Rcvs or longs

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Feb 7, 2009
Threads
31
Messages
3,303
Like title says which if you have experience, main thing turns me off is if longs are China now, I'd prefer to support rcv then. Any info on who making the longs as in China?
 
Longfield is owned by trail gear now. Has been for a while while RCV is the company who made the original longfield axles.
 
Yup I know that and internals metal are different on both, I don't know anyone who has blown a rcv or long from trail gear either, I'm under impression longs are made in China by China metal? Rcvs merica, both gun drilled so the only difference I know of is merica and possibly China, and rcv stronger internals
 
How much more are RCVs? I'd go RCVs all day long over trail gear chromos if the price was similar. Not sure what RCV options there are for the 80 but some RCVs come in either chromo or 300m ($$$). If the RCVs are chromo and $$$ I'd consider the TGs hard.
 
what makes the rcv's internals stronger? both spec out 4340 steel. we can get into the china vs 'merica debate, but there is little evidence that one is actually stronger than the other. to me, it boils down to what you value more - money or american made (but wouldn't it be funny if they were sourcing chinese steel?). That's not to knock anyone, we're free to do what we want....this is 'merica after all.

The longs are about $200 less and come with tone rings & dust caps (looking at 30 spline options).
 
I opted for the Nitro Axle birfs, made by RCV. They are built to Nitro's specs, with a harder inner race for full time 4wd longevity. I've heard horror stories of folks running RCV's, Longfields, other chromo's and having them click and chatter in less than 20k miles. The Nitro's are supposed to be longer wearing.
So far, they are amazing!! But.....its only been a couple weeks and a couple semi aggressive off road runs. But not having the front axle chatter around corners or make that Gawdawful noise when locked is worth it!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
I run RCV front axles in my 80 and I broke my ring gear before the axle shafts or birfs. I think they are a very strong well made product. As heavy as the 80 is I wouldn't gamble with the trail gear longs. I did opt for trail gear longs in my 1st gen 4runner but haven't done anything crazy yet so I can't speak to their quality.
 
I went with RCV. Only drawback was that I did the PT kit at the same time, and that is one heck of a long cut on the chopsaw to take off the outer groove (since I went with Aisin hubs and not the lesser ones avail with the kit). On the other hand, you get a cool chunk of splined chromo to put on your keychain! Many moons ago, I put the original Longs in my pickup, back when they were made in house by Bobby Long before he passed away. Didn't know they're now made in China, so I'd support the home turf for this. I've had mine in about a year, not much hard wheeling as I'm still down from a bad accident, but I haven't had a single problem. Are you running a PT (part time) kit?
 
Trail fear are $680 the RCV's are $830....

The RCV's are 4340 outers with 300M stars, the trailgears are 4340 complete. You can also get the RCV's with complete 300M inner shafts. Not really sure why you need an ABS tone ring, it's not a wear item.

Yeah why keep our money in America when we can send it to China. :rolleyes:

You seem to always be chasing the cheapest price. Seems awfully counterproductive in such a small community where you only have so many real innovators. Without those innovators (in this case Bobby Long and RCV) you wouldn't even have a trailgear option. So yes it is 'merica but more importantly it's the people that support the community through innovation that should help you realize unassing your wallet to support them is a good idea in the long run.....


what makes the rcv's internals stronger? both spec out 4340 steel. we can get into the china vs 'merica debate, but there is little evidence that one is actually stronger than the other. to me, it boils down to what you value more - money or american made (but wouldn't it be funny if they were sourcing chinese steel?). That's not to knock anyone, we're free to do what we want....this is 'merica after all.

The longs are about $200 less and come with tone rings & dust caps (looking at 30 spline options).
 
Last edited:
Not all 4340 is heat treated the same and frankly there can be large differences between similarly specd materials. 4130 chromoly is very different from 4340 so not all chromoly steels can even be compared.

Make your choice based on whether you think one product is superior or not.

That said, i am not a materials engineer but have a graduate degree in economics and i can tell you with confidence that fear about "sending dollars to china" is unfounded, especially in light of a fiat currency (paper money.) Mercantilism as a legitimate school of economic thought died in the 1700s but persists thanks to lobbying by unions and entrenched industries who wish to benefit at everyone elses expense. The us steel industry is notoriously bad at inefficiently keeping jobs in the US - often quoted at over $500,000 per worker:

http://www.investors.com/politics/o...-the-unseen-cost-of-saving-jobs-with-tariffs/
 
I went with the rcv because I think they are Better. so far so good
 
Going rcv and how am I chasing the price, I can get the rcv for 700ish thanks for the info everyone
 
good price paid 900 for mine a few months ago.
 
Rcv. I went with them due to quality, and they are local for me. It's a 90 minute drive if I ever need a rebuild or warranty work.
 
For me I narrowed it down to RCVs and Nitro chromos. I did my shopping with CruiserOutfitters and have been very pleased. A good Jeeper buddy (yes, they exist) spent a day with me installing them. The two biggest PITAs were removing the ABS sensors from the Birfs (use a big press) and compressing the snap ring to connect the axle shafts to the Birfs.

From what I've "heard", you'll never regret going with RCVs. They were just about $200 more than my Nitro setup and the Nitro has grease fittings like the RCVs.
 
Trail fear are $680 the RCV's are $830....

The RCV's are 4340 outers with 300M stars, the trailgears are 4340 complete. You can also get the RCV's with complete 300M inner shafts. Not really sure why you need an ABS tone ring, it's not a wear item.

Yeah why keep our money in America when we can send it to China. :rolleyes:

You seem to always be chasing the cheapest price. Seems awfully counterproductive in such a small community where you only have so many real innovators. Without those innovators (in this case Bobby Long and RCV) you wouldn't even have a trailgear option. So yes it is 'merica but more importantly it's the people that support the community through innovation that should help you realize unassing your wallet to support them is a good idea in the long run.....

IF RCV's have 300M stars, they're missing it from their website. Or I just missed it, which is completely possible. But, even if it is 300M, I fail to see the advantage. Granted, I haven't fully studied out the complete specs on 300M....just browsed. And yes, part of my joe job is dealing with steel, so I know there is one person out there who thinks I know what I am doing.

At the end of the day, unless we pull mill certs from either of these companies, there is no real way to know which is "better," if either has a leg up at all. The standard is there, the question is, are they sourcing steel which meets the standard?

As far as the accusation of me always chasing the lowest price, I get that you may think that is the case. But trust me, it is far from the truth. My wife still hasn't found out about the $1350 radiator I just bought. 4x4 labs bumper, slee bumper, gull wing GLASS windows, magnum air compressor (is this the only place where you can buy cheap china and not get harassed on ih8mud?). I could go on. When I shop, I have my set of criteria which I am looking to meet, and when I stop realizing value, I stop spending money. I apologize if what I value doesn't align with what you value.

Finally, just because someone invents something, doesn't mean it is needed by me, or even the greater "Community." Case in point, the $70k 1FZFE. Shouldn't you be supporting those guys....a turn key turbo kit may be born out of it?

So, if I were to buy aftermarket axles today, I can say RCV wouldn't get my money. And maybe that makes me a bad guy?
 
Seems awfully counterproductive in such a small community where you only have so many real innovators.

The aftermarket world for FJ80 parts has been stagnant for years. Who is out there innovating and making parts for the FJ80? I'm talking real parts, not beauty accessories and roof racks. At least the scummy Chinese companies are giving people options.
 
If someone bought a Slee bumper and 4x4 Labs bumper and sent them to China to be reproduced, would you buy them?

Not saying you're a bad guy, but someone designed, prototyped, spent their time and money bringing them to market, I guess I just feel like it's important to support that. I think it's fine if a company like Trailgear, brings their own tube bumpers, sliders, etc to market but it really rubs me the wrong way when it's literally a reproduction of someone else's product.

Maybe I am the one that has it twisted and there could be a bunch of cheap parts for 80's if I just started buying copies, but I guess I know Christo, and Bobby Long, Beno, I haven't met Luke from 4x4 Labs but I am sure he is a great guy and I will continue to support them and the others with my wallet.


IF RCV's have 300M stars, they're missing it from their website. Or I just missed it, which is completely possible. But, even if it is 300M, I fail to see the advantage. Granted, I haven't fully studied out the complete specs on 300M....just browsed. And yes, part of my joe job is dealing with steel, so I know there is one person out there who thinks I know what I am doing.

At the end of the day, unless we pull mill certs from either of these companies, there is no real way to know which is "better," if either has a leg up at all. The standard is there, the question is, are they sourcing steel which meets the standard?

As far as the accusation of me always chasing the lowest price, I get that you may think that is the case. But trust me, it is far from the truth. My wife still hasn't found out about the $1350 radiator I just bought. 4x4 labs bumper, slee bumper, gull wing GLASS windows, magnum air compressor (is this the only place where you can buy cheap china and not get harassed on ih8mud?). I could go on. When I shop, I have my set of criteria which I am looking to meet, and when I stop realizing value, I stop spending money. I apologize if what I value doesn't align with what you value.

Finally, just because someone invents something, doesn't mean it is needed by me, or even the greater "Community." Case in point, the $70k 1FZFE. Shouldn't you be supporting those guys....a turn key turbo kit may be born out of it?

So, if I were to buy aftermarket axles today, I can say RCV wouldn't get my money. And maybe that makes me a bad guy?
 
Last edited:
Just to clarify for my sake. Long sold out and whomever bought them must of forgot a non compete in the sale?

An important point, as tg isnt "knocking off" if the above is true.
 
Back
Top Bottom