I've done wheels and other aluminum castings...and a 30' Airstream camper. The best way to do an object of this size is with an air-powered die grinder (preferably a 90 degree grinder) with three or four 4" cotton buffing wheels and three or four rouge blocks of different grits. It's a dirty job. Wear a mask and safety glasses. Mineral spirits does a pretty good job of getting the black off your hands and face.
If it were me, I would stop where you are, scuff it with 800 grit and paint it.
If it were me, I would stop where you are, scuff it with 800 grit and paint it.