This is a never ending debate. Narrow tires can be effective in certain conditions for sure. I ran some 33x10.50s (close equivalent to the 255) on my Tacoma for a couple years, before changing to 33x12.50. In my personal experience, the only advantage I had with the narrower tires was less rolling resistence that resulted in a very slight increase in fuel economy. On paper there are perceived benefits to a narrower tire. But from my personal experience in the locations I travel I had better traction, better stability with the wider tire. Snowy conditions are one area that are hotly debated between wide tires and skinny tires. Again, from my experience I traveled much farther in deep snow with wider tires than I could with the narrower ones.I think we need to mention 255/85's for the expedition rig.
Think of it like this, the Eiffel Tower has four large and very wide legs--the amount of pressure each base has on the ground is about as much as a man sitting in a chair, or 190lbs. The distribution of weight across the base is very wide. The same principles apply to tires, larger tires are typically wider and the distribution of weight becomes more evident in slippery conditions. I know, I know, skinnies are ugly and don't have the same appeal as say a Nitto or Cooper.
Skinnies are probably the least talked about; but, they are one of the most if not the best tire for a Land Cruiser, period. The amount of pressure per square inch becomes a factor in snow, ice, sleet and rain. You mentioned 90% would be on the road...you need to think of how a larger tire performs in these adverse conditions on a flat road. I'm sure 35's and 37's do great here too, but the the skinny is king.
Zona
Conditions can vary enough from location to location that could make a narrow tire a preferable choice. For me it was not. That isn't to say they are a bad choice. When I had the skinnies I didn't really have complaints, but when I switched to a wider tire the improvements were noticeable in every condition except for highway driving fuel economy. The skinnies seemed to wander a bit more on the highway however. That could be a result of the steering feel being lighter because of less rolling resistance (smaller contact patch), but in general I felt the wider tire tracked straighter.
Again, just one person's experience.
).