Blown Birf Question...

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jan 2, 2003
Threads
139
Messages
2,669
Location
Park City, Utah
Guys I had some exploded birfs in my axle for some time and now the inside of the knuckles are all chewed up. No big deal but the surface where the inner axle seal is a little mangled now. I don't have a set of seal drivers (will be picking some up today!) and badly mangled an inner axle seal tryting to get it in last night. I don't have a tool that would work for grinding out any crap. I am thinking of getting maybe a dremel or some sort of air driven grinder with a bit or attachment to clean up the mangling?

Any ideas or comments on this. I would not run an axle seal but I don't want to leak all over the place..
 
isnt the seal there to prevent leaks? and if so you need one to not leak
 
Dremel or air die grinder with a carbide bit has worked wonders fixing this mess in the past for myself, and many others.


Time to go tool shopping!


:beer:
 
camcruiser13 said:
isnt the seal there to prevent leaks? and if so you need one to not leak



The inner axle seal is there to keep gear oil in the axle housing with the diff, and out of the Moly grease in the knuckles...


:beer:
 
Inner axle seal is supposedly needed but I have heard of and know some guys who don't run them. Also supposedly gear oil is a better lube than bearing grease as long as it is in plentiful supply. This includes birfs, etc. But having had a blown axle seal and even badly blown ones in the past, when they leak they leak...
 
camcruiser13 said:
so one does not need seals?



Cameron....


Where did I say anything like that?



I would install them....but I also have known people to not use them....I was not one however.


:beer:
 
wanted to know if it was needed or not, no need to get testy. was curious thanx for the clarifications steve
 
I've never found them to keep all the gear lube in the axle. Don't they commonly have two small holes drilled in the body of the seal? I thought it was more of a keep the gear lube from flowing freely and keep most of it in the axle. I have never pulled apart my hubs even with all new seals and not had some gear lube in the hubs, it doesn't seem to mix or displace the grease.
I generally fill the knuckle pretty full with grease when I put them together BTW. I do keep good seals in there though.

This is just what I do, not sure it's the best.
 
Keeping 90w out of the knuckle area also has some import because the rubber & felt knuckle seals can't stop 90w near as well as they stop grease. 90w leaking out the knuckles gets messy. Wouldn't likely hurt anything at the knuckle/birf, though. Still, as mentioned, the inner axle seals help keep the diff 90w in place since low 90w level around the R&P can cause heat damage at high speed.

Also, I don't think 90w would prove to be a good birf lube unless the birf could be immersed in 90w always. The LC knuckles aren't designed for that like my IHC TravelAll's closed-knuckle, front D44.
 
camcruiser13 said:
wanted to know if it was needed or not, no need to get testy. was curious thanx for the clarifications steve



That was testy huh..... ok.


Go have a :beer:



Jetboy said:
I've never found them to keep all the gear lube in the axle. Don't they commonly have two small holes drilled in the body of the seal?



There are not any holes drilled in any of the Toyota seals that I have ever seen/installed. If you are having troubles keeping a seal in the housing there could be a few things at play creating this issue:



Knuckles not centered on the housing causing the spindle to not be centered on the axle bore/seal bore, causing the axle to not run centered on the seal.



A bent housing could create this same issue.



Good luck!

-Steve
 
And for a DD not having axle seals will wash most of the grease away from the top knuckle bearing. Then if you have a long period without using 4wd you will starve that bearing of a lubricant and end up with an even bigger mess.

Also packing the knuckle with grease may seem like a go thing to do But I cannot see why you would need to. The friction surfaces are inside the birf not on the outside. On a ball and claw I could see this being needed. As long as you pack the knuckle bearing and leave some grease around those areas I see no need in packing the knuckle full of grease just the birf. It just makes a bigger mess when rebuilding the knuckles.

Anybody have a different opinion?
 
yes I don't pack the knuckle full of grease either, pretty unneccessary I think. What I do is pack the birfield so it is entirely full of grease almost oozing out. I am usually in there at least every 6 months for whatever reason, usually the birfs still have some grease in there after even 6 months.. :)
 
Poser said:
If you are having troubles keeping a seal in the housing there could be a few things at play creating this issue:

Knuckles not centered on the housing causing the spindle to not be centered on the axle bore/seal bore, causing the axle to not run centered on the seal.

A bent housing could create this same issue.

When I had Warn Birfield eliminators in my truck I couldn’t keep the front end from leaking, even after replacing the seals many times. Now that the junk has been replaced by Longfields it hasn’t leaked a drop, even in the same housing. I think the u-joints were offset just enough to use up the seals.

I hate the stinky gear oil/moly mix running all over the inside of the tires and slinging everywhere.
 
lemon said:
When I had Warn Birfield eliminators in my truck I couldn’t keep the front end from leaking, even after replacing the seals many times. Now that the junk has been replaced by Longfields it hasn’t leaked a drop, even in the same housing. I think the u-joints were offset just enough to use up the seals....
That may have just been the inherent sideways "walking" that wheel joints do when turned near the stops.

My old GM trucks with serviceable front D44s engaged don't make sharp turns smoothly at the wheel joint, but the axle seal is at the diff, not at the end of the housing inboard the knuckle, so no leakage issues ensue from the "walking". Fortunately, sharp turns aren't made at high speed.

Thanks for post that tidbit of info, though. I'd never before considered the turning characteristics of Warn's birf eliminators. Thank God for Bobby Long. :grinpimp:
 
if you have treated birfs..(ie: Smurfields) you will want to pack the knuckle extremely well. when you turn the wheel, the grease gets pushed out of the birf, and they will wear out. having it packed tight keeps the birf full of grease!!
And they will last alot longer!

I promise!:D
 
Hey travis.. To let you know my smurfields held up extrmemely well over at least a year but finally gave up the ghost a couple months ago. I actually blew two of them in one shot! I think it might have been related to lack of bump stops though (which I just added now). Are you still in the business of making these? Are you in Utah also? Best, Andre
 
welcome travis rankin;)
 
Back
Top Bottom