Going to preface with my intentions of not trying to sound the a******.
Take that for what you will.
I'm certain what follows will be bitched about, both because length and verbiage, but understand I'm trying to assists on a few different levels with actual, factual quantifiable data, as well clear my name in no uncertain terms.
So my findings with the arms are as follows.
Your findings are subjective-translated "butt dyno".
Nothing wrong with offering an opinion, I do it all the time, but be cautious on who you call out and what you state as fact, if for no other reason than the amount of new guys that'll read a post and immediately whip out a credit card.
Not the purpose of this forum.
Because you're buddy runs a 6" Slee and his butt dynometer finds it to be as predictable as an OE 80, doesn't make it factual. The statement is contradictory to all physical laws, how they impact chassis dynamics, and also what the guy whose name is on the lift will adamantly exclaim.
First, I run them with OME shocks.
Then you've not begun to unlock the "potential" those arms or even OE arms afford.
BUT, that's ok, because if you're wheeling, or driving over speed bumps at the mall, going to blow the seals on the OMEs soon enough (unless you have installed limit straps, or some other corrective measure that doesn't allow the shocks to top out) and can get it right, then.
Think I'm wrong?
Take a few measurements:
First, measure the shock length, from pin mount surface to pin mount surface at ride height.
Second, let the axle droop to the bottom of the shock travel, measure and note.
[If you've a 5" lift, there's 1.75-2.25" of droop, based on OME L's extended lengths.]
To highlight the gains with correct travel shocks (and coils, but will come back to that):
Remove the shocks, repeat the above droop measurement. (Unnecessary......illustrative, since we know you'll rip the brake line from the frame, before the draglink and panhard will bind enough to stop it.)
Now, you've established the limitation of the extended shock length, which is painfully obvious how it effects axle droop, but more to check as to how it effects "flex".
Put one side shock on.
Stuff that side, measure the opposing.
Droop that side, measure the opposing.
This illustrates how having too short of a shock can effect the axles ability to articulate.....and how with only the axle weight, the fact that the panhard is in play, acting like a lever, when the shock is too short, puts pressure laterally on the axle, itself.
-translated-
Prolly why your axle mounts are bending. You're putting a lot of undue lateral stress on the axle housing, when it's articulated, as I noted when cycling with only the axle weight, NOT the entire weight of the front corners of the fat ass 80.
[will edit with pic that should illustrate this, along with several others illustrating the above process, taken during the 4-5 hour process of cycling the suspension, on a frame lift.]
Armed with the above data, which is all documented somewhere in an overly verbose, epically proportioned thread, already, you can conclude yourself, that the shocks (and coils, but later) are limiting the front (and rear) axles ability to move.
I do think that opposing panhard and drag links would alter this, but irrelevant to the fact that, when discussing, no mention was made and ALL were very well aware a LHD application.
I still run both the OE driveshafts...
Then you're shorting the slip yoke's contact by an 1". I don't recall what the total joint travel is, but that's bound to be a decrease of 25-33%.
You also reported that you swapped the front phase and this eliminated driveline vibrations, which I do believe it can.....for a little while.
Your reports that pinion angles are within X degrees of similarly lifted kinda have me thinking you may not understand what needs to be measured, because it's only the correlation between your two output flanges and your driveshaft that matter.
SO:
First, take driveshaft off and measure from between the bottom, center, and top of flanges. (This should be done at several positions of the axle, typically, but the 80 isn't capable of overextension/compression of the driveshaft, so not necessary. You'll need these dimensions to order driveshaft from Jesse, so hot them down.....or just buy mine and call it good.)
So, take digital angle finder and assess the difference between your two output flange faces, you'll see why altering phase is a temporary fix [that may have pushed the out of round rotation to the TC output flange, which will inevitably force seal failure, then bearing, then the aluminum itself].
The difference between the two precludes usage of a conventionally jointed driveshaft, that can only function in a circular motion when the two faces are the same angle off the driveline angle.
(Back with pics)
For instance, Toyota set the front up in a broke back configuration, showing the flanges do not have to be parallel, but have to be the same angle from the driveshaft angle.
Your measurements will also show that a double cardan shaft won't spin circularly, since that requires a 0 degree difference between the front output flange and the TC's.
-translated-
Front diff has to point at the TC flange, I think, within 1 degree of accuracy for a double cardan shaft to function.
Here's what I experienced and when I use the subjective term "vibrate" I don't mean like one with a couple of watch batteries, I'm talking like a Sybian.
Had the OE front driveshaft installed and I crunched the slip yoke, because the front sway bar (that I was told I could run) contacted the driveshaft, enough that I couldn't (6', 220lbs) compress nor extend.
It did NOT vibrate, but it was also under pressure that inevitably would pose a big issue, like pushing the TC flange into the housing.
I borrowed a 16 year old double cardan shaft (one of the first distributed by Slee) and it DID NOT vibrate, but it was tired and too short, by 1-1.25".
So, swapped with a freshly built double cardan shaft and it vibrated so much it could be felt in the steering wheel.
That's when the discussion began and when determined the angles were too far off to allow anything but a double, double cardan shaft to maintain a circular path, because it's kinda like a wet noodle, with no given flange face effecting its rotation.
The numbers don't lie.
If yours doesn't vibrate, great. More power to you and I'm being sincere, but it's because of other contributing factors, ie bearing wear, driveshaft wear, and so forth.
Everything on mine was brand new, so if there was to be a caveat from the manufacturer that one could only use on a RHD vehicle that the joints/bearings has a few miles on it, then I'd bear responsibility, but that was never uttered.
Second, the flex they offer is much easier than most other radius-arm setups on other Cruisers out there.
Most other would insinuate multiple.
I know of one other that still produces and he didn't tell me what I wanted to hear, so, due to lack of options, the SEs were the only choice.
Bracket binding is when the arms touch the brackets they're mounted to on the axle, stopping their side to side movement and slowing the suspension's ability to easily move through its entire range of motion.
Rubber bushings have misalignment characteristics very similar to a heim, except they lack the ability to stop themselves from exceeding beyond it.
The bracket binding on the arm is about all that can prevent from the bushing from fatiguing prematurely, by disallowing continual, excessive punishment, and that was (edited: probably) calculated into Mr Ts equation when he designed the arm thickness, mounts, bushings and so forth.
Granted, we want to push past the OE abilities, but there are instances where that simply isn't possible with OE parts, since even Mr. T's bad ass bushings will fail prematurely....and they're the best out there.
Previously stated why there may be limitations on your axles ability to articulate, which may offset whatever perceived limitation of the bushings.....so think you'd create an ongoing maintenance issue by altering the arms thickness and have other means to open up the front end, without modifying.
The bracket bending is because of a lateral force pushing against it, so increasing the distance the lateral force CAN leverage itself against, isn't going to stop it.
Take that for what it's worth.
This is something I plan to address by narrowing the arms slightly and having my bushings narrowed on a lathe when I get around to finally replacing them.
Say this were advisable and were to produce the baddest assed 80 ever, it'd be worth considering replacing the axle mounts with heavier steel and simultaneously reinforcing, instead of altering the arm thickness.
Two cents that can be tossed in the gutter, but a thought.
This solution has proven hugely successful on other rigs in AZ that I wheel with, so I'm looking forward to this and seeing what it does, if anything, to help.
Again, if you'll check the above, you can eliminate a lot of unnecessary work for a marginal gain in articulation......I'll stay away from my observation that the front's ability to articulate is a marginal gain, in the wheeling reality, since it's better to push than pull and a wheel on the ground serves little purpose if it's no downforce from corner.
I was made well aware of the fact that the pinion angles would be completely wrong and that the only way to properly fix it would be to cut and turn the axle....
You weren't listening to what I was saying, which I agree was a lot, but wanted to make damn sure you were fully aware of all aspects.
Cut and turn is for caster correction.
Rotating the axle housing would've been what I said, if doing it right, without the $1,300.00 bandaid front driveshaft.
I'm sure I can find transcripts, but with no uncertainty am I clarifying that I never said C&T corrected pinion angle.
To my surprise, the wobbling went almost completely away.
It either does or it doesn't, but it'll kinda sorta mebbe worsen.
I was in disbelief after all I had heard
Because it's what you wanted to believe.
Not knocking. I heard what I wanted to hear when sourcing, against the sound advice from numerous old hats to the 80, but I admit it and paid a hefty price to prove them right.
This slight vibration and occasional "grr" would concern me, but one of the rigs has been running it this way for about ten years and no buses full of nuns have perished yet.
Is the busload of nuns the barometer of success or fail?
For the record, it wasn't mine.
I knew I had failed early on with the TOTAL SUSPENSION, but even then, didn't grasp the ramifications.
Again, I'm sure Delancy will definitely point out that I am hugely wrong, but the guys I hang out with, who have ridden in my rig since I put the arms on, have said I should not worry. I'm not trying to offend him or anyone here, but I trust and value their opinions and I'm confident that, as with anything else on the rig, maintenance and inspection from time to time will help me keep an eye on it.
Listen, man, I'm happy for you.
I was very concerned about selling any of the parts, but you've eased that since you're overjoyed.
Here's what you're missing, stated reluctantly, because I know misinterpretation will be possible:
I didn't set out to build a marginal 80...
Planned for a year, while searching for the right candidate, all the while knowing that it would be an extensive mechanical restoration, guaranteeing my lifetime of use, to the nth degree, as well this tag line that can still be found on posts from many years ago, was constantly used with each and every vendor or guru with which it was discussed.
"not only do I want to wheel all day, then safely drive home at 75mph, I want my wife to be able to do the same."
Anyone worth their salt told be it wasn't possible, but proceeded to believe what I wanted to, and invested a lot of money, and I mean A LOT of money, to have failed miserably, because I didn't listen except to those that told me what I wanted to hear, regarding suspension.
If I opine the arms offer no ROI, I'm saying it based on a lot of factors that I don't think you understand, the reason why I even went that far with it.
I'm not attacking credibility, but a lot can be inferred from this post, which I still don't understand unless you've a group buy on the horizon:
For what it's worth, I run Delancy's SE arms and I have experienced NONE of the issues he continually states.
That you've since either agreed that the issues exists, or almost kinda but not really don't know if others may or may not.
There's no disputing the following:
They DO NOT correct pinion angle.
They DO NOT correct caster.
Which are the two items that I've discussed when addressing the inherent deficiencies.
For those saying that I should express concern over even the slightest vibes or noises, I would refer to what several of my buddies have said.
That doesn't justify saying you have no issues with the arms, it means you have agreed to disregard them.
That's fine, I don't give a s***, and more power to you and yours.
It still doesn't change the facts.
here's a quote from Beno (altered slightly for relevance in this thread),
I can bet it was on a thread about flex, three link, long arms, or any number of those discussing the deficiencies of the OE radius arms.
Having eaten crow at beno's table more than once, I now completely understand and agree with his "embrace her for what she is and don't try to make her something she's not" sentiment.
That said, have you seen beno's 80?
Might want to consider the source...
(Edits to follow. Concerned the efforts will be lost on iPhone)