only to normally aspirated engines. For supercharged and turbocharged vehicles, it's more correct to use the formula for Pressure Ratio, which shows how force induction has less of a loss for any given altitude gain....

Pressure Ratio = Pressure Atmosphere + Boost Pressure/Pressure Atmosphere OR PR = Pa + Pb/Pa

So for a super/turbo truck at sea level
PR = 14.5 + 6.5/14.5
PR = 1.45

For a super/turbo truck at 5000ft
PR = 12.2 + 6.5/12.2
PR = 1.53

Since we know that the density of air is 13% less at 5000 feet, we would expect the same decrease of 13% power output on a normally aspirated engine. However, when you apply force induction, the drop in power is less. However, that can actually be a lot less, since supercharger compressor efficiency will vary with engine demand, load, and volumetric efficiency at a given altitude.


The Standard Atmosphere
...

So the boost gauge reads how much pressure above the atmosphere. If the boost gives a constant pressure at seal level or elevation, then you would be correct. If the boost gauge gives readings relative to the 14.7 number then they would increase with altitiude and so I will give you that one.:beer:

Just differentiating between an absolute pressure guage, and a relative pressure gauge. What's on your truck, is a relative pressure gauge, so it should read higher. Whether it does or not is affected by all the other variables associated with absolute manifold pressure (and Density = temp). Most factory turbocharged applications are absolute pressure based. Since the advent of electronic wastegate control, most turbo applications are 99% of engine power up to 10,000 feet. Usually at 10,000 feet a barametric sensor switch shuts down altitude compensation to prevent turbo overspin.

The places I am comparing ar close to 700 feet within ecah other. The road to Moab outside Grand Junction is 4500 feet vs 5200 feet in denver. The differences I noted are likely due to driving conditions at the time whether environmental or driving style.

I still claim an increase of boost with the snorkel.

That's a lot of efficiency Ken, I personally don't buy it, but maybe under ram air conditions only. I think you might see a slight difference at high speed (ram air effect) + low altitude. But I see problems at low speed and/or high altitude. If the air is less dense at higher altitude, you would need a larger pipe to create the same positive pressure at the inlet of the SC (or going slow enough, you would need a larger pipe to create less negative pressure). The slower the vehicle speed, the longer pipe friction surface starts to revert back to *more* negative pressure at the SC inlet than a stock air inlet.

Race car engineers like 'directiing' air vs ducting air when possible for this very reason. There is no mathmatical limit to air volume and pressure in a scoop or dam. There is an exact mathmatical limit to air volume and pressure (> temp) in any given size duct.

Remember your WWII era planes used supercharging to produce gains at much higher altitudes than we will ever drive....

Cheers

Scott Justusson
94 FZJ80 Supercharged
 
Last edited:
Gee I guess I made it up then:rolleyes:

Boost on a supercharger is a mechanical function Ken. It's possible to have less negative pressure at the SC inlet, which would give better performance *only* under ram air situations (= Pi > Po = Pressure SC inlet > Pressure Atmospheric). The problem with long snorkels is that ram air is 1:1 correlation to vehicle speed. Which means exactly that gains could be positive or negative based on vehicle speed. At what speed do you find this significant? What's the diameter of the snorkel pipe and what is it's overall length? Isn't that snorkel designed for a stock normally aspirated 80?

When I see higher relative pressure gauge observation with a 500ft altitude difference in the wrong direction to how a relative pressure gauge works, and a snorkel summarily creating more pressure on a supercharger outlet, something doesn't seem right in the conclusion department. The reason I don't "buy it" is because the conclusions appear to defy the laws of physics in my opinion.

How do you explain an increase in observed relative gauge pressure to 8psi when dropping 700 ft on a 6.5psi SC?

When I drove my SC truck up at your altitudes over the last couple years, I can't say I felt any significant performance difference between sea level and 5000ft.

Not intending to harm or foul, only trying to understand what you are saying.

Scott J
94 FZJ80 Supercharged
 
Funny, my Cummins makes less boost in Denver, My SC Tacoma makes less in Denver, My HJ61 makes less in Denevr, and my wifes E55 makes less in Denver. I guess Mercedes, Chrysler and Toyota didn't get the memo.
 
Would the supercharger make different boost depending upon the output temperature and maybe the amount of engine work including porting the head, larger intake and exhaust valves, larger cylinder walls and bigger exhaust?
 
Funny, my Cummins makes less boost in Denver, My SC Tacoma makes less in Denver, My HJ61 makes less in Denevr, and my wifes E55 makes less in Denver. I guess Mercedes, Chrysler and Toyota didn't get the memo.

Turbo ECU's without MAPS and altitude compensation will make less performance at higher altitudes. My old GLH turbo had altitude compensation, audi, volvo, mazda, bmw all have altitude compensation in turbo applications. It's not a memo, it's how much padding a manufacturer puts into the turbo application, and how much altitude correction is in the programming. Some manufacturers spend more time and money on this than others. The point is, you can design a force inducted engine to have the same output at any altitude. To date, I'm only aware of Bosch offering a 10,000 ft barametric sensor switch for automotive applications. This is more likely due to overheating of charge air than anthing else.

Superchargers are more unique in that there are a lot of other factors that affect 'performance'. Since a SC doesn't rely on combustion energy for compressor efficiency, gains in low rpm 'on boost' performance are higher than a turbo, and can be higher than the same SC at lower altitudes.

Trying to stay out of the really nerdy stuff right now. Bottom line is that one of the advantages of SC/Turbo applications are less/no loss of performance due to altitude changes vs a normally aspirated engine of the same design.

HTH

Scott J
94 FZJ80 Supercharged
 
Last edited:
Would the supercharger make different boost depending upon the output temperature and maybe the amount of engine work including porting the head, larger intake and exhaust valves, larger cylinder walls and bigger exhaust?

SC boost isn't really a function of output temperature, that's a Density Ratio correction to Boost Pressure (Pressure Ratio) in the manifold. Certainly anything affecting engine Volumetric Efficiency will affect observed boost levels of the SC. As a rule, increases in engine VE on a mechanical force inducted engine will show decreases in absolute manifold pressure (and observed relative gauge pressure). As a rule, increases in engine VE on turbo force inducted engines will show no decrease in absolute manifold pressure (and observed relative gauge pressure).

Scott J
94 FZJ80 Supercharged
 
Boost on a supercharger is a mechanical function...

...How do you explain an increase in observed relative gauge pressure to 8psi when dropping 700 ft on a 6.5psi SC?...

A supercharger makes boost based on a fixed gear ratio, which is what I think you are acknowledging in this quote. Therefore, when the air at the supercharger inlet is more dense, the boost output pressure (noted on the gauge) will increase correspondingly.

For the sake of illustration, lets say that a theoretical supercharger is geared so that it adds 50% to pressure. Sea level pressure on a standard day is 14.7 psi. 150% of 14.7 is 22.05 psi, which would show up on a differential pressure gauge (aka boost gauge) as 7.35 psi of boost. If this same supercharger was pumping air at 1000' above mean sea level (assuming the same ambient air temp), it would have an input pressure of 14.7x97%= 14.529psi. 150% of 14.259= 21.3885psi. 21.3885 minus the ambient (input) pressure of 14.259 psi equals 7.1295 psi of boost, or a loss of 0.2205 psi due to +1000' density altitude change.

A turbo should be a different story, because many of them will produce more boost than the engine can use when they're operating at low density altitudes. This excess air pressure is vented via the waste gate, which would slowly close as it gains altitude, thereby maintaining the same amount of boost from sea level until the waste gate is fully closed.

Romer mentioned a higher boost noted at ~700 feet lower altitude than he normally sees at his 700' higher home altitude. That would seem to corollate pretty well with my very basic math equations. I acknowledge that I'm leaving out the variable of marginally lower pumping losses to adiabatic heating at higher altitudes due to a decreased volume of air being compressed in the same amount of compressor space, but hey, I'm just an average joe and try not to get too wrapped around the axle when I'm thinking about these things.

I'm confused as to why you're saying a forum member's supercharger would have less boost at lower altitudes, where each rotation of the supercharger's vanes compresses a greater volume of air than it does in thinner higher altitude air. A supercharger without a wastegate doesn't have any means to compensate for the drop in air pressure entering its intake, hence it should have lower boost at higher density altitudes.
 
Last edited:
The fact still remains I see more boost with the snorkel. I also have a different MAF (Scott don't touch it!). I still am pretty sure I saw more boost at lower elevations and I know my engine had more power at sea level when I went to Missouri.

I wish you would just speak english scott as you don't make the whole story the way you approach the discussion.

I will tell you at any moving speed the snorkel will provide more airflow to the supercharger than that small spot under the fender. It also provides cooler air as tests I performed using my OBD II scanner before an after in the same conditions showed an over 20 deg F drop in intake temperature. Cooler air is more dense. The combination of more dense and cooler air will provide more power in an apples to apples comparison.
 
Romer, you're an engineer, right? Do you happen to recall what the increase in air density is for each degree of temp drop? I'm curious how much boost your snorkel adds with its cooler (denser) intake air charge.
 
Romer, you're an engineer, right? Do you happen to recall what the increase in air density is for each degree of temp drop? I'm curious how much boost your snorkel adds with its cooler (denser) intake air charge.

I'm a EE who is now in management.

It's a great question though.
 
What were your actual temps before and after the snorkle? I'd prefer to know your highway cruising numbers if you have them, as it seems that driving at highway speeds up a steep road would be where most folks would need to utilize that power. In a quasi-scientific attempt at quantifying the snorkelled supercharger advantage I'll try to plug them into this density altitude calculator that I found.
 
...
A turbo should be a different story, because many of them will produce more boost than the engine can use when they're operating at low density altitudes. This excess air pressure is vented via the waste gate, which would slowly close as it gains altitude, thereby maintaining the same amount of boost from sea level until the waste gate is fully closed.

What happens to a supercharger's output of excess air? In other words, isn't critical altitude (aviation term for SC output design) and Engine VE going to change the engine performance of a fixed gear output SC? Doesn't indeed the M90 produce more air output than the engine air demand?

...
I'm confused as to why you're saying a forum member's supercharger would have less boost at lower altitudes, where each rotation of the supercharger's vanes compresses a greater volume of air than it does in thinner higher altitude air. A supercharger without a wastegate doesn't have any means to compensate for the drop in air pressure entering its intake, hence it should have lower boost at higher density altitudes.

What happens to a supercharger's output of excess air? Isn't it quite possible to see better SC engine performance at higher altitudes? I am saying that a supercharger observed and actual performance depends on a lot of VE factors. I would say that a members observed relative gauge pressure vs SC output at altitude, seem to offset enough to see no difference in observed gauge pressure. Even using your simplified example, relative gauge error would compensate for a 700ft drop in altitude from Denver to Moab. Stay at sea level, cool the intake charge with an intercooler (effectively lowering altitude), doesn't the gauge still read 6.5psi? I think you are really presenting a density ratio argument, more than a pressure ratio argument.

Scott J
94 FZJ80 Supercharged
 
What happens to a supercharger's output of excess air? In other words, isn't critical altitude (aviation term for SC output design) and Engine VE going to change the engine performance of a fixed gear output SC? Doesn't indeed the M90 produce more air output than the engine air demand?



What happens to a supercharger's output of excess air? Isn't it quite possible to see better SC engine performance at higher altitudes? I am saying that a supercharger observed and actual performance depends on a lot of VE factors. I would say that a members observed relative gauge pressure vs SC output at altitude, seem to offset enough to see no difference in observed gauge pressure. Even using your simplified example, relative gauge error would compensate for a 700ft drop in altitude from Denver to Moab. Stay at sea level, cool the intake charge with an intercooler (effectively lowering altitude), doesn't the gauge still read 6.5psi? I think you are really presenting a density ratio argument, more than a pressure ratio argument.

Scott J
94 FZJ80 Supercharged


I have no clue what you said
 
I have no clue what you said

4 points Ken
WRT your observations, I think the relative pressure gauge you have isn't accurate to absolute, only a reference unto itself. And any observed gauge difference in 700 ft of altitude change seems outside the measure ability of an aftermarket relative boost pressure gauge to me.

A SC truck with more mods should see less boost from a SC if output is simply fixed as a few here argue. I would think mods creating a higher demand for air (increasing Engine VE), should result in lower absolute manifold pressure AND higher engine output if ineed SC output is fixed.

All Pressure Ratio Equations in forced induction are corrected by a Density Ratio.

A snorkel has benefits in water crossings. A dam, scoop or other airflow directing device is better for performance. I say 'available' cool air, beats ram air over a wider operating range of an engine.


SJ
 
1. You said my gauge isn't that accurate so any delta is probably just within the tolerance of accuracy. I get that you stated that as your opinion.

2. no clue what your point is, but I don't recall anyone saying the output of a SC is fixed

3. That was suppose to make it simple? no clue what you are saying here either.
 
Back
Top Bottom