Value Add VS. Value Deduct -Your take?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Nov 2, 2017
Threads
9
Messages
86
Location
Maryland
Hello Everyone,

As I get older I feel like my opinion has changed several times. After reading several threads/posts and soliciting feedback from close friends, I'd like to get your take on what adds monetary value vs. deducts monetary value on a FJ80, FZJ80, and LX450.

Regular maintenance:

-Brakes (front and rear pads/rotors)
-Tires (265/75/16 or 285/75/16) (265/70/17 or 285/70/17)
-Aftermarket wheels (16" or 17")

Lift kits:

-OME stock height
-OME 2.5"
-OME 4"
-OME 6"

Preventative maintenance:

-Birfield joints
-Rear axle
-Head gasket

This is more of a skeleton list, but I feel like these things come up most often. If you have any other big ticket items that would influence your opinion please comment.

TIA!
 
If I got 30 cents on the dollar for everything I've put into mine, I'd feel pretty lucky. Spending $10,000 in upgrades to make your LC worth $3,000 more adds value to your LC but sure hurts your bank accounts value. But it sure is fun fixing these things up.
 
Not that I care either as I never intend to sell my LC so I don't care what it's worth but...

Documented regular maintenance, documented repairs and documented preventative maintenance will add far more value than customization. A well maintained relatively stock car appeals to a large market where a customized car is only going to appeal to a select few.
 
IMO, documented maintenance will make it easier to sell, but not worth more.

I agree that upgrades are perhaps worth $0.30 on the dollar if they are tasteful. A 4" lift is likely worth more than a 6" lift since there's a bigger market for a 4" lifted rig vs a 6" lifted rig.
 
To me, standard maintenance just needs to be done, not a value thing. If you didn't do it, I'm either looking for a super cheap price or not interested.

As to lift, tires, etc., as stated before pennies on the dollar.
 
To me, standard maintenance just needs to be done, not a value thing.
In addition to what you said above, to me standard maintenance done on time shows pride in ownership.
 
Mostly stock, everything is new. I wouldn't sell my rig for less than the insured $20,000 value.

Original payment was $3000 cash and I painted the exterior of the fancy house the PO owned. Since then, I have about $15,000 worth of parts receipts and way, way over 1000 hours into my rig. $20K would be a fair deal, but I would very much regret selling it. It would be among the last things I would sell, including my house. I would buy a camper to tow if I needed to do that.
 
Yeah, I agree with the others that there is no reliable ROI on improvements or mods to these vehicles. They are money pits, but fun ones at that. I don't see myself selling mine anytime in the next 10 years, so I'm good with still putting lots of time, and some money, into it. It's also fun for me, it's a type of therapy. So, how do you quantify smiles and stress reduction? I don't think these trucks make cents, but they do make sense.
 
I will 3rd that one^^^. Modification is really a matter of personal preference. Plus it’s all part of the fun and enjoyment of owning the rig. The odds that I would be able to find a Land Cruiser that has been modified in the manner in which I totally agree with are extremely slim. Plus that Land Cruiser will will cost me more than if I were to buy a nice clean stock one which doesn’t come with the worried that perhaps the previous owner did not do the work with the upmost integrity. Lastly, modifications usually add wear and tear and make things wear out faster and cause more problems in general and I don’t want that headache when purchasing a vehicle
 
Stock cruiser = value add
Modified cruiser = value deduct
Lifted cruiser = value deduct
Ugly, dingy, dirty, dented cruiser = Not even going to call you unless I need a parts truck...maybe...
 
Is there anyone here willing to say, they will pay more for a stock LC vs a slightly-somewhat built one all else equal? Because that seems crazy to me. We can agree the mods only add a fraction of value, but to say they actually decrease the value doesn't seem logical. Even if you didn't like the exact choice of modification there is a used market for all that stuff. Maybe you're not interested in reversing that work, or worried about how someone who mods their truck also drives it (i.e. wheels it), and that's why you wouldn't buy it, but that seems like a separate matter.

Like if I bought a stock 80 in good shape with maintenance and ownership history, didn't drive it at all, then put bumpers and a lift on it and sold it shortly thereafter, I would not expect to sell it for less than I bought it (assuming a fair deal both times).
 
If you are mechanically inclined and have access to basic hand tools and a garage, i would pay more up front for a stock rig, unmodified, and spent all its live in dry/ none rust belt climate, and that was exactly what i do with all the cars i have owned. I bought my LC bone stock from AZ with good maintenance records. Granted, i am OCD and i love doing my own work and love getting my hands dirty. These trucks are by far the easiest platforms to work on compared to most 90s or later vehicles. Have i bought a modded rig for a little more up front, knowing myself, i would have spent double in replacing 90% of all mods from PO. Doing research and learning while wrenching is possibly the most rewarding for any LC owners out there, and this holds truth for all types of cars.
 
Is there anyone here willing to say, they will pay more for a stock LC vs a slightly-somewhat built one all else equal? Because that seems crazy to me. We can agree the mods only add a fraction of value, but to say they actually decrease the value doesn't seem logical. Even if you didn't like the exact choice of modification there is a used market for all that stuff. Maybe you're not interested in reversing that work, or worried about how someone who mods their truck also drives it (i.e. wheels it), and that's why you wouldn't buy it, but that seems like a separate matter.

Like if I bought a stock 80 in good shape with maintenance and ownership history, didn't drive it at all, then put bumpers and a lift on it and sold it shortly thereafter, I would not expect to sell it for less than I bought it (assuming a fair deal both times).

If you had two identical, in every way vehicles, except for one was stock and one had tasteful mods, I'd probably pay more for the modded one. Exceptions would be something special like a low-low mileage, 1997, Land Cruiser, 40th w/ lockers. Then, I'd prefer almost 100% stock as I'd be trying to bet on the long-term resale going up.
 
If you had two identical, in every way vehicles, except for one was stock and one had tasteful mods, I'd probably pay more for the modded one. Exceptions would be something special like a low-low mileage, 1997, Land Cruiser, 40th w/ lockers. Then, I'd prefer almost 100% stock as I'd be trying to bet on the long-term resale going up.

Im not sure I agree I have no interest in driving a stock 80 series 40th or not as I dont see much value increase going forward.
 
Im not sure I agree I have no interest in driving a stock 80 series 40th or not as I dont see much value increase going forward.
100% agreed with LCP. I also have no interest in driving a stock LC. I use it exclusively for offloading/camping and the ample storage spaces without sacrificing too much creature comfort. If i just want for long term investment, there are tons other options out there. If i need a DD, the LC would not be one for sure.
 
This is really a question of increasing or decreasing your pool of potential buyers. A stock vehicle will always bring more buyers to the market than a built or modded vehicle. This becomes even more prevalent the older or more classic a vehicle becomes.

All things being equal, an unmolested 80 is going to bring more buyers to the table, and therefore, command more cash.

On the other hand, does that mean that you may be able to find a better deal on a built truck, verses a stocker that you intend to build out yourself? The answer is usually yes.

That being said, there are some things you can do to increase value without modifying to the point of decreasing the potential market:

1. Paint and bodywork (done right)
2. New carpet and upholstery
3. Repair and Maint. documentation
 
Back
Top Bottom