The Ongoing CO emissions saga.

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Mar 21, 2015
Threads
29
Messages
388
Location
Parker, CO
I have failed 3 emissions tests now, and the latest one is the most puzzling.

I failed my first test with high Nox, my level was 4.8 with the limit being 4.0

I aired the tires way up and dumped a botle of heet in the tank, on the second test I still failed but with a Nox of 4.1 this time.

I replaced my EGR modulator (which I think was fine) and went through my entire EGR system. I replaced some vacuum lines, replaced the Intake tube, cleaned the TB. I found a bottle of seafoam in my garage that I don't remember purchasing and figured what the hell, I dumped 3/4ths in the tank and the rest in the PCV line to the intake. I added another bottle of heet before the test. I had roughly 1/4th of a tank of gas.

I failed again today, with a NOx of 4.8 AND a CO of 44! My previous CO was 12, and the limit is 20.

Did the seafoam in the tank throw off my CO results? WTF???
 
Seafoam will drive your numbers up as it causes the oil and sludge buildup to come loose and burn up.

If you want to drop your numbers fix your issue causing them, i.e. replace/repair parts. If youre under the gun and need time, take it in early in the morning, get the engine good and hot, and run a 20:1 mix of denatured alcohol in the fuel tank.

This is a temp measure until you can isolate and fix the problem.
 
I have failed 3 emissions tests now, and the latest one is the most puzzling.

I failed my first test with high Nox, my level was 4.8 with the limit being 4.0

I aired the tires way up and dumped a botle of heet in the tank, on the second test I still failed but with a Nox of 4.1 this time.

I replaced my EGR modulator (which I think was fine) and went through my entire EGR system. I replaced some vacuum lines, replaced the Intake tube, cleaned the TB. I found a bottle of seafoam in my garage that I don't remember purchasing and figured what the hell, I dumped 3/4ths in the tank and the rest in the PCV line to the intake. I added another bottle of heet before the test. I had roughly 1/4th of a tank of gas.

I failed again today, with a NOx of 4.8 AND a CO of 44! My previous CO was 12, and the limit is 20.

Did the seafoam in the tank throw off my CO results? WTF???
Try looking through this thread. I have a 94 that I was having a lot of issues trying to pass colorado emissions.
'94 FZJ80 Failed Emissions
 
was the engine really warmed up well ?

takes surprisingly long
 
Try looking through this thread. I have a 94 that I was having a lot of issues trying to pass colorado emissions.
'94 FZJ80 Failed Emissions

Good stuff in there, I think I'm just going to break down and buy o2's and cats. Does anyone here know if I can legally replace my 2 in line cats with 1?
 
you can not replace two cats with one in colorado. burn out the seafoam. do a full tuneup and oil change, don't fill the tank past halfway, then dump two of the yellow bottles of heet in the tank. drive on the highway for no less than 45 minutes and put a new fuel cap on while waiting in line at aircare station. nothing quite like passing the sniffer only to fail on the cap and have to go back and do the entire nightmare test again.
 
Can a pair of cats work well for HC/CO and not NOX?

We don't test NOX here but 290k on my 94 and they are working perfectly for hydrocarbons and CO. Originally a Colorado truck, too.

2500RPM
HC(ppm) 11 (220 limit)
CO% 0.02 (1.2 limit)

690RPM
HC 6 (220)
CO 0.03 (1.2)
 
To pass Colorado emissions you most likely will have to replace the cats and have good operating O2's.
Cleaning cat and O2 might help. I cleaned my Cat's and O2's with Oxalic and Citric Acid bath. It got my cats with 400,000 mi to pass. Got my O2's to work again too.

I tried denatured alcohol with no luck. Check the O2's plug connector for corrosion.
Using additives to help past test like alcohol will raise CO. As NOx goes down CO goes up and vice versa.

As you are very close to passing you could try this. Burn out a couple tanks of gas driving around to get rid of the Seafoam.
Try to do it all hwy miles. Change your oil with G-Oil. It will lower HC (hydrocarbons -32%), CO (carbon monoxide -48%) and NOx (nitrous oxides -80% emissions. Is used 4 cycle G-Oil as I couldn't find automotive G-Oil. Got it at Lower or Home Depot.
With a couple bottles of HEAT, the acid bath and G-oil I passed the test.

THE BENEFITS
Benefits of Green Motor Oil
Effects of Green Motor Oil on the Environment (Automotive):
Green Motor Oil (G-OIL) has several advantages over crude or other oils including synthetics:


  • Ultimate Biodegradable and Renewable
  • Environmentally friendly, significant amount of ground water pollution can be controlled or eliminated
  • Low or no toxic
  • High Performance…naturally better than synthetics
  • Excellent lubricity (superior performance can be achieved by introducing Molybdenum disulfide nanospheres)
  • High flash point
  • The unsaturated fatty ester, Methyl Oleate, helps to lower the pour point.
  • Reductions in Greenhouse gas emissions
  • Provide significant reductions in HC (hydrocarbons -32%), CO (carbon monoxide -48%) and NOx (nitrous oxides -80% emissions
  • Best solution to air and water pollution
  • Can be stored anywhere
 
If you go the citric acid route, here is more info that adds to the video posted above:

http://www.subaruforester.org/vbull...rter-citric-acid-bath-p0420-91379/index2.html

"I crunched the numbers last night, and converted the 0.1M solution to a percent solution, so we can all know exactly what the exact concentration was, in the article that Zenon was referring to.
A 0.1M solution of citric acid is made by adding 19.2 grams of citric acid to a container, and then adding distilled water to the container until it reaches a liter (notice that you are not adding 19.2 grams of citric acid to a liter of distilled water - the citric acid powder takes up space, and you are just adding enough water on top of this to make the total solution volume 1 liter).
The article that Zenon referred to actually said that oxalic acid worked better than citric, though, and a solution of both of them combined worked the best of all.
To make a 0.1M solution of oxalic acid, use 9 grams of oxalic acid instead of 19.2 grams of citric acid, and just follow the directions above.
If you want to make a combined solution of both of them, just mix the above solutions together.

Here is the same thing in English units:

0.1M citric acid solution = 2.56 ounces citric acid in one gallon of total solution
0.1M oxalic acid solution = 1.20 ounces oxalic acid in one gallon of total solution

Also, oxalic acid can have some bad fumes, but I don't think that it would be that big of a deal if you do it outside like Zenon.

One last thing. The article that Zenon posted said that they had a device that re-circulated the fluid constantly through the catalytic converter, but that they kept it at 50 degrees celsius (112 degrees fahrenheit) for only 2 hours. Anyway, the oxalic acid is stronger than the citric acid, so I mentioned this so that you don't heat it up too much for too long, and let the acid eat away too much of the reactive metals in the catalytic converter."

Here is a guy doing the fix (but not really by the book):



Long drawn out video, but you get to see a damaged catalytic converter that can't be fixed with citric/oxalic acid:



PS: I have an NTK upstream O2 sensor for sale in classifieds. Brand new. I mistakenly ordered the one for a 1994. NTK is OEM for 1994 and earlier. Denso are used 1995-1997. PM me if you need it.

For Sale: - NTK 24044 O2 sensor for pre 1995
 
Last edited:
Good stuff in there, I think I'm just going to break down and buy o2's and cats. Does anyone here know if I can legally replace my 2 in line cats with 1?

Not in Colorado.

Same number of cats in relativity close to stock configuration.

Pretty sure the high flow weld on cats will fail the rolling road test also, just in case you were thinking of those.
 
Why did you air your tires way up? Do you have to put it on a dyno? I live in the SF Bay area (yes california) and all wheel drives dont go on a dyno. Just curious. I thought we had the most strict rules here.
 
Why did you air your tires way up? Do you have to put it on a dyno? I live in the SF Bay area (yes california) and all wheel drives dont go on a dyno. Just curious. I thought we had the most strict rules here.

It goes on a 4 wheel dyno. Air pressure reduces rolling resistance.
 
Make sense, didnt know you needed the dyno. Sorry i cant be of any help. Good luck.
 
Back
Top Bottom