The PTO winch that came with my FJ40 was a total workhorse. I used it to pull stumps out of the ground, move brush piles, and pull other rigs out of trouble. The times it let me down was when I was self-recover mode. I sheared the pin 3 times and was left waiting for a buddy to finish the pull.
What I really didn't like about the PTO in self-recovery mode is I couldn't use the tires to help motivate the cruiser out of the situation I was in. The tires want to run at a much greater speed then the PTO for the same gearing. For instance, as described by 65swb45, I was pulling myself up a waterfall using only the PTO. About 3/4s of the way up the shear pin popped leaving me stranded on the drop. I engaged the wheels and could climb about 6" before I would loose traction and drop back against the cable. I now have an electric winch and run the winch and tires together and am much happier with the results.
If I were mostly using the winch for work applications I would want the PTO back. I use the winch mostly for helping get myself further down the trail and for that I prefer an electric.
What I really didn't like about the PTO in self-recovery mode is I couldn't use the tires to help motivate the cruiser out of the situation I was in. The tires want to run at a much greater speed then the PTO for the same gearing. For instance, as described by 65swb45, I was pulling myself up a waterfall using only the PTO. About 3/4s of the way up the shear pin popped leaving me stranded on the drop. I engaged the wheels and could climb about 6" before I would loose traction and drop back against the cable. I now have an electric winch and run the winch and tires together and am much happier with the results.
If I were mostly using the winch for work applications I would want the PTO back. I use the winch mostly for helping get myself further down the trail and for that I prefer an electric.