stock roll bar wall thickness

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Apr 1, 2004
Threads
253
Messages
3,644
Location
Boise, Id
I've searched...

Everything I read is along the lines of 'it's not much' I'd like to know exactly what it is. I did find that it is 1.910 inches in O.D. I'd like to calculate an equivalent standard size tube, but need the wall thickness of the stock bar. So, if anyone has taken some calipers to one please post up the thickness.

Thanks,

Dan
 
Owyhee Jackass said:
I've searched...

Everything I read is along the lines of 'it's not much' I'd like to know exactly what it is. I did find that it is 1.910 inches in O.D. I'd like to calculate an equivalent standard size tube, but need the wall thickness of the stock bar. So, if anyone has taken some calipers to one please post up the thickness.

Thanks,

Dan
Why?

The stock bar is scary thin, I literaly touched it with the angle grinder and made a hole.

Maybe a better approach would be to calculate how much force you want the roll bar to take then size the stock accordingly?
 
Build a replacement out of 2" x .120 wall tube..

Teh stock bar is like .080 thickness.. Way to thin to keep you alive..
 
rusty_tlc said:
Why?

The stock bar is scary thin, I literaly touched it with the angle grinder and made a hole.



No s***.... X2!!!



I thought that Mark at Metal Tech had posted up that it was .075" or something like that....



It serves a decorative purpose at best, is garbage metal and beyond a piss-poor design for functionality in the event that it needs to protect the occupants in the event of a rollover.



What are you looking at doing?
 
rusty_tlc said:
Why?

The stock bar is scary thin, I literaly touched it with the angle grinder and made a hole.

Maybe a better approach would be to calculate how much force you want the roll bar to take then size the stock accordingly?

I just want to calculate the moment of inertia and compare it to other sections.
 
Engineers :rolleyes:
 
Owyhee Jackass said:
I just want to calculate the moment of inertia and compare it to other sections.



Practical application and real-world experience has shown them to fold up like the tin foil junk they are on more than a few occasions.....



Good luck!


-Steve
 
Mace said:
Engineers :rolleyes:

Yep.

I'm not building this to withstand multiple rolls e.g. rock buggy. I just want to walk away. I have limited space as I'm trying to fit this inside a stock FJ45 cab. Thanks for the info.

BTW race car specs for roll cages on a car over 2500 pounds are DOM SAE 1020 1.5 O.D. .120 wall which has a moment of .1248 in^4

The stock bar, if it is 1.91 od and .072 and assuming it's made out of similar material (big assumption) has a moment of .1758 in^4

So in this case the stock bar is theoretically stronger. 2 inch od .120 wall has a moment of .3144 in^4, almost twice as strong yet...

I haven't found any specs for cages on a rock-crawler to compare to.
 
Owyhee Jackass said:
Yep.

I'm not building this to withstand multiple rolls e.g. rock buggy. I just want to walk away. I have limited space as I'm trying to fit this inside a stock FJ45 cab. Thanks for the info.

.

A cage inside a 45?

We can all dream!;p

Of course I've wondered about one too Dan. Looked at the one Jim Sickles fabbed up for his 45. Of course you've got squat for leg room, squat for head room and squat for seat adjustment to start with.:doh:

I've concluded that a rollbar anchored to the frame in the bed is prolly gonna be the best solution for me. Look to see some vertical bars coming down off the front of the bed bar in the near future.;)
 
Inside the truck? do a 1.5 OD .120 cage out of chromoly. Then make sure you build it right.

The most important thing about roll cages is the design, Material is secondary..
With stronger materials (chromo) you can underbuild a cage and still have it be strong. Most race cars are built with Chromo..

Using the justification of "I am not building it to survive consectuive rolls" is really a poor idea. Build it as strong as you possibly can with the requirements that you have set forth. Do not underbuild on purpose..
 
You might want to check w/ ec4wda. They used to publish a very detailed book on their safety requirements.
 
Mace said:
Inside the truck? do a 1.5 OD .120 cage out of chromoly. Then make sure you build it right.

The most important thing about roll cages is the design, Material is secondary..
With stronger materials (chromo) you can underbuild a cage and still have it be strong. Most race cars are built with Chromo..

Using the justification of "I am not building it to survive consectuive rolls" is really a poor idea. Build it as strong as you possibly can with the requirements that you have set forth. Do not underbuild on purpose..
x2
Twice I've been in rollovers, both times the rig rolled more than one revolution.

Also consider that buggies roll at low speed, which means much less inertia. If you are looking for protection in a DD you would want to think about a highway speed rollover. IMHO for the casual offroader a highway rollover is much more likely than one on the trail.
 
Mace said:
Build a replacement out of 2" x .120 wall tube..

Teh stock bar is like .080 thickness.. Way to thin to keep you alive..


I have a stock roll bar in my 74 fj40 ....i was driving back from maine when i hit a truck rim and tire that somebdy left in the middle of the highway at night. it smapped my front drivers spring pin and started fishtailing...at 65 mph my rig flipped over in the air landed and rolled several times and came to a rest upside down. I walked (Crawled) out of it without a scratch...no broken bown not even a small cut. I have all the faith in the word that a stock bar is more then enough to keep you alive. front roll bar to the front floor would have made it less scarry. :)
 
JohnnyC said:
I have a stock roll bar in my 74 fj40 ....i was driving back from maine when i hit a truck rim and tire that somebdy left in the middle of the highway at night. it smapped my front drivers spring pin and started fishtailing...at 65 mph my rig flipped over in the air landed and rolled several times and came to a rest upside down. I walked (Crawled) out of it without a scratch...no broken bown not even a small cut. I have all the faith in the word that a stock bar is more then enough to keep you alive. front roll bar to the front floor would have made it less scarry. :)



Was the hard top on the truck?
 
JohnnyC said:
I have a stock roll bar in my 74 fj40 ....i was driving back from maine when i hit a truck rim and tire that somebdy left in the middle of the highway at night. it smapped my front drivers spring pin and started fishtailing...at 65 mph my rig flipped over in the air landed and rolled several times and came to a rest upside down. I walked (Crawled) out of it without a scratch...no broken bown not even a small cut. I have all the faith in the word that a stock bar is more then enough to keep you alive. front roll bar to the front floor would have made it less scarry. :)
You got lucky...


where is that pic from the roll in Texas?
 
Mace said:
Inside the truck? do a 1.5 OD .120 cage out of chromoly. Then make sure you build it right.

Yes, inside. Currently, with the top off, I've got the stock headache rack and the windshield frame for protection. And that is just when I have the windshield up, I usually fold it down.

I'd love to just buy a Metaltech cage and be done with it, but that's not an option. The only 45's I've seen with cages in them are very customized.

I'm using SAE 1020 DOM 1.5 od .120 wall. $3.42/foot. I'll get a quote on chromoly and compare.

I'll be adding 4 bows to the bed, removing the headache rack too.
 
attachment.php



attachment.php
 
Back
Top Bottom