I did my ABS delete a little different and found no need for a proportioning valve yet with excellent results given my set up. Under wet conditions I can modulate the pedal and get my rear to lock without the front or go for the full mash and everything locks. I found much better pedal control after the delete. With that said I would not change a thing.
I have heard many say they can 'out brake' two comparable vehicles one with and one without ABS, and with many years driving cars and trucks I think there is an element of truth to this, and so would not contest your comments Phil. What I would say to you and those that have tested this system against that system etc have done it under controlled conditions. Where the ABS will beat ANYONE in a braking distance/control contest is in a real world event.
Your driving between cars down a side street and a kiddie runs out in front of you, the reality is you WILL stand on the brake pedal as hard as you can, it is reality. You will not think right I need to brake and not brake too hard in case I lock the wheels but, I am also going to be prepared to cadence brake if the wheels do lock, and of course I am ready for the back to come around as the rear wheels might lock.....THAT DOES NOT HAPPEN!
Kid runs out and you WILL slam on the brakes, the ABS is ready for that wheel lock, your LSPV is ready to reduce over braking the rear wheels depending on the amount of weight you are carrying, and the ABS will also allow you to retain some ability to steer (automatic reaction) to miss that kid.
Many many years ago I was driving a loaded van, a guy walked out in front of me on a green light, I saw him out of the corner of my eye, in one motion I braked as hard as I could and turned the steering wheel as quickly as I could to the left. The front of the van missed him and he got clipped on the side of the head by the mirror on the drivers door, and he went down, he died four days later! Despite all my years of driving I did the best I could and could do no more. I reflect on this often when I read threads like this and came to the same conclusion each time. If the van had been fitted with ABS would his life have been spared, I can only say possibly?
It's ironic that the reason this poor guy was there in the first place, was because one of his two feuding son's had just got married and he was walking between the reception and the other son's place of work, one son refused to go and 'bury the hatchet', the old boy walked out in front of me with a head full of sadness and of course he was not in a right mind to check the lights. The inquest was also horrific, standing side by side with one of his son's who I had known a number of years!
I think the distance covered between him stepping in front of me, and the distance covered bringing the van to a stop after the mirror hit his head that if ABS was fitted may, and I mean 'may' have shaved off another couple of MPH and lessened the impact but, I think where the ABS would have been a significant factor in this instance would have been my ability to steer the vehicle perhaps another few inches to the left.........or perhaps the width of the door mirror?
regards
Dave