Think my engine is toast....

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

txgringo

SILVER Star
Joined
Mar 25, 2012
Threads
101
Messages
1,067
Location
Durango, CO
Last night after I got off the highway from an 80 mile drive, my engine started running really rough and then the temp started climbing. My temp never goes over 200, and when I stopped at the 2nd red light, my engine started kind of stumbling and I noticed my temp was at 212.

After I pulled out of the light the stumbling stopped, but the temp continued rising. I was thinking maybe the fan clutch had died, so when I got stuck at light #3 I shut her down since the temp rose from 212 to 220 in about 1/4 mile. When the light turned, I cranked it up and drove another 1/4 mile so I could pull into the parking lot of the Goodyear shop where I always get my minor work done. By the time I reached there, the temp was at 230.

Once I got stopped I immediately killed the engine and popped the hood. Radiator wasn't gurgling like crazy, and the reservoir had plenty of coolant in it, so I knew I wasn't dealing with a radiator leak/busted hose. My oil light stays on more than it stays off, but I had checked my oil before leaving the house and while it was less than a quart low (had planned to change it in the next couple days so I didn't add any). I checked it once again at this point and the oil level was slightly lower than at the start of my 160 mile round-trip drive, but the dipstick was still wet so I know I had oil in it. It wasn't foamy or milky, so I was still thinking maybe it was just a fan clutch.

I let it cool for about 15 minutes with the hood open, then attempted to crank it once more. There was a very loud "CLANK" and the engine would not turn over. Subsequent attempts to turn it over yield silence. Effen lovely. So I let it sit another 10 minutes and try once more, hoping for the best. Another loud "CLANK" but this time I could actually feel whatever caused the CLANK shake the vehicle.

Now I'm starting to accept reality and realize that any budget surplus I might have had for the next few months already has a destination.

Does anybody have any thoughts on what kind of damage I'm looking at? I'm preparing for the worst and need to start weighing my options ASAP.
 
Starting with your reservoir? If you lost a lot of coolant it does NOT follow that the reservoir would be empty or even low. This is the problem with recovery systems, and in general makes them very unreliable with regards to checking the actual content of the cooling system. With the engine cool what was the level in the actual radiator?

It could be the head gasket has failed? When the engine is switched off, remaining pressure in cooling system forces water into the combustion chamber, water is not compressible so the engine is effectively locked. Pull all the spark plugs and try to crank again.

regards

Dave
 
hopefully no bent rods if head gasket blew. pull spark plugs, let it cool 100%, check radiator level once cool, try turning it over again with no plugs.
 
^^^This^^^. If still any doubt you can do a compression test, but also I would drain/replace the oil but collect a sample of the used oil and send it to Blackstone labs for an engine oil analysis. That can reveal a coolant leak but also elevated wear metals. If you can get the engine running and you're sure you have a head gasket leak (and you need the vehicle as a daily driver) consider adding a bottle of the Bar's Professional Headgasket sealer, the one that costs about $40-50. MIght be worth a try to help get you back on the road.
 
Thanks guys. I'm waiting on a friend to pick me up and take me back to it so I can check it out. I had to leave it last night cuz I had the family with me and had to get the kids home.

Do I need to pull all the plugs to try to turn it over, or can I just pull a couple?

If it won't turn over with the spark plugs out, what's the next most likely culprit?

One other question, if I blew the HG shouldn't I be able to see evidence of coolant in the oil? e.g. foamy or milky looking?
 
Pull all. pressure in cooling system pushed coolant through bad hg into cyl. after shutting down. reservoir doesn't lower level until engine cools and draws it down. spin it over and stand back. probably blow it all over out plug hole.
 
All plugs
Oil does not always get contaminated, gasket could be blown around the fire ring.
Vacuum from engine cooling system will not always pull coolant from engine if there is a leak elsewhere, hence why I said it is no indication of the correct level. The recovery tank idea in a vehicle designed for overland travel is ridiculous, just like no oil pressure light, don't get me started!

regards

Dave
 
If the oil light was on. I'd be expecting a motor swap soon. There is very little oil in the 1fz once that light comes on.

Your phh has been replaced?

I've seen Temps on 80s from 185 to 220
Anything above and it's a warped head as well.

Did you try to run the heater to soak up some of that temperature?
 
I think the oil light comes on when it's down about 1.5 quarts. Still 6 in there, so that really shouldn't be a big deal. I agree it sounds like it's hydro locked from hg failure.
 
The temp hit 230 right before I shut it down.

Yes PHH was done and I ran the heat on high as soon as i saw the temp climbing.

Went back today and was able to crank it up on the first turnover. Still running rough as hell. Shut it down immediately and added 2 quarts of oil just to be safe. Upon next crank I got the CLANK again and it didn't start up.

Waited a little while then cranked it up and pulled it into the shop bay and added 1 gallon of antifreeze and changed oil. Had about 7 quarts of oil including the 2 I had just added, so it was very low but not dry. No sign of leaked coolant or oil under it from being parked overnight.

After the oil change got another CLANK and it didn't start up so I left it there for the night and will have it looked at by a more senior tech in tne morning. Not sure where to go from here, but definitely don't want to drive it yet.

Also noticed that the fan seemed to turn pretty easily by hand. Possible bad fan clutch? Thinking that could have been the start of my rising temp.
 
If it won't turn over it is probably hydro locked, although if it DID start once the liquid must have escaped somehow (bleed down or perhaps back through the HG breach?). I would pull all the plugs and turn it over, that would free it from the liquid (remember to blow out the spark plug well area so no debris gets into the cylinders). I just did this today on my 02 Dodge Dakota 4.7 that has been nursing a bad coolant leak and running rough and weak so I suspected HG failure. I ran Blue Devil head gasket sealer (get the more expensive ~$50 one, NOT the "pour-n-go") though it twice about a year ago and it has held until now. The other day I added nearly a gallon of coolant and it wouldn't turn over, so the missing coolant must have found its way into a cylinder or more after I shut it down the day before. I suspected cylinder no. 8 and pulled all plugs and had someone crank it while I watched the rust colored water fountain. To my dismay I saw no. 8 AS WELL AS nos. 3 and/or 5 spewing fluid, I couldn't tell with water going everywhere. Perhaps if I had been smarter I would have recorded it and watched the playback. Plug no. 8 was wet and the ground electrode was bent all the way to the center electrode by the force of the liquid pushing on it, but the other plugs looked normal (but well worn). I tried to upload some pics but it just fails. But the correct way is to do a compression test, and with all the plugs already out I will. But just turning it over demonstrated that the bottom is fine, no knocking or unusual noise, just easy turning, so that may give you some peace of mind. After you identify what cylinder(s) is(are) bad, you could try the HG sealer, but you must follow the directions precisely. I did it the lazy way and just ran it through the system without pulling the plug on the bad cylinder because I was too lazy to check which was bad and pull the plug. This leaves too much pressure in the cylinder for the sealer to be able to seal well because of the compression stroke. Removing the plug eliminates this pressure and allows it to seal better. My short cut may have hurt the healing process, maybe not (but I suspect it did and I might have gotten better results if I went the whole nine yards). So now I might try again the correct way, but if I have two or more bad cylinders I will probably just park it until I am ready to do the HGs.

Also when I pulled no. 5 I had to use a 4 foot pipe on a breaker bar and the eerie squeal sent chills up my spine because some moron must have cross threaded it. The bottom two threads are gone - worn flat. At least now I know the plugs aren't original because I doubt the factory would have done that, but who knows these days? The PO probably went to a quick lube grease monkey joint for a tune-up and some knuckle head forced the plug on. I just hope the aluminum head is OK.
 
My light comes on at 1 qt low and shows at the low mark on the dipstick. Still plenty of oil in there. Good luck txgringo.
 
I was lazy and tried to see if it would crank without pulling plugs, which it did. The senior tech at the Goodyear shop checked it out this AM and said it does have coolant in the oil, so definitely a blown HG.

Getting pricing on the kit from Beno now.

Anybody have a link to a thread with a reasonable "while you're in there" list? I want to do the things that are most likely deteriorated or likely to fail without going nuts in there. I don't want to miss opportunities while it's all opened up, but I am on a budget...

I'm also planning to replace the exhaust system and have the exhaust manifold and heat shield ceramic coated. I have a local company that will do the manifold (inside and out) for about $200. Thinking of what else I might want to do to it...

Anybody have experience (good/bad/otherwise) with thermal barrier coatings on other parts on the 1FZFE? (thinking maybe head, piston heads, and ???)?
 
I was lazy and tried to see if it would crank without pulling plugs, which it did. The senior tech at the Goodyear shop checked it out this AM and said it does have coolant in the oil, so definitely a blown HG.

Getting pricing on the kit from Beno now.

Anybody have a link to a thread with a reasonable "while you're in there" list? I want to do the things that are most likely deteriorated or likely to fail without going nuts in there. I don't want to miss opportunities while it's all opened up, but I am on a budget...

I'm also planning to replace the exhaust system and have the exhaust manifold and heat shield ceramic coated. I have a local company that will do the manifold (inside and out) for about $200. Thinking of what else I might want to do to it...

Anybody have experience (good/bad/otherwise) with thermal barrier coatings on other parts on the 1FZFE? (thinking maybe head, piston heads, and ???)?
Assuming you do the silver high temp on the exhaust, it should drop underhood temps a bit. Not sure anyone has done the coatings on piston tops/combustion chambers for the 1fz-fe yet. Might not need it unless you are planning on boost. Then again, you could benefit by going more on initial timing and preventing detonation. Unfortunately, you would be your own guinea pig on that one. If it were me, I'd do the exhaust and skip the internal coatings, the quality of combustion chamber design and precision tolerance of the engine in general makes the benefit of internal coatings negligible.
 
IMO, if you're going to have the exhaust manifolds out, the intake disconnected, and the head off, yank the damn thing out and rebuild it. The only tough parts left are transmission unbolt and motor mount reinstall. Plus think of all the "while you're in there" stuff you could knock out. And you get a nice result when you're done-

IMG_0481.webp
 
I don't have the knowledge or time to rebuild it myself, so I will have to get it done somewhere. I agree that a rebuild would be preferred, but not sure of the cost. I'll definitely weigh the option while I'm talking to a mechanic.

Does anybody have a ballpark of the parts and labor cost difference of a "full" rebuild vs. head gasket + front & rear main seals?

Anybody know a good shop in the Milwaukee area to go to for this? I'm asking a few people I know here, but most of the people I know here aren't "car people" and none of them are cruiser addicts...
 
Back
Top Bottom