Tricky starting issue

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Nov 10, 2008
Threads
4
Messages
30
Location
Denver, CO
I have a 96 TLC and the starter motor won't work in the morning. It starts up in the afternoon or evening with no hitches. Once started, it runs great and will continue to run and start while the engine maintains its warmth. It's been about 25-35 degrees out overnight and at first I thought I had a battery issue. The battery tests fine, holds a charge and even with a trickle charger on it over night still won't start in the morning. All my cables are tight and clean. The contacts on my starter are clean and in good shape. My alternator is functioning correctly. I've been trying to find a starter relay to test but my books (Chilton and Haynes, I know, shame on me) are oddly vague on whether or not there even is one. Has anyone else had this kind of an issue? I am tempted to just run a bypass or a larger gauge relay setup, but I'd like to not waste my money on something that can be simply fixed. There aren't that many components in the starting sequence that would be affected by a temperature shift like that, are there? Thanks in advance for any ideas.
 
Are you saying the starter does absolutely nothing when you turn the key? You hear nothing?
 
Has anyone else had this kind of an issue?

I haven't heard of a specific time-of-day issue, but starter problems are somewhat common. The starter has a solenoid built into it. The solenoid can get sticky with age, and corrosion can build up in the circuit limiting the amount of current going to the solenoid. Some people address these problems by adding a Ford (I think) starter solenoid. In my opinion, that's just doubling the amount of complication and potential problem source, but it has solved the problem for several people.

Off the top of my head, I believe the solenoid circuit goes from the battery, though the firewall on the right side, over to the ignition switch on the left side (left-hand drive models), then back out, through the neutral safety switch, then to the starter. That's a long circuit.
 
I haven't heard of a specific time-of-day issue, but starter problems are somewhat common. The starter has a solenoid built into it. The solenoid can get sticky with age, and corrosion can build up in the circuit limiting the amount of current going to the solenoid. Some people address these problems by adding a Ford (I think) starter solenoid. In my opinion, that's just doubling the amount of complication and potential problem source, but it has solved the problem for several people.

Off the top of my head, I believe the solenoid circuit goes from the battery, though the firewall on the right side, over to the ignition switch on the left side (left-hand drive models), then back out, through the neutral safety switch, then to the starter. That's a long circuit.


Thanks for the input! Is the solenoid rebuildable? And it does sound like a long circuit, but not overly complex. Maybe I can run new wire replacement for the oe wire. You say that the wire itself gets corrosion, or the components do? I don’t mind reworking the loom if it will make the difference, and I can always rebuild the starter. I just didn’t know if I was barking up the wrong tree. Definitely don’t want to make things more complicated and unreliable.
 
Pull the starter and bench test it. In the morning when you're having problems.

If you've never done it before, the procedure's in the FSM. I wouldn't go replacing wiring until I knew the starter was good.
 
I had the exact same issue, when the truck was parked outside in the below 20 degree weather. Turn the key and absolutely nothing, no click, no lights nothing. I believe it was the ignition switch. When it warmed up to 30 degrees I could walk out and the truck would start with zero issues. I bought the switch but moved and haven't been in temps that low since....
 
Maybe I can run new wire replacement for the oe wire. You say that the wire itself gets corrosion, or the components do?

Most likely, it's just a small amount of oxidation on the various terminals along the way, plus the ignition switch itself (not the lock cylinder). The first thing I'd do is use De-Oxit on all the connections and replace the starter (I like having a spare for something that can leave me stranded). Only after exhausting all options would I consider the "Ford solenoid mod", and I certainly wouldn't add another solenoid into the mix, I'd use a relay.

The solenoid plunger and contacts on the starter can be rebuilt with a kit that's around $10 from RockAuto.
 
Most likely, it's just a small amount of oxidation on the various terminals along the way, plus the ignition switch itself (not the lock cylinder). The first thing I'd do is use De-Oxit on all the connections and replace the starter (I like having a spare for something that can leave me stranded). Only after exhausting all options would I consider the "Ford solenoid mod", and I certainly wouldn't add another solenoid into the mix, I'd use a relay.

The solenoid plunger and contacts on the starter can be rebuilt with a kit that's around $10 from RockAuto.

Thanks for the advise! I’ll pull apart all the connectors and give em a good cleaning with deoxit and then see what happens this weekend.
 
Starter is going. Dealer still sells them if you want a Toyota branded part, but it still made by someone else. Easy fix. Just switch it out and be done with it.
 
Thanks for the input! Is the solenoid rebuildable? And it does sound like a long circuit, but not overly complex. Maybe I can run new wire replacement for the oe wire. You say that the wire itself gets corrosion, or the components do? I don’t mind reworking the loom if it will make the difference, and I can always rebuild the starter. I just didn’t know if I was barking up the wrong tree. Definitely don’t want to make things more complicated and unreliable.

Test the voltage at the signal lead to the starter. This will tell you if you need to address the corrosion/oxidation issues in that circuit.

The Ford solenoid is overkill for that fix. I used a Bosch relay, and have had zero starting issues since.

Your original post questioned whether Toyota installed a starter relay. They did not. Adding one is easy.
 
Here's a thread I started: 94 delayed cranking. Starter, ignition switch, or other?
I recently did the same ford solenoid on my son's 92 with 405K and now it starts perfectly every time. IMHO I believe the factory wire from the switch to the starter being over 20 years old and located in a hot engine compartment needs to be replaced with a new/bigger wire. The heat and other conditions degrade the wire enough where these no start issues are becoming more prevalent.
 
Pull the starter and bench test it. In the morning when you're having problems.

If you've never done it before, the procedure's in the FSM. I wouldn't go replacing wiring until I knew the starter was good.

^^^^^^^^^

Yes, good advice to 'bench test'. Whether installing a new starter, rebuilt solenoid or even just testing the old one for function.

Not too hard to reach the starter on our 80 series....but on my 100 series there is no way in hell I'd exchange one without first bench testing. Though most people skip this step.

 
The 200s are worse.
 
JMHO. I've rebuilt starter solenoids, banged on starters, replaced starters with no permanent fix until I added the Ford relay solenoid. If your starter is less than 3 years old, it's probably not the starter.
 
JMHO. I've rebuilt starter solenoids, banged on starters, replaced starters with no permanent fix until I added the Ford relay solenoid. If your starter is less than 3 years old, it's probably not the starter.

Agreed. And super easy to diagnose, with a voltage drop test.
 
Test the voltage at the signal lead to the starter. This will tell you if you need to address the corrosion/oxidation issues in that circuit.

The Ford solenoid is overkill for that fix. I used a Bosch relay, and have had zero starting issues since.

Your original post questioned whether Toyota installed a starter relay. They did not. Adding one is easy.

I will definitely do the testing at the signal lead. Did you use a new wiring setup when you put the Bosch relay in? And thanks for answering that part of my query!
 
Wow, a lot of opinions on this one. Really appreciate all the input. I will be tearing it down this weekend and doing the bench testing as well as voltage drops and hell, even resistance checks on the different sections of wire. Then, even if the diagnosis gives me an obvious culprit I’ll go ahead and clean and rebuild whatever I need to. I will check at the dealership and see what a new starter costs (assuming first born). Then look into making the relay setup if all else fails. But at least now I have somewhere to start. Thanks guys, will report back results.
 
You can also have a brush issue in the starter. You can rebuild the entire starter with Denso parts or buy a new starter if that is your issue. You may have other issues which have been covered already.
 
Back
Top Bottom