Optima Batteries

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Dreamin said:
I have used both the RED tops and the YELLOW tops, I have found that the RED tops work better for day to day use as well as lot of winching abuse, therefore I only use the RED tops now.
Even Optima would disagree with your choice of the red top over the yellow top for winching.
 
I am using the blue Excide Orbital - deep cycle sealed battery as well

my conventional super duty truck battery the PO had put in (he never wheeled) lasted but one AZ wheeling summer before it puked - didn't leave me stranded, just discovered it before the next trip

[I would have bought a Yellow Optima if Checkers had had them, but it was 4:30 on a Sunday with the next autosupply store 30 minutes away - you get the idea - sparrow in hand, dove on the roof]

turns out: :bounce: the Excide is smaller than the Optima, which leaves me with the option of getting two into space (if I ever figure out a good second tray for those mounting those smaller batteries sideways :rolleyes:)
 
I picked up a 'refurbished' yellow top a couple years ago for $40. Apparently some of the local indoor go-cart places run electric carts and they run yellow top Optimas. They replace them as a matter of preventative maintenance, so there's a local parts store that gets all the ones that load test ok, and they offload them cheap.

The one I picked up looked almost new and hasn't given me a problem in almost 3 years of "daily driver & weekend wheeler/wincher" use. A few months ago, my alternator quit randomly for a while (still haven't figured that one out) and I drove on just battery for a couple weeks, throwing it on the charger overnight once a week. No problems. I'm sold on yellow tops.

I run the starter and accessories off the side terminals and the winch cables off the top terminals.
 
SizzleChest said:
so, a blue or yellow top would be fine in a daily driver with occasional winch use on the weekends?
Yes. If you do not have any drains like an alarm system, you could let it sit for 6 to 12 months and it should start right up.
 
bsevans said:
Yes. If you do not have any drains like an alarm system, you could let it sit for 6 to 12 months and it should start right up.

then why do I see so many red tops in rigs of all kinds - not just FJ and many without winches (more than any other color when I have noticed they are not using a 'regular' battery but some sort of Optima).

and, why would Costco in my area seem only to sell and always be sold out of red tops? Costco is a pretty general place not for super specific people and needs and they seem to carry the more everyday general need.... so why mostly red tops if it is more of a specific need/usage battery?
 
the deep cycle batteries spposedly recover better from strong draw, like a winch, and they are presumably better on start when you are not using the truck frequently

but I haven't done a side-by-side comparison
 
wantatlc said:
then why do I see so many red tops in rigs of all kinds - not just FJ and many without winches (more than any other color when I have noticed they are not using a 'regular' battery but some sort of Optima).

and, why would Costco in my area seem only to sell and always be sold out of red tops? Costco is a pretty general place not for super specific people and needs and they seem to carry the more everyday general need.... so why mostly red tops if it is more of a specific need/usage battery?
Just because people use them does not make them the best choice - just the least expensive choice amoung Optima batteries. There is a large step in cost from the red top to either the yellow or blue top. At the Costco here in Tucson you can get your choice of all three Optima batteries.
 
e rock said:
I picked up a 'refurbished' yellow top a couple years ago for $40. Apparently some of the local indoor go-cart places run electric carts and they run yellow top Optimas. They replace them as a matter of preventative maintenance, so there's a local parts store that gets all the ones that load test ok, and they offload them cheap.
.
hhhmmmm, i'll have to check that out if i can't ever get orbitals.

just got another "second" today for the piggie...$59 after tax.
 
FWIW, we just purchased two yellow top batteries for power to our surveillance systems in our bait cars and both were bad right off the shelf. Not a good thing for being the first time we used them.
 
bummer



but they do honor the warranty - my husband got a new one when his went bad :)
 
I run a pair of D31 optima's one yellow one blue, the blue having the extra terminals. Run both in paralel in our comp truck.

Excelent batteries, you can just see the top of the blue one in the rear the other sits opersite on the other side.


14-07-062.jpg
 
I will never buy another Optima again. I had a good redtop once, but the past 2 yellow tops were junk.

I now buy Walmart Everstarts. They kick ass in tandem in my towrig, and just put a new one in my 40.
They cost alot less too.
 
Last edited:
Not that great of reviews on my red Optimas in the '76 FJ40. Better than wet batteries for the corrosion issue.
Go with the Odyssey PC 1500.
Has mil specs
12 year shelf life
6-8 year under use life
Out here in Phx, AZ We average 2-2.5 years for a battery.
It is currently 114 F outside. This is the biggest killer of batteries in the southwest.
 
Back
Top Bottom