Let's play a game!

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
May 19, 2011
Threads
20
Messages
507
Location
Texas
It's called guess what the heck happened to my spindle and bearings (there is a joke in there somewhere).


Tearing down my front axle to fix my leaky diff and when I pull the rotors off and wipe down the spindles I see these marks. It's on both spindles in the spots where the bearings ride.

pcoLdL2h.jpg



This is what the inside of the bearings look like.


4M1OWUTh.jpg



I ran my fingernail in those areas and can't feel anything by the way.

The grease in the bearing area was also a chocolate brown whereas everything else still looks good. All of these parts including the spindles have only ~10,000 miles on them. I followed the FSM for the amount of grease to use in that area along with everything else pertaining to the front end. There has been a noise since not too long after I finished rebuilding it. It happens mainly when I let off the gas and coast from highway speeds. I figured it was my stock front drive shaft screaming in pain because of the 4" lift.


Are these barely used $500 spindles and bearing toast?
 
looks like barely enough preload, and the outter bearing just started to spin. if there is no worn area on the bottom side of the spindle, clean and run them.
 
looks like barely enough preload, and the outter bearing just started to spin. if there is no worn area on the bottom side of the spindle, clean and run them.


I feel I should mention that this side (passenger) needed the socket and a good bit of force to get the outer nut off whereas the other side just needed the socket spun by hand.


Water intrusion?

Doesn't look like it as far as I can tell.
 
Spindle bearing and the axle shaft look good by the way. Only some small marks on the axle shaft. I don't think they were there when I put this all together.

MEC2tz3.jpg



Whatever you might see where the spindle bearing rides is a reflection, it's still nice and pretty.


QPsIoyk.jpg
 
Water intrusion?
X2

Chocolate colored grease & rusty marks on parts points to at least a small amount of water getting in there.
 
Looks like galling maybe? I wouldn't use that axle any more but as with everything else, your mileage may vary...:meh:
 
X2

Chocolate colored grease & rusty marks on parts points to at least a small amount of water getting in there.

Do I need to do anything to the marks or since I can't feel them is there nothing I can do?

Looks like galling maybe? I wouldn't use that axle any more but as with everything else, your mileage may vary...:meh:

If it was galled, wouldn't I be able to feel it?


It's not even blue. Nothing to see here, carry on...

Good to go then?
 
I feel I should mention that this side (passenger) needed the socket and a good bit of force to get the outer nut off whereas the other side just needed the socket spun by hand.

Was this because I didn't set the preload properly? I did it by feel instead of with a fish scale, should I get me a fish scale this time?
 
"If it was galled, wouldn't I be able to feel it?"

Not if pieces of metal have been torn out of that circled area, no. The other possibility is that it has always been there and is a minor flaw in the original part. Either way you could still use it if that is what you want to do. I was just saying that I wouldn't, but there's plenty of folks who would.

Not very likely that your guesstimated preloading caused the problem, but it sure didn't help any. Follow the FSM and do it right, or don't and keep on doing it again and again. Your choice. I have made that mistake myself and now keep pretty close to the factory bible.

Please always bear in mind that this opinion is worth exactly what you paid for it...:meh:
 
"If it was galled, wouldn't I be able to feel it?"

Not if pieces of metal have been torn out of that circled area, no. The other possibility is that it has always been there and is a minor flaw in the original part. Either way you could still use it if that is what you want to do. I was just saying that I wouldn't, but there's plenty of folks who would.

Not very likely that your guesstimated preloading caused the problem, but it sure didn't help any. Follow the FSM and do it right, or don't and keep on doing it again and again. Your choice. I have made that mistake myself and now keep pretty close to the factory bible.

Please always bear in mind that this opinion is worth exactly what you paid for it...:meh:

Thanks :beer:
 
It was a Valvoline moly fortified grease if I remember right.

That should be good stuff based on what I found on BITOG.com

I used the red mobil 1 synthetic on my wheel bearings. I haven't pulled it down yet, so I don't know how well it's working..
 
Against my better judgment I'll be reusing the spindle and bearings. I bought a fish scale so I can set the preload properly this time. In the near future when I have $500 laying around I'll get some new ones for peace of mind. Hopefully things turn out ok. :beer:
 
I wouldn't even hesitate to use those spindles. There are no grooves, metal peeling, or heat color changes. What you are seeing is a little scuffing on the spindle from not enough preload on the bearings, and in a cornering (or other) situation, the inner races may have turned a few times. I have run spindles that had major chewing on the surface, and as long as it was still "snug" to slide on the bearing, I didn't worry about it. I have even used a center punch to dimple the outer part of a spindle so it would tighten up the bearing surface to hold things together better. You have to do the center punch thing equally, and yours is NOT be even close to being bad enough to warrant that! I grew up on a farm and we did things that we HAD to do to make them work. Some may be "back woods or hokey", but they saved a TON of money and worked OK. I'm not saying you'll get another 100K miles, but you may put off spending the extra $500 for another year or so.
 
Back
Top Bottom