*For Clarity*
My agitation stems not from the product, but from this post:
Different production run would make no difference waht so ever.
Our coils use the same mandrel and have to come off the mandrel within spec or they get scrapped.
We scrap at least 10% of every production run for this reason as we dont allow re tempering to change the height as that causes sag over time.
Every coil sits the same height for the same weight.
The only way it sites higher is less weight.
It is definitely not helpful in any way, other than to say "it's not the springs, end of discussion". It doesn't ask for more data, or images, or offer any direction to
@peacesells63 .
I would think that if offline discussion was going on outside of this thread that you wouldn't continue discussion here along a different path. Maybe a quick "hey, we're waiting on some measurements from this guy. We'll get this sorted" would have been better than your above post.
You stated on multiple occasions that this is the only set of coils that present this way (see below)
And that out of the thousands of coils out there, this hasnt been an issue with any others
if this one set of coils were in fact a unicorn
When I started this thread, I presented data that was
very similar to
@peacesells63 data, which is why he stated he was going to add to this thread instead. That makes this at least two recent sets that may have a problem.
I also believe there was an offer from the seller to supply 1" lower coils, but the person declined that offer.
We both declined this offer for exactly the same reason, detailed earlier in the post... In fact, I tried really hard to source a set of 50mm rears to go with the 50mm fronts. I was offering to purchase
more product. I got a one sentence re-direct to your distributor, who couldn't for some reason get any (which I already knew and had detailed in my original e-mail, hence the direct request).
@Lumpskie I appreciate where you're coming from, but I think you may have at least partially misunderstood my post. Yes, I did aggressively refute an almost ridiculous dismissal of "things that couldn't go wrong", but the intent wasn't to so much say that they had, but to bring to light the stonewalling with incomplete facts that I was seeing. I didn't want or ask for a public admission of a problem. What I was asking for was a public description (the rate curve) of what these springs were supposed to be, and I offered with that, to measure the rate on the set that I had, so we could compare.
Reading through this post from the beginning would show that nothing I said is either "baseless" or "unfounded".
As far as further contribution, prior to today, if anybody had asked for specifics, I'd have jumped back in with whatever I could provide, and I've done my best to do that whenever I feel it is beneficial to this community, however with this issue in particular, I felt that my involvement would be kinda like dogpiling the guy. I put my data in on the front side, peacesells put his in later. I didn't see any reason to re-iterate
my case, as peacesells had done it for me with a near carbon copy of what I was seeing.
As far as contribution today, the below is what I have, and will be all I'll add to this, so make of it what you will, as it's no longer worth arguing over. I'm ok with where my truck sits.
Without further ado:
15,000 miles on the springs, almost exactly, as of today
25 5/8" hub to flare now (front, didn't measure the back today)
Here's what 1014 lbs of everybody I could drag away from the loading dock at work looks like... (certified postal scale just inside the door there...)
The front dropped right at 2" (putting me at 23 5/8 hub to flare) The calipers aren't right on the line in the pic because it was a little hard to hold and photograph at the same time. This was verified with a tape on the hub/flare as well...
Here are the coils. The deads are seated hard in some places, and in others they're not, all the way up the stack.
Take what you will from this, but I personally don't see how 1000lbs added to the front of one of these trucks could be normal, nor do I think that's what
@Lumpskie has got on the front of his at his 23" (call it 23.5 for arguments sake) measurement. I don't know where the problem lies, and frankly, at this point I don't care. Like I said, I'm ok with where it's sitting. All I know, is that the springs are the only thing holding all that weight up...