Diagnosing differential vs transfer case

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Mar 26, 2016
Threads
5
Messages
65
Location
California
So once again I've let my OCD get the better of me and I'm tracking down a deceleration whine that's been coming somewhere from my front end. The sound only occurs on deceleration, usually around 30-40 MPH, and even the most gentle application of throttle completely cures it. I'm fairly certain it's coming from a bad pinion bearing in the front differential, but aside from tearing the thing apart or taking it to a driveline shop to have them diagnose it, what can I do? I've tried changing to 85W-140 oil in the front diff which seem to have smoothed it out a little and reduced some of the feedback I get through the pedals, but maybe that's just in my head. Are there any other diagnostic checks I can do before I start throwing real money at this? Thanks again for your guys help!
 
You have any lift? If you think the front, do you have the caster bushes in?
 
It's almost always not the transfer case, so I think we can set that aside and assume that half of the question is resolved unless further evidence of its involvement demonstrates its relevance.

If you're not sure about it maybe being just a u-joint issue, try pumping the u-joint full of grease. That will cause a temporary shift in how it runs by taking up space caused by wear-and-tear slop until it slings off. If the noise goes away, maybe that's it.

If you're thinking the pinion is the issue, is there any drippage from it? If dry, that's a good sign, but still could be giving you the whines. Here you might try pumping some extra grease into the slip joint on the front driveline, just more than enough to service it, you want a slight bit of movement to change the overall length. You want a little pressure, but don't go crazy here, it takes surprisingly little. Drive it then to see if it makes any difference. A very rough diagnosis, but if there is a audible change that's something that points more toward the pinion. Don't forget to back the zerk out and release the pressure after doing this so it doesn't cause you to pull your hair about something else.
 
Removing the front shaft and driving it is a good troubleshooting tool but requires the center diff-lock switch which is no big deal to obtain and install.
 
So once again I've let my OCD get the better of me and I'm tracking down a deceleration whine that's been coming somewhere from my front end. The sound only occurs on deceleration, usually around 30-40 MPH, and even the most gentle application of throttle completely cures it. I'm fairly certain it's coming from a bad pinion bearing in the front differential, but aside from tearing the thing apart or taking it to a driveline shop to have them diagnose it, what can I do? I've tried changing to 85W-140 oil in the front diff which seem to have smoothed it out a little and reduced some of the feedback I get through the pedals, but maybe that's just in my head. Are there any other diagnostic checks I can do before I start throwing real money at this? Thanks again for your guys help!
How loud
 
No lift as of yet, just 285/75/16 BFGs.

I actually just greased all the drive line u-joints last weekend without any changes. I hadn't heard of backing the zirk out after pumping a little grease in. I assumed that the pressure was equalizing as the old grease got pushed out. Thanks for the tip!

Haven't tried pulling the front drive shaft since I don't have the CDL yet either.

Noise seems have gotten a little louder since when I first got the truck, but not significantly so. Adding the 85w-140 weight oil might have helped a little bit.
 
Had the same thing. It was the bearings in the rear nose of my transfer case. Had Robbie Antonson (PowderPig on Mud) install a rebuilt nose and the whine went away. If you want to find out what it is, put it on a rack in gear with someone in the drivers seat and have them run up the rpms while you listen to each component with a screwdriver against each diff as well as the transmission and each of the 3 components of the transfer case. You will hear the whine which will tell you which bearing is gone (assuming it is a bearing). You can get a rebuilt transfer case component from Robbie (he will ship it to you from Boulder) or from Onur.
 
Last edited:
I might just see if any of these local driveline shops can do a real diagnosis affordably. Unfortunately I just don't have any access to a lift and my resources at home are fairly limited.

Before I forget though is there any special procedure for loosening the zirk to relieve pressure? Just loosen a couple turns with a wrench and then tighten back down?
 
Grease zirks are just tiny tapered pipe thread.. yeah, use a wrench to loosen it (can be removed completely), then screw it back in. Don't over tighten.

Also a 7mm nut driver works well, IIRC
 
No lift as of yet, just 285/75/16 BFGs.

I actually just greased all the drive line u-joints last weekend without any changes. I hadn't heard of backing the zirk out after pumping a little grease in. I assumed that the pressure was equalizing as the old grease got pushed out. Thanks for the tip!

Hmmm, did the noise change after you greased things up? Because once you get pressure in the slip joint, it doesn't take much to start getting the weirdness happening. I learned this the hard way the first time I serviced my shiny new FJ55. All of the sudden I had this obnoxious noise from the driveline. Fortunately, after a talk around the breakroom table, it was suggested that I may have overdone things a bit. Slack isn't always good, but there has to be some in the drivetrain -- and I'd taken all the slack out of the system by turning it into a hydraulic ram...

So, back the zerk off. If there's pressure inside, it'll be obvious when things come snotting out. You'll likely find the noise changed -- and if you're lucky, maybe even gone. If not, then onto Plan B. Good luck!
 
No thankfully it's not that. The noise was around long before I greased the drive line and didnt change at all after I did it, so I'm fairly confident that's not it.
 
OK, sounds like you've probably ruled out the pinion already. If it was acting up, then it likely would have been sensitive to the extra dab of grease and you would have heard it change its tune. That's not an absolute, but does tend to point in other directions
 
You don't unscrew the zerk. You use a small narrow screwdriver and push in the ball in the end of the zerk.
 
What lift are you on? Any?

Have you added or changed any parts recently that would change your suspension geometry.

The rear 3rd can act any manner of ways depending on how you change pinion angle (shorter upper arms vs. lengthen lower arms), same with the front.

How many miles on your drivetrain & has it ever been in an accident?

The front axle shell is really to a certain extent kind of fragile, depending on how you do something or if a car hits you at the right angle - I've bent a shell & Christo has multiple to his name, so do others.

When you swapped your diff oil did anything mettalic come out?

Did you notice this after a session of wheeling you can point to where maybe you remember a particular hit that you did the "mental grimace" over?

Does the sound get progressively louder in proportion to the steeper the incline in a downhill when coasting (increased engine braking vs level ground)?
 
What lift are you on? Any?

Have you added or changed any parts recently that would change your suspension geometry.

The rear 3rd can act any manner of ways depending on how you change pinion angle (shorter upper arms vs. lengthen lower arms), same with the front.

How many miles on your drivetrain & has it ever been in an accident?

The front axle shell is really to a certain extent kind of fragile, depending on how you do something or if a car hits you at the right angle - I've bent a shell & Christo has multiple to his name, so do others.

When you swapped your diff oil did anything mettalic come out?

Did you notice this after a session of wheeling you can point to where maybe you remember a particular hit that you did the "mental grimace" over?

Does the sound get progressively louder in proportion to the steeper the incline in a downhill when coasting (increased engine braking vs level ground)?



Reviving this thread a little bit. Sorry for the delay in responses. Been pretty crazy at work. No lift, running BFG 33s. No recent part changes. Drivetrain has 152,500 miles. No trail damage, it's pretty much sounded like this since I've had it. No large metal shavings or anything obvious when changing diff oil, just a little bit of that fine silvery paste on the magnet. No difference in sound based on uphill or downhill travel. While driving I've shifted the transmission into neutral with no change in sound. Did the same thing while driving with the transfer case and again with no change in sound.

Had a local driveline shop take a look at it. Nothing too scientific, just took it out for a spin with me and listened to the sound. They seemed to agree that it was rear differential but said they couldn't rule out the transfer case without really taking a look at the parts or seeing the 3rd member off of the truck.

I'm getting ready to order a new ring and pinion, master bearing install kit, and pull the 3rd member and take it in to the shop. Does anyone have any last minute input before I commit money to this theory that it really is just a bad pinion bearing? Thank you guys again for all your help!
 
why not have it looked at by one of the real cruiser shops first ?

sounds like you are just throwing money at a problem that isn't properly diagnosed
 
You don't need a CDL switch to lock the center diff.. put transfer case into Low and wait for CDL light.. then pull the fuse for the CDL motor. When you put case back into High it won't have any power to unlock CDL and you can alternate removing the front and rear driveline to narrow down the problem.
 
why not have it looked at by one of the real cruiser shops first ?

sounds like you are just throwing money at a problem that isn't properly diagnosed

At first it didn't seem like there were a lot of dedicated cruiser shops in my area, but I found this place about an hour or so away. Any heard of Rock Solid Offroad?

RSO Performance

Or any suggestions for shops in the San Diego area? I've heard of a couple other cruiser friendly places but they don't look like they really do any driveline stuff.

You don't need a CDL switch to lock the center diff.. put transfer case into Low and wait for CDL light.. then pull the fuse for the CDL motor. When you put case back into High it won't have any power to unlock CDL and you can alternate removing the front and rear driveline to narrow down the problem.

That's a great tip! Thank you for that, I wouldn't have thought of that.
 
If you want to find the problem on your own, you can use what any "top-notch" shop will have: A good set of listening tools

Bottom-line pricing on Steelman 6600 at ToolTopia.com

In fact, if your shop doesn't use a set of these before they start working on your rig, you need to ask some serious questions....like how they know precisely what the problem is.

With a set of these, you can clip them on your transmission, each nose and the center of your transfer case as well as your differentials or other components and drive down the road with the ear phones on. You can swap to each component and listen to the sounds they are generating. This will tell you beyond a shadow of a doubt what is generating the sound.

This device is $99 and it could save you thousands in unnecessary repairs.
 
Back
Top Bottom