A simpler approach...
Ken
I thank you for taking the time to search out and read/copy the basics of supercharger operation. I would like to think it takes less time to do a search, than have me explain supercharger basics. That said, I thought we were beyond these basics in our discussion. Specifically, the two statements you made in conclusion of that reference are where I'm focused. I'll keep it as simple as I can.
WRT to snorkels, I personally find them to only be good for water crossings, and bad for things like ram air and effective temp drops. Short straight pipe to available cool air, and resonance tuning of the airbox will yield more benefit. The snorkel applications I've seen for the 80 is far from optimal. It has 270 degrees of bends, it's small, and it's not tapered (small inlet to larger outlet). All offsetting it's ram air 'gains'. Which means you are offsetting cold air gains by wall friction = effective pressure drop. A couple of good simple reads to help understand my point.
http://www.bmwe30.net/cgi-bin/datacgi/database.cgi?file=articles&report=view&ID=00004&Section=03
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/showthread.php?t=1129295&highlight=ram+air&forum_id=1
I did a rough calculation of a 3in diameter pipe 6 feet long at 500cfm and 270degree worth of bends, and came up with ~2psi drop (or 4in Hg) thru a snorkel of similar design. Since these snorkel designs seal the pipe to the airbox, it can't exceed 500cfm (SC air demand), so your .5psi pressure gain (1in Hg) from ram air at highway speeds is probably less.
As you can see from the articles, cooling the air has benefits, but again, to offset a 2psi drop in pressure (4in Hg) using a snorkel, it appears you need to really cool that air.

Summary: I predict better net gains in getting cold air *available* (not sealed) to the airbox using the shortest route possible. Use a snorkel only if frequently swimming with your 80.
WRT altitude changes in boost. Defining SC "makes up for loss of power a normally aspirated motor will see" is where I was focused. I think I already addressed this in my post to Karl above. What I did notice too, was a reference in the rules of NHRA regarding altitude corrections at various tracks, in the force inducted classes. They equally correct for supercharging and turbocharging. Which seems to support that the efficiencies at altitude between both types of engines are the same.

Summary: Altitude changes in forced induction engines do affect output in terms of heat (compressor efficiency and engine thermal/volumetric efficiency).
HTH and my .02 on snorkels
Scott J
94 FZJ80 Supercharged
See now that explains in a non complex way how the supercharger works
It tells me that the cooler air by using the snorkel increases power as it provides more air to mix with fuel.
It tells me that at higher altitude, the supercharger makes up for the loss of power a normally aspirated engine would see.
That wasn't quite the discussion we were doing, but in a 2 minute serach I wanted to find an example of how to explain a complex subject
Ken
I thank you for taking the time to search out and read/copy the basics of supercharger operation. I would like to think it takes less time to do a search, than have me explain supercharger basics. That said, I thought we were beyond these basics in our discussion. Specifically, the two statements you made in conclusion of that reference are where I'm focused. I'll keep it as simple as I can.
WRT to snorkels, I personally find them to only be good for water crossings, and bad for things like ram air and effective temp drops. Short straight pipe to available cool air, and resonance tuning of the airbox will yield more benefit. The snorkel applications I've seen for the 80 is far from optimal. It has 270 degrees of bends, it's small, and it's not tapered (small inlet to larger outlet). All offsetting it's ram air 'gains'. Which means you are offsetting cold air gains by wall friction = effective pressure drop. A couple of good simple reads to help understand my point.
http://www.bmwe30.net/cgi-bin/datacgi/database.cgi?file=articles&report=view&ID=00004&Section=03
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/showthread.php?t=1129295&highlight=ram+air&forum_id=1
I did a rough calculation of a 3in diameter pipe 6 feet long at 500cfm and 270degree worth of bends, and came up with ~2psi drop (or 4in Hg) thru a snorkel of similar design. Since these snorkel designs seal the pipe to the airbox, it can't exceed 500cfm (SC air demand), so your .5psi pressure gain (1in Hg) from ram air at highway speeds is probably less.
As you can see from the articles, cooling the air has benefits, but again, to offset a 2psi drop in pressure (4in Hg) using a snorkel, it appears you need to really cool that air.

Summary: I predict better net gains in getting cold air *available* (not sealed) to the airbox using the shortest route possible. Use a snorkel only if frequently swimming with your 80. WRT altitude changes in boost. Defining SC "makes up for loss of power a normally aspirated motor will see" is where I was focused. I think I already addressed this in my post to Karl above. What I did notice too, was a reference in the rules of NHRA regarding altitude corrections at various tracks, in the force inducted classes. They equally correct for supercharging and turbocharging. Which seems to support that the efficiencies at altitude between both types of engines are the same.

Summary: Altitude changes in forced induction engines do affect output in terms of heat (compressor efficiency and engine thermal/volumetric efficiency).HTH and my .02 on snorkels
Scott J
94 FZJ80 Supercharged
Last edited:



