Birfield Carnage!

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Dec 5, 2006
Threads
43
Messages
235
After all the expert advice on this forum I enlisted the help of fellow Mudd member theKirk to tear down my front knuckles. Before I say anything about the job I want to offer a huge thank you to theKirk who did not know me but offered to come buy and walk me through the whole job. If Mr. Kirk is any representation of the type of people we have on this board, then we really have one stellar bunch of people on here.

OK, first thing we noticed was that the birf was running almost dry. There was no leakage at the knuckle which tells me that a certain PNW dealership (which shall remain unamed until such time as they decline to replace my parts) which serviced the birfs 37,000 miles ago failed to pack the housing 3/4 full as the FSM instrcuts. Enjoy the carnage........

birfcarnage.JPG

This is what we saw when we opened it.....hey look, no grease!



birfcarnage-1.JPG

Uh-Oh, I don't think we're supposed to see those ball bearings yet.


birfcarnage-2.JPG

The whole cage basically disentegrated.


birfcarnage-3.JPG

Here is the birf with whats left of the cage.



birfcarnage-4.JPG

I'm not sure if I can reuse this birf and I was hoping to get opinions here. Notice the gouges in these teeth. The inside looks semi-ok though, I'll post up another pic of it when I get it all cleaned.



birfcarnage-5.JPG

Notice the lack of leakage on the inside of the knuckle. This birf did not loose its grease, there never was any to begin with. Do you think maybe a tech needs to get fired?


birfcarnage-6.JPG

Notice the gouge in the bell housing where a piece of the cage was driven into the steel. Do I need to worry about the housing or would you guys just put the new birf right back in here?

Kirk and I both thought the real testament to Toyota engineering here is that this vehicle drove around for 37,000 miles with no grease in the driver side birf before it finally came apart. Thats pretty unbelievable.

The Passenger side was intact and the grease didn't look all burnt like it was in this one but there was little grease over there as well. Fortunately we think a repack will do the trick on that side (or do I need to replace both birfs together?).

One other thing; the bearing pre-load shim on the top of the passenger side knuckle was missing. Do I have to replace that part or is it OK without?
 
Ouch!!

Yes, someone should indeed get fired. That seems to be pretty much straight up negligence.

Yes, theKirk is a pretty good example of the types cats we see wandering around these halls. Don't worry--he didn't come and help you to help you....he came to help your truck....:doh: :flipoff2:

Just kidding. Get on the phone and get some new birfs.

And take these pics to the dealership and raise hell.

Good luck.
-o-
 
I don't think that was rust, just burnt grease residue.
 
Nice, someone should at least get a severe tongue lashing for that one. It reminds me of a time I had my ball joints and tie rod ends replaced on an older Ford. It developed a major death wobble as I was going around a corner, and I almost lost control. It turns out that the mechanic had forgotten to put the cotter pin in the castle nut and the tie rod fell off.... That is definitly a testiment to the quality of Toyota.
 
Wow!
I might keep that birfield bell around for a trail spare - but I wouldn't run it. That thing was exposed to the same excessive wear & heat that did in the cage, plus some more when things came apart and jammed around in there. I woudn't trust it. When you clean up the inside of the bell, I bet you'll find alot of wear in the ball channels - and on the star as well.

To be honest, that big ding in the bell housing has me a little concerned also. Definitely bitch at the dealer - but don't expect to get much satisfaction from them. Did you own the truck when that servoce was done?
 
No, I didn't own it when the service was done, but I have any idea that me be very pursuasive to a dealership trying to keep a good reputation. ;)
 
Great goodness! At least now you know for sure what's up.

We are among good company here. . . . usually, except when junk wanders in.

Look at the upside; now you know how the system works, how to work on it and you'll have new parts so you shouldn't have to worry about it again for a really long time if you put it back together correctly.
 
Sorry you had to learn & find this carnage.........you now have a nice paper weight:flipoff2:
 
I'm not sure if I can reuse this birf and I was hoping to get opinions here. Notice the gouges in these teeth. The inside looks semi-ok though, I'll post up another pic of it when I get it all cleaned.

If you are talking about the exciter ring for the ABS, the one with square notches in it, I think it will work fine. The only way to replace that ring is with an OEM birfield. You you are going that way anyway it's not a problem. However if you were looking at aftermarket birfs then you need to reuse it.
 
Notice the gouge in the bell housing where a piece of the cage was driven into the steel. Do I need to worry about the housing or would you guys just put the new birf right back in here?

I would not worry about the gouge in the knuckle housing. You can save that ABS ring but the rest of that birf is of little use. I don't think you can buy the cage, star, and balls separately.

If it were me, I would try to get the dealership to pony up for 2 new birfields if I had paid for the service. With the PO having paid for the service then you are on less solid ground. If they will pay for one they will probably pay for both.

If theKirk says the DS birf is OK then go with his recommendation or post up some pics. You don't have to replace them both when you replace one.

-B-
 
how long have you had this truck?
 
Chiming in, here...

First off, thanks for the kind words, Jeremiah... I'd be blushing here, if I had any sense of shame. I just hope I didn't talk your ear off, doing the job. ;)

I really don't have a clue whether or not that birf is OK. My first instinct is, replace that puppy, just to be safe. I don't have enough experience with these things to say--this is only the second Land Cruiser I've done this on. Although I've done the same job on the military 2 1/2- and 5-ton trucks, and a few other Toyota products, like a '90 Truck and a 4Runner. Both the PS and the DS side were run for a very long time with minimal lubrication. I still can't believe they lasted as long as they did--I think Jeremiah has set a new benchmark, here--Longest Running Birfield With Almost No Lubricant. I don't expect anyone else is going to try to beat 37,000 miles.

Anyone else think these pics may belong in the FAQ, if only as a cautionary tale for those that don't do their maintenance?

The other thing that threw me with this birf job is this: That passenger side upper trunnion had no shim on it, at all. Given what we've seen of this guy's work (the service tech who did this for the previous owner), I'm afraid he may have left off the shim for that side, along with forgetting the grease. Which is why I'm strongly suggesting to Jeremiah that we take the steering arms off the tie rods, and do the full-scale pre-load thing with the trunnion bearings. I didn't bother to do that with mine--just left the tie rods on, and went for it. In Jeremiah's case, I don't think it's a good idea. Do the rest of y'all concur with that?

Or, is "no shim" an option, with the upper trunnion? I'm thinking it might be, but... This is a rig that Jeremiah puts his family into, so I want to be absolutely sure we're doing the right thing with it.
 
You have virtually zero chance of getting any satisfaction from the dealership since not only did you not pay for the work, you did not give them the chance to open it up and see what's going on. I'm not saying don't go there and try - I would - but don't expect victory.

As for the shim, the only way is to do the fish scale test if you must have it "correctly done". That will require buying a set of shims which must be ordered. Personally, I'd inspect the axle seal to see where the shaft was running in the seal, and look at the knuckle bearing races. If the seal is not worn at the top, and the races don't look stressed, I personally would simply bolt it up without the shim. Every knuckle did not neccessarily come with a shim though the odds are it at least came with a small .050 one.

DougM
 
Who ever done that job in the first place needs the birf shoved up there arse, while shouting at him "now do you want me to leave it dry or do you want some grease on it!"

Hilarious! :D
 
how long have you had this truck?

One month. I heard the birf clicking, but had read several posts in the archives about driving for a while on clicking birfs with no problems. I also had no reference point to gauge the severity of my clicking. I planned on opening it up this summer and had already suspected that I might need new birfs. I do admit, I'm a little embarrased to have been driving it around like that though :o
 
One month. I heard the birf clicking, but had read several posts in the archives about driving for a while on clicking birfs with no problems. I also had no reference point to gauge the severity of my clicking. I planned on opening it up this summer and had already suspected that I might need new birfs. I do admit, I'm a little embarrased to have been driving it around like that though :o


of course, then we won't mention at all that you should have checked the grease level right away when getting it and/or hearing the noise... :D
















nah, would probably have made little difference in the long run.... :)
 
I understand the axle seals leak grease with fair frequency. I've already replaced my axle seals twice, the first time with replacement parts and the second with OEM. I postulate that the PO might have simply cleaned of the grease that flowed out and promptly forgot about it rather than replaceing the grease regularly. If so, the dealer is off the hook.

I think it unlikely that a mechanic can forget to put grease in. The Birf is a fairly complicated job and low level mechanics don't get to that kind of work without a trainer.


Kalawang
 
Nope, Kalawang. These idjits completely forgot to put in the grease--the wiper was totally dry, no grease on it at all. The felt looked like it was brand-new, aside from rust stains. I think Jeremiah can post pictures of that, too. There was zero grease on that thing, at all. Plus there's exactly zero sign that the dif oil was contaminated. It was pure, clean, and looking like it was just put in, actually.

And, it didn't get out the wheel bearing way, either--that grease was fine, still tacky. And, it looked to be something like MobilOne--different type of grease than the molybdenum type in the birfs, what little was there. Trust me, I'd have seen signs that the PO had done something like you describe, and said something to Jeremiah. This is a genuine case of service technician idiocy.

I think they got in a hurry, and forgot to do it, or just didn't read that last page of the FSM section where it says to put the grease in. The guy probably hadn't done one, before--that type of axle is pretty uncommon, on newer Toyotas in the states--everything has been independent front suspension for years, in the 4X4 world. Average tech may never have seen something like that thing, unless they've been around Land Cruisers.
 
Back
Top Bottom