Transmission Slipping

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Nov 13, 2010
Threads
54
Messages
1,351
I have 97 LC with 200,000 miles. This morning entering the freeway it felt like the transmission was slipping once I got to about 50-60 mph. Engine RPM's were around 2500 and didn't seem to change when the LC started having symptoms. It felt like the vehicle was lunging a little with intermittent loss of power. If I didn't accelerate and just maintained my speed it seemed fine. Symptoms lasted about 4 minutes or so and then resolved.

Didn't notice anything after exiting the freeway and driving on surface streets up to 45mph. Coming back home entering the freeway it was similar but much less pronounced and lasted only between the acceleration between 50-60mph for about 30 seconds. Checked the transmission fluid and it was fine.

Mud search didn't reveal much and it seems like the A343f transmission doesn't tend to have much trouble which makes me question my diagnosis. No engine light either. Any help would be appreciated.
 
My buddy in KS recently went through something similar. Turned out to be his fuel pump.
That was in a Ford Expedition though, so YMMV.

His explanation over the phone was just like yours and he was sure it was the transmission going south. Two weeks later, the fuel pump died. The problem went away entirely with a new fuel pump.
 
My experience with transmissions slipping is the rpm's go up and the vehicle won't accelerate, not like you described.
 
Last edited:
My buddy in KS recently went through something similar. Turned out to be his fuel pump.
That was in a Ford Expedition though, so YMMV.

His explanation over the phone was just like yours and he was sure it was the transmission going south. Two weeks later, the fuel pump died. The problem went away entirely with a new fuel pump.

I hope that is all it is. Replacing a fuel pump seems easier than replacing a transmission but I could be wrong. I haven't performed either. If it was the fuel pump why am I only getting symptoms in 3rd gear? Shouldn't acceleration at any speed give me trouble?
 
Mike experience with transmissions slipping is the rpm's go up and the vehicle won't accelerate, not like you described.

I'll have to take the LC out again and pay closer attention to the rpms when I get a chance and can find a safe place to do some testing incase I lose power completely.
 
Mine was the wiring harness in the engine bay. Insulation melted on the wires and caused all sorts of odd transmission behavior.
 
Went for a drive this afternoon. I didn't get onto the freeway but drove the some surface streets and found a few very steep hills to climb. There were only a few times when I felt like something was slipping or lunging but symptoms were very subtle. I couldn't exactly find a way to trigger it today but stayed under 45mph due to surface streets. Accelerating rapidly from stop was not a problem at all other than guzzling gas and didn't have any issues. I'll have to take it out on the freeway tomorrow and see. I will have to go check the wiring harness - but not sure a visual inspection will tell me much unless it is obviously melted. I'll have to look up testing the fuel pump regulator. Could a driveline issue cause this?
 
Took it out for a drive on the freeway. The slipping/shuddering wasn't easily reproduced. It was pretty subtle unlike the first time a few days ago but again seemed most noticeable between 55-65mph. Above 65mph there were never any symptoms. I did get a few symptoms here and there in lower gear or lower mph. No noticeable change to RPM, or engine sound when the symptoms were present. I am starting to doubt it is the transmission. Doesn't seem to be a fuel supply problem either. I have a trip coming up and will see how it does on that. Hopefully it will be fine and not leave me stranded :) If I am able to get a more reliable symptomotology I will update. In the meantime I guess it is watching and waiting and poking aroud to isolate what has been causing this.
 
I had similar symptoms, was a bad no. 5 spark plug. I thought it was tranny at first, it was the plug missing.
 
I had similar symptoms, was a bad no. 5 spark plug. I thought it was tranny at first, it was the plug missing.

I'll have to check this out - thanks.
 
You might try turning off the overdrive if it comes back. I believe that is controlled by an engine temperature sensor, and if that temperature sensor is flaky it might be telling it to engage/disengage the OD. Just a thought...

I'll give this a try as well. I am starting to doubt it is the transmission at this point though. Engine RPM's don't change and the symptoms are more of an intermittent shudder without really any other symptoms. Doesn't hurt to give it a try though.
 
So, it has been a few months since I originally posted. I continue to have an intermittent shudder mostly noticed when accelerating. I can't reliably create the symptoms but have noticed it most when accelerating onto the freeway of accelerating between 55-65 MPH with RPM around 2400. RPMS don't change/jump around and engine doesn't seem to change note. It still accelerates fine apart from the shake/shudder.

After reading a bit more and driving it, I doubt it is the transmission but felt it is still likely in the drive line somewhere. I tried greasing the front and rear drive shafts and U joints without an improvement. I decided to take of the rear drive shaft today and will see if that eliminates the symptoms. The front drive shaft has a little rotational play when turning it by hand, but no play when puling/pushing in any direction. The rear didn't have any play at all. I am running stock suspension so I doubt a failed U joint is the problem but figured I would start by removing the rear followed by the front to see if I can eliminate the shudder. DRTDuck's suggestion that it may be a spark plug seems like a possibility as well. I didn't see his post until today. I'll have to look into that as well after getting through the drive shaft stuff.
 
If the transmission slips...like mine does, as mentioned the engine will rev up and you go nowhere but feel a lunging sensation or a jerk when it catches. When hammer the gas sometimes it revs up to 5k RPM and then catches if that's a better visual for you. If you're having a power loss and shudder on acceleration there are a number of things to check, given that it happens in a specific gear range/ loading of the engine I would not look at a fuel pump or fuel pressure regulator first. Toyota and ford or any other domestic manufacturer are in no way comparable as far as parts longevity. Fuel pumps last the life of the vehicle in the case of older Japanese vehicles fuel pump replacement is not often heard of, but I can tell you I've replaced countless domestic fuel pumps. I've even seen the same vehicle 3 times in a 6 year period for the fuel pump ( Pontiac) lasting about 40k a fuel pump, but I hardly ever replaced the fuel pump in a Nissan or Toyota or Honda. That being said, FPR's are much in the same boat as the fuel pumps. I would start by checking the ignition system. Cap, Rotor, plugs, plug wires, resistance check the ignition coil, test the igniter. One question that first comes to mind is, when was the last time the Oxygen sensors were replaced? Some are good for 60k miles others 105k miles etc.. Also, check your air intake hose for cracks and make sure the clamps are snug. Unmetered air might be getting pulled in while under load screwing with your ECM's ability to calculate proper fueling.

RECAP:
Check plugs, wires, dizzy, ignition coil and igniter. I'm not sure whether your year had a crank position sensor, if so, check it.
If all is well, Use starter fluid or an unlit propane torch to check for intake leaks and leaks around other vacuum lines.
If that checks out, use a scan tool to check live data of Oxygen sensors, or if they haven't been replaced, replace them.
 
If there is play in the front driveshaft and not the rear, why didn't you pull the front driveshaft instead of the rear?
 
Could the slipping be your torque converter locking and unlocking?
 
Thanks for the responses.

Landcruisinmy93 - Thanks for the help. I agree that it probably isn't the fuel pump or regulator or transmission. I have been thinking about whether or not it is the spark plug/rotor/cap or wires but the symptoms are never present at idle. I would assume that over the last several months I would have had some symptoms at idle if it involved any of those components. I replaced both 02 sensors with OEM about 1 year ago. I doubt they went bad that fast. I also don't have a CEL - not always present when components go bad I know, but the engine seems to be doing fine. I'll look over the vacuum lines and air intake as well.

LS1FJ40 - I didn't have any specific reason that I took the rear out instead of the front. Partly wanted to see what it felt like driving it as a front wheel drive vehicle. I planned on taking both off anyway just to get a better idea of how everything hooks up and works. Is there not supposed to be any play at all with rotation of the front drive shaft? The U joints themselves don't seem to have play, it seems to have a little play where it connects to the front axle and transfer case. Is there a bearing in there that could be bad?

Alleycats - not sure if the torque converter is going out. I don't know how to check that or what the symptoms would be. I'll have to look it up. I also am thinking it may be the viscous coupler, but will have to read up on that as well unless anyone can chime in to point me away from that since I have no idea what symptoms would develop if either of those components started to fail.
 
Drove around with the rear drive shaft off. Still had symptoms so I guess it isn't that. I'll take off the front tomorrow and see if that changes anything. I also turned off the OD and still had symptoms as well. I don't think I have a clogged cat. Not sure how to check that. No overheating issues and after driving for the past few months I don't think there is any actual power loss. I'll keep on trying things out and post on my progress.
 
Back
Top Bottom