Winch bronz gear

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Aug 26, 2017
Threads
54
Messages
555
Location
Dfw
57121AAD-F576-43F2-8610-9F4957D76FBF.webp
37657166-E767-4F00-B66B-316D68B34F56.webp
65230DF8-13FF-4E93-A076-09B28979DD34.webp
I’m hoping to get some input on the condition of the bronz gear in the winch I got. It would appear that at some point in its life it may have had the wrong gear oil in it, or maybe no gear oil in it at all, the seals are leaking like craze. I see fine bits of bronz on the gear and in the box. Given that I’ve never seen a bronze winch gear before let a lone one that is 30 plus years old I don’t know what is normal wear and tear, or one that is ready to totally fail. To me, it looks in okey shape given its age, but I have little knowledge to base that on. Any knowledge you can impart would be greatly appreciated! Ihope all have a good new year! Bill
 
IMO.......I would say it looks like it ran without lube for a bit of time. Had there been lube, many of the fine shavings I see would have been washed into the bottom of the case. If it were me, I would replace the gear before I use it again.
 
You sure it’s bronze and not steel that’s stained from old oil?

It’s not a transmission. I’d clean it out, replace seals and run it.
Given what I see, and everything I’m reading, it’s bronze. Thanks for your input!
 
IMO.......I would say it looks like it ran without lube for a bit of time. Had there been lube, many of the fine shavings I see would have been washed into the bottom of the case. If it were me, I would replace the gear before I use it again.
I think I agree with you on it running with out gear oil. I’ve ordered new seals. I’m wondering how hard it will be to find another one in better condition...only one way to find out I guess. Thanks for your input!
 
I was hoping to get a bit more input. Thanks!

We have no idea what winch you have. Could you post a photo of the whole winch, or maybe tell us the manufacturer and model name/number?
 
X2 on what @1911 said. A winch having a bronze gear is a new one on me. I understand a bronze bushing but a gear seems crazy unless it doesn't have any real load on it.
 
X2 on what @1911 said. A winch having a bronze gear is a new one on me. I understand a bronze bushing but a gear seems crazy unless it doesn't have any real load on it.
I agree that putting a bronze gear in a winch seems crazy, but I’m guessing someone smarter than me though it was a good idea. Thanks for responding!
 
We have no idea what winch you have. Could you post a photo of the whole winch, or maybe tell us the manufacturer and model name/number?
thanks for responding! I’ve posted what u asked. Hope this added information helps.
 
X2 on what @1911 said. A winch having a bronze gear is a new one on me. I understand a bronze bushing but a gear seems crazy unless it doesn't have any real load on it.

Worm Gears Explained


Metallurgy of Worm Gears
The most common worm gears are made with a brass wheel and a steel worm. This is because the brass wheel is typically easier to replace than the worm itself. The wheel is made out of brass because it is designed to be sacrificial. In the event that the two surfaces come into contact, the worm is marginally safe from wear because the wheel is softer, and therefore, most of the wear occurs on the wheel. Oil analysis reports on this type of unit almost always show some level of copper and low levels of iron - as a result of the sacrificial wheel.
 
Worm Gears Explained


Metallurgy of Worm Gears
The most common worm gears are made with a brass wheel and a steel worm. This is because the brass wheel is typically easier to replace than the worm itself. The wheel is made out of brass because it is designed to be sacrificial. In the event that the two surfaces come into contact, the worm is marginally safe from wear because the wheel is softer, and therefore, most of the wear occurs on the wheel. Oil analysis reports on this type of unit almost always show some level of copper and low levels of iron - as a result of the sacrificial wheel.
Very interesting. Thanks!
 
OK, now we’re getting somewhere. You have a PTO winch. Here is 5 pages of reading to get you started:

PTO Winch Information
Yes thanks for the link! I’ve spent quite a bit of time reading that information. What a good thread! My question however is what people think of the condition of my current bronze gear. As folks can see it differently has issues. But given age of the gear, does it have reasonable wear and tear or will it fail after a few more uses. If so, should I be looking for another used gear. ( I’m pretty sure they don’t make new). Thanks
 
Back
Top Bottom