This thread will document my engine replacement journey. The convo started in another thread, so I'll copy those posts here for clarity.
I'll save judgement until it gets a thorough inspection upon arrival. I have no record of previous maintenance, so prepared mentally for anything.
Hit a milestone on my commute home yesterday.
![]()
WOW! That's awesome! How about a recap of the past 350k miles? What needed to be replaced due to age? What failed miserably? What surprises you that it’s made it this far with no signs of failing? And any other info you feel like sharing?
I'm on the precipice of repairing/replacing the engine. I have been nursing an oil leak on the front of the engine, likely front main seal. It's been slowly eating coolant with no obvious escape evidence. It needs a timing service, I found plastic guide pieces in the oil pan last year. So I've been doing mental math on rebuilding versus engine swap. Right now the scale leans towards buying a junkyard engine and rebuilding as needed (heads, timing, seals).
My biggest repair in the last 19+ years was the A750F a couple years ago. I replaced the radiator just before that. There are some other things I've fixed that are documented in this tech section.
I'll start a new thread to document the process, but found an engine out of FL with 107K on it. It arrives at the end of the week. Observation #1: junk yards add core charges for the block now? I never knew. They also offer parts & labor warranties?! I went for the lowest cost option available which was no added warranty, it comes with a 6mo basic warranty. I'm going to eat the core charge to have spares on hand and save packing a shipping a block. My plan is to give it a thorough evaluation, then likely go ahead and rebuild heads, timing, water pump. So any kind of warranty seemed kind of unnecessary. I'm at $5,150 OTD.
I've wavered back and forth on whether to just stab the new engine in and run it for another 250K5150 is better than a new truck payment!! But I do wonder about something. The YouTube channel car care guy has a video on the 5.7 blowing a head gasket, in that video he argues that new engines normally cannot be rebuilt (machined) due to their casting design. He argued even head machining is a problem. Just something to think about. Not being negative. Just provoking thought.