Overheating woes - fan conversion?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Feb 1, 2021
Threads
17
Messages
196
Location
Massachusetts
Hi All,

I am currently running into an overheating issue. I'm about to swap out my aftermarket water pump for an OEM water pump. I currently also run an electric fan because I couldn't find a water pump with oil cooler and with a fan clutch, as what was originally installed. The question is, can I install a direct drive fan and use the OEM shroud, instead of a clutched fan? Has anyone else done that and able to comment?

Additionally, I am planning to swap out my radiator for a new CSF 2888 4 row from rockauto. I considered OEM, but the comments about them arriving damaged >20% of the time deterred me (city racer is out of stock). Am I making a mistake? Anyone else running the CSF 2888?

Thank you!!
 
Oem ordered at a dealer...if it shows up damaged, don't take it.
Delete the oil cooler, there no pros or cons to either keeping it or deleting it.
 
Has anyone else done that and able to comment?
I've done most of what you're trying to do.
For the correct waterpump call @cruiseroutfit. You CAN run a direct drive fan in place of the clutched fan; you need to swap the flange on the waterpump shaft and add a spacer between the flange and the fan. I do this because there isn't room for a fanclutch on my 55.
Can you get your current radiator re-cored? I've tried 4-row cores and 3-row cores in my radiator. The tubes and fins on the 4-row were thin and fragile compared to the 3-row core. I like the 3-row cores better.
 
Last edited:
For the correct waterpump call @cruiseroutfit. You CAN run a direct drive fan in place of the clutched fan; you need to swap the flange on the waterpump flange and add a spacer between the flange and the fan.
Thank you pighead! I purchased the Aisin water pump with cooler and without clutch from city racer - can I purchase the spacer and flange from @cruiseroutfit? Is this the spacer?

Can you get your current radiator re-cored? I've tried 4-row cores and 3-row cores in my radiator. The tubes and fins on the 4-row were thin and fragile compared to the 3-row core. I like the 3-row cores better.
I actually don't have a leak in my radiator, I'm just having such a hard time keeping my engine cooled, and I had read that the 4 row was a must.

I do have an old downey header installed, which I have heard can cause heat issues.
 
Thank you pighead! I purchased the Aisin water pump with cooler and without clutch from city racer - can I purchase the spacer and flange from @cruiseroutfit? Is this the spacer?


I actually don't have a leak in my radiator, I'm just having such a hard time keeping my engine cooled, and I had read that the 4 row was a must.

I do have an old downey header installed, which I have heard can cause heat issues.
If you have the waterpump made for the direct drive fan, just bolt the direct drive fan to it (the direct drivefan is different from the clutched fan). Yes, that's the spacer. Now, my engine was originally a Late F with the direct drive fan, so when I swapped in the 2F block I had all the correct pieces and parts to get the pulleys to line up pretty well. That part is not always easy.
If your only symptom is a too warm engine, maybe a simple rod-out of your current radiator is all you need. It used to be considered routine maintenance...
I run that same header, it's not the problem.
 
Do you run a bug screen in front of your radiator? It will prevent the bugs from clogging up the air passages in the fins. Go to car wash. Soak the radiator with like 409 from both sides. Then take the wand and power wash the fins from the engine side first trying to back wash all the trash out the front. Then power wash from the front. Install a bug screen.

What thermostat are you running? 160 in mine. I run a curtain 1/2 way up from the bottom in front of the radiator in the winter so it will warm up and run 1/2 on the gauge.
 

This what I installed on my 1968 F with the Vintage Air AC. I’m pretty sure it’s an FJ60 water pump. The kit comes with pump, pullies, clutch, fan….pretty complete. I had to get a different fan shroud, I think from a 76, and still use a 3 row radiator.
The assembly works very well in 100 degree weather, with engine temperatures just over 200 degrees on those hot hot days.
 
If you have the waterpump made for the direct drive fan, just bolt the direct drive fan to it (the direct drivefan is different from the clutched fan). Yes, that's the spacer. Now, my engine was originally a Late F with the direct drive fan, so when I swapped in the 2F block I had all the correct pieces and parts to get the pulleys to line up pretty well. That part is not always easy.
Ah ok I understand. So I would just simply add the spacer and bolt the fan - I see what you mean regarding all the correct pieces. Looks like there are a lot of variations of the fan. That should put the fan inside the stock shroud correctly? I assume that is why we need the spacer.
If your only symptom is a too warm engine, maybe a simple rod-out of your current radiator is all you need. It used to be considered routine maintenance...
I run that same header, it's not the problem.
Great callout. I'll look into this.

What thermostat are you running? 160 in mine. I run a curtain 1/2 way up from the bottom in front of the radiator in the winter so it will warm up and run 1/2 on the gauge.
I'm running an OEM Aisin 180F THM004.


This what I installed on my 1968 F with the Vintage Air AC. I’m pretty sure it’s an FJ60 water pump. The kit comes with pump, pullies, clutch, fan….pretty complete. I had to get a different fan shroud, I think from a 76, and still use a 3 row radiator.
Very interesting - I have a 77, I wonder if my shroud would work. It is w/o oilcooler, which would mean I would also have to change the upper thermostat housing and block off the oil cooler... which I was trying to avoid as it continues to add cost.
 
What electric fan do you have?

Pic?

Quite a few guys ditch them as they just don’t cut it … mounted too close and not correctly shrouded to pull air all the way around

Going to any oem fan setup with matching shroud will correct your overheat issue imho

Btw where in mass are you? … I’m just over boarder in ny
 
I can't remember the make of the fan anymore - here is a photo
1788112303566.webp


I'm right on the border - not too far from New Lebanon NY. Back and forth between here and Boston.
 
Shift to a mechanical fan. Not sure how hot it gets in Mass. Never had luck with electric fans in TX. Also that shroud is not optimum. The fan is only pulling from the cross section of the fan. The rest of the shroud is too close to the radiator. The louvers on the shroud counter act any suction you want to achieve.
 
Ok - making the switch for sure based on all these comments. Plan to use my water pump w/ oil cooler without the fan clutch - direct drive fan. This spacer and this fan to bolt up to the water pump I ordered. I'll start there and see if I still overheat. Then look to swap out the radiator.
 
I agree that it’s too restrictive … your on the right path :)

Don’t forget fan shroud … I think u said you had one… the solid fans had a lil different of a shroud than the later … I think you’ll need the earlier … not a 100% on that been sometime

I am not far from you … just west of new Lebanon in schodack/east greenbush

So in Adam’s area?

Tyke moses has used parts near you if your in a pinch … he’s in north pownal vt
 
I think by going with an electric fan, you created your cooling problem. The closer to stock the better you'll likely be.
 
Then look to swap out the radiator.
You're still running your original radiator? that doesn't leak? Take it to the best/oldest radiator shop in your town and talk to them. Old radiators can be made good as new. You don't need 4 cores, 3 is plenty. There is zero chance it will be damaged when you pick it up, it will be perfect and painted gloss black. You know it'll fit back in, and sometimes it's worthwhile to have a good working relationship with a radiator shop
 
I don't know that it is the original - this was a farm truck for most of its life. My brother thinks that he re-cored it in early 2000's. Either way, I'll see about taking it to a shop. No leaks that I have noticed!
 
When I had a 2F or 155F later there lives I was also having cooling issues, I should have flushed the fins in the radiator. Now I have a R2.8 that was set up for an electric fan but with advise here I installed a mechanical fan and a 4 core radiator. I have as yet had the chance to test to see if I have enough cooling.
 
x2 on the mechanical fan and early shroud to fit. A reverse flush often does wonders if you can track down or make/buy one, and another issue can be if a radiator stop leak additive has been used. My theory is if one of the type that set when exposed to air is used it probably works initially but if the system is drained afterwards you end up with white scale on the inside of your radiator, I have an 80 I ended up replacing the radiator on and the inside of the old one had a coating of something.
CLR might work

XJ8 COOLING SYSTEM FLUSHING AND REFILLING Tool makeup.webp
 
Back
Top Bottom