Birfield Carnage!

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

of course, then we won't mention at all that you should have checked the grease level right away when getting it and/or hearing the noise... :D

nah, would probably have made little difference in the long run.... :)

Ya, they where trashed when I bought it. Even had I filled it with grease I wouldn't have reversed the 35,000 miles of damage. Really the only difference Is I am pulling it apart now instead of last month.

I'll try to post up a pick of that dry wiper.
 
for reference here is what a birf looks like when the diff oil completely washes away the grease. you can see al the oil all over the place, note the rollers from the failed upper trunnion bearing that had no lube, I bought it with the understanding that it "needed a repack" did no know aout the bearing, on the way home it drove surprisingly well without this bearing, having only an odd shifting feel when turning that I thought was TRE's, I did not have any suspicion it was this bad until I jacked up the front end and te wheel flopped 4" at the top :eek: Birf was just fine because it never turned without grease (Part time Fj62)
FJ62birf1.webp
FJ62Birf2.webp
 
I have a set of those ABS sensor tattlers. I left them at Upsidedown's shop, but they're probably still there. They are in good condition (I disabled my ABS); PM me if you want them, just pay shipping.
 
Iron Yuppy, I appreciate the offer. I'll let you know if I need them.

RavenTai-Thats pretty much what mine looked like, except the diff oil was tightly sealed in the differential. Is there any other explanation for this than failing to repack with the proper amount of grease?
 
Is there any other explanation for this than failing to repack with the proper amount of grease?


From what I can see from your birf pics both outside and inside there is no washing going on, you can see the leftovers of grease (and rust?) in your pics were it a washing condition they would not be there only oil, and the outside would be a nasty oily mess (see pics above and that is well away from the oil source). where as yours looks too dry. there should be a little funk of grease getting past the wiper seal for a healthy seal or dripping wet with oil for a "needs repack" but never bone dry.

IMO from the pictures as presented there just was never enough grease in the first place, looks like the mechanic put a little on the birf and that is it. not the cavity 3/4 full as it was suppose to be.
 
this is my personal opinion and i am sure that the OCD crowd on here will disagree with me but...

when i have done birf jobs, i really really really pack the grease in the birf itself, a little around the axle seal, some near the felt, but i dont pack the whole housing. Looking at a birf and the spinning and turning motion, also with how much work it takes to get grease in the actual joint, i dont see the grease in the knuckle really doing a whole lot. i am not saying the dealer ship is not at fault but the grease really only needs to be in the joint itself. thats why you cant do a birf repack through the access hole in the knuckle... i have done it this way on 2 rigs and been in my 80 since i did it this way, 30K ago, looks fine...


obviously they didnt do a good job. the joint was prolly worn before the servicing and ht repack didnt fix the problem. lots of guys here do repacks or switch sides with birfs to lose the clicking and it doesnt work.
 
IMO from the pictures as presented there just was never enough grease in the first place, looks like the mechanic put a little on the birf and that is it. not the cavity 3/4 full as it was suppose to be.


i dont know what the fsm says about a repack but do they say to seperate the axle from birf in the instuctions for repack? the guy prolly did the hardest part of tearing it all down then didnt pack the joint right....
 
My thought was that if it clicks, its worn. If it is worn it gets replaced. This job is enough of a PITA that I'd just as soon put new parts in and not have to see them again for 50K or so.
 
i dont know what the fsm says about a repack but do they say to seperate the axle from birf in the instuctions for repack? the guy prolly did the hardest part of tearing it all down then didnt pack the joint right....

there is no reference in the FSM for a repack, just disassembly and reassembly instructions, they leave it up to you as for the "why" and therefore "how far". but there is a part in there about how to separate the birf


I am with you on completely disassembling the birf and completely filling with grease, I even put a good bit of work to get all the air pockets out of the grease in the birf.

where we differ is I fill the cavity aprox 3/4 full per the FSM, there is a lot of cyntrifugal force going on there, without any in the cavity the birf will sling most of its grease to the sides and not take in anymore eventually leaving it dry and we get what you see above.
 
FWIW I have a clicking birf on the front left and has been for some time. I have wheeled it HARD and even sheered the rear axle with no harm to the front to date...
 
give it time it will eventually let go.
 
Cruiserdan should read this, maybe he can help you with getting reimbursed. Worth a shot, with these pics and testamony as backup.



I have read it.

Establishing blame lies in producing an original repair order and a timeline from thereafter.

I must say that if a Toyota dealer put that thing back togther without properly packing the knuckles I am embarrased to say the least. On the other hand I have seem some stupid s*** in my 28+ years in the car business.
 
Dan, I have refrained from scanning in the original repair invoice to protect the dealership. Needless to say, if they do not help me out at all I will scan it here for all to see. The timeline was 37,000 miles and about 2 years. Would you like me to send you a copy with a photograph of the odometer? Anyway, I want to talk to the dealership first, but asuming they don't help, probably tuesday, I'll be contacting you for parts.
 
Dan, I have refrained from scanning in the original repair invoice to protect the dealership. Needless to say, if they do not help me out at all I will scan it here for all to see. The timeline was 37,000 miles and about 2 years. Would you like me to send you a copy with a photograph of the odometer? Anyway, I want to talk to the dealership first, but asuming they don't help, probably tuesday, I'll be contacting you for parts.



Unfortunately it's a moot point. The service warranty is 12 months, unlimited mileage, so you are out of coverage.
 
Dan, I have refrained from scanning in the original repair invoice to protect the dealership. Needless to say, if they do not help me out at all I will scan it here for all to see. The timeline was 37,000 miles and about 2 years. Would you like me to send you a copy with a photograph of the odometer? Anyway, I want to talk to the dealership first, but asuming they don't help, probably tuesday, I'll be contacting you for parts.

Usually repairs like that get guaranteed for 12K or 12 months or so whichever comes first. Did they do it wrong? Probably. At 37,000 miles on a 60,000 mile FSM suggested job, you're probably outside of warranty and into that fuzzy space between the warranty and the next time when the PM should be done.

It sucks, yeah they seem to have done it wrong, I don't think you'll have much luck getting it warrantied. For your sake I hope I'm wrong.

YMMV
 
It sucks, yeah they seem to have done it wrong, I don't think you'll have much luck getting it warrantied. For your sake I hope I'm wrong.

YMMV

Sometimes, it's important to move on. No way in the world they will help you with this. You have an old truck with a two year old repair. You may think they did it wrong, but you can't prove it, and they owe you nothing. It was even owned by someone else when the repack was done. My vote--forget about it. Buy the replacement parts, do the repair and drive on. If you get all worked up about making the guilty pay, you'll just be unhappy and not enjoy your vehicle.

With that said, you have learned a valuable lesson about who works on your vehicle. No one cares but you. If you want to drive a Land Cruiser, you must do these kind of repairs yourself. Only you will take the time to do it right and not cut corners to make it in under "book time".

When you do the repair, do it by the book-the book being the FSM. Replace the seals, pack the cavity and do it right. Then take the time to look critically at the spindles, replace the wheelbearings and you will have a front axle good for 30,000 miles.
 
I have a set of those ABS sensor tattlers. I left them at Upsidedown's shop, but they're probably still there. They are in good condition (I disabled my ABS); PM me if you want them, just pay shipping.

I'll be happy to take those if JeremiahEaster doesn't want them. I have two new birfs coming and they don't have those on them.

Let me know
 
Landtank, are you going to try the ebay birfs?
 
Back
Top Bottom