First post... Fan into radiator

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
May 22, 2018
Threads
6
Messages
38
Location
SWMO
So, my first real trip started late yesterday and ended (conveniently) in a riverside campground after putting my fan into a brand new radiator and puncturing it.

Anyone had this issue? Happened in 4-Lo during an off camber area of trail. Bottom fins of the radiator.

Mounts all “look” to be in good shape, fan clutch is the blue one and functions properly. I’m going to get rid of the clutch and go auxiliary to prevent this from happening again. However I’m curious if anyone has run into this issue, especially under heavy load? Possibly an incorrect radiator? P/O put it in so I guess it’s possible?

Thankfully we had tow straps and had not gotten too far out. It was also a badass spot to camp. Got a big trip planned in October so i guess better now than later.
 
First guess is motor mounts. Second guess is loose mounting bolts on the radiator. Best guess is the shroud was not properly fit at the bottom corners of the radiator. As rpm/load increases the fan blades bend forward, if the shroud is loose at the bottom, it draws rearward, contacting the fan blades and steering them into the bottom area of radiator. I remember someone doing that in Arch Canyon a few years ago. Nothing wrong with motor mounts or fan/clutch. All due to loose shroud at the bottom. Been done multiple times. Some inexpensive radiators have poorly shaped pockets for the tabs on the bottom of the shroud. Gotta work at it to get both corners securely anchored. ALLWAYS check this whenever shroud is removed on ANY brand of radiator.
 
How much do you retard the cooling capabilities if you run with the shroud off?
 
How much do you retard the cooling capabilities if you run with the shroud off?
a BUNCH!! jUST REACH DOWN TO THE LOWER PART OF THE FAN OPENING, LIKE THE 5 AND 7 OCLOCK POSITIONS AND PULL BACK TOWARDS THE ENGINE. iF THE SHROUD DOESNT MOVE, THEN YOUR GOLDEN. shhh!
 
a BUNCH!! jUST REACH DOWN TO THE LOWER PART OF THE FAN OPENING, LIKE THE 5 AND 7 OCLOCK POSITIONS AND PULL BACK TOWARDS THE ENGINE. iF THE SHROUD DOESNT MOVE, THEN YOUR GOLDEN. shhh!

Somebody really likes their shroud! :rofl:


I won't shout it, but I do agree.
Removing the shroud, or replacing the engine driven fan with an auxiliary fan are both really bad ideas.
Just have a look at how many threads there are on overheating issues
 
I’d lay odds in the neightborhood of 80/20 in favor of loose rad bolts over motor mounts since you mention it’s a brand new radiator.

But yeah, if you have the proper part/thickness radiator & it’s tight, and the fan/ fan clutch bolts are too - then motor mounts.

When runnimg right, the mech unit is a solid performer - going to an electric puller is a downgrade IMO.
 
This is what I’m doing...I took out my ac compressor. I’m using the pulley to run a belt through the hood through a slit cut vertical from the pully. The I’m running a rod to the front then another belt an pully on the fan to give my self dual front and rear belt driven fan! also I removed the condenser. And also lost angle approach by lowering the axel cooling radiator where the drivers side bumper cap is.
 
I’d lay odds in the neightborhood of 80/20 in favor of loose rad bolts over motor mounts since you mention it’s a brand new radiator.

But yeah, if you have the proper part/thickness radiator & it’s tight, and the fan/ fan clutch bolts are too - then motor mounts.

When runnimg right, the mech unit is a solid performer - going to an electric puller is a downgrade IMO.

Go back and read my “best guess”? The 3rd one. Have seen that one MAMY times!
 
Somebody really likes their shroud! :rofl:


I won't shout it, but I do agree.
Removing the shroud, or replacing the engine driven fan with an auxiliary fan are both really bad ideas.
Just have a look at how many threads there are on overheating issues

Well, yeah! I do luv my shroud. Sorry about the caps. Traffic was kinda heavy and I was typing in Braille?!?!
 
I had a similar problem a few months back. Downshift from 4th to 3rd and the fan went into the bottom of the radiator. Happened 2 times in a row as we first thought it was instalment error. Replaced everything... it turned out to be a sticky fan clutch. I had a cheapo fan clutch from Oreilies in there that would not disengage at higher RPMs hence the fan into RAD
 
Go back and read my “best guess”? The 3rd one. Have seen that one MAMY times!

Eeeeeeeaaaaasy down - I agree.

Dude’s issues are about the rad / fan / clutch hardware prob coming loose. Thousands of 80’s run around on less-than-awesome fan clutches or motor mounts, yet we bounce our junk & never so much as a hiccup.
If the shroud was loose, sure -it could have ate a few blades & sent one into the coolant tubes. No question.

Nobody’s going to know until he tosses up pics, but neither of us care -either way, his radiator got beaned. And he’s out another ~$300.
 
I had a similar problem a few months back. Downshift from 4th to 3rd and the fan went into the bottom of the radiator. Happened 2 times in a row as we first thought it was instalment error. Replaced everything... it turned out to be a sticky fan clutch. I had a cheapo fan clutch from Oreilies in there that would not disengage at higher RPMs hence the fan into RAD

Kind of ruled that out, since it's already got the Landtank clutch. Hoping thats not the case anyway.

Eeeeeeeaaaaasy down - I agree.

Dude’s issues are about the rad / fan / clutch hardware prob coming loose. Thousands of 80’s run around on less-than-awesome fan clutches or motor mounts, yet we bounce our junk & never so much as a hiccup.
If the shroud was loose, sure -it could have ate a few blades & sent one into the coolant tubes. No question.

Nobody’s going to know until he tosses up pics, but neither of us care -either way, his radiator got beaned. And he’s out another ~$300.

LOL, thankfully the P/O just replaced the radiator and not myself. Makes it suck just a little less. I'll post pics when I figure it out. I'm betting y'all are right about a loose/ill-fit shroud and/or rad bolts.
 
a BUNCH!! jUST REACH DOWN TO THE LOWER PART OF THE FAN OPENING, LIKE THE 5 AND 7 OCLOCK POSITIONS AND PULL BACK TOWARDS THE ENGINE. iF THE SHROUD DOESNT MOVE, THEN YOUR GOLDEN. shhh!

Looks like I'll be sourcing another shroud before summer then. Mine was cracked/flapping when I bought it, and when I replaced my radiator (due to tank pin-holes, not because the fan ate it) I left the shroud off, rather than put a defective part back on.
 
What’s the current consensus on a replacement radiator? Local Toyota dealer treats us LC/LX guys pretty good on pricing. Not opposed to eating the cost of an oem one.

Also heeding the advice given on keeping the clutch.
 
The engine mounts are fail safe right? The top steel cover drops down onto the lower mount if the rubber fails, is that enough movement to let the fan reach the rad?

Regards

Dave
 
I bought a Toyota rad which is trad from dealer was only 330 bucks fit correctly and no issues
 
How much do you retard the cooling capabilities if you run with the shroud off?

I'm running without my shroud on the Cruiser and it posts temps very similar to the LX450 with the shroud 90% of the time. The only time I see variation is if I'm in heavy bumper to bumper traffic for 20+ mins and occasionally on trails if we are climbing extended grades. If its moving at all the temps are the same and it doesn't need to move far to bring temps back down. I run 186*F during cold months and am seeing 191-196*F now in summer with AC running. Saw 201*F for a few mins on trails on a real hot and humid day here.

I saw a thread previous that estimated a difference of 5% in temps ... that seems about right. :meh: That being said, I'm sure a Toyota engineer put a shroud on for a reason.
 
I'm running without my shroud on the Cruiser and it posts temps very similar to the LX450 with the shroud 90% of the time. The only time I see variation is if I'm in heavy bumper to bumper traffic for 20+ mins and occasionally on trails if we are climbing extended grades. If its moving at all the temps are the same and it doesn't need to move far to bring temps back down. I run 186*F during cold months and am seeing 191-196*F now in summer with AC running. Saw 201*F for a few mins on trails on a real hot and humid day here.

I saw a thread previous that estimated a difference of 5% in temps ... that seems about right. :meh: That being said, I'm sure a Toyota engineer put a shroud on for a reason.

I've been thinking about installing a digital gauge for more accurate temps--what type are you running?
 
Have you replaced your engine mounts recently? If so... did you remember to put the dust shields back in?

I went through two radiators because of this mistake.... Makes sense when you think about it, the dust shields are about 1/4" thick, so without them in the front of the motor is about 3/4-1" lower. Then in Low range or when you downshift to pass on the interstate the engine torques on the mounts it causes the fan to climb the shroud and slice the fins on the bottom of the radiator.

In my case I added in some slotted 1/4" plates between the engine mounts and engine. Stopped this from ever happening again.
 
Back
Top Bottom