Not Your Typical Rotor Wobble

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jan 1, 2011
Threads
16
Messages
131
Location
Breckenridge, CO
Soooo. I've had a slight steering wobble since installing new front brake rotors about 6 months back. (Also rebuilt front axle at this time) Yes, I broke in brakes after install...The wobble has gotten worse...flat out shakes the whole car violently when brakes are lightly applied. Seems oddly intermittent, but frequent. Maybe just an issue when brakes are warm? Definitely gets worse when car is loaded with 6 middle school guys... The wobble seems to dissipate when hard braking is initiated. I don't see any heat spots on rotors. For the record, the rotors are O'Reilly Auto el cheapo's.

I rotated tires to see if it could be a tire balance issue. No such luck. While I had the tires off I checked for play in bearings...found none. When spinning the rotors, I felt a slight, intermittent drag. I removed hubs on both sides to inspect the tightness of the wheel bearings...everything looked great. Spun both of the rotors with hubs off and they were both smooth as butter...re-installed hubs and the intermittent drag was back. both wheels...

What could this be? Are my problems related? Perhaps not. HELP!
 
Subbed because mine do this too haha I replaced rotors and pads, I am thinking its a bleeding issue for the brakes. mine is more of a pulsation than shake, but sounds similar. I have yet to check rear drums yet though
 
Soooo. I've had a slight steering wobble since installing new front brake rotors about 6 months back. (Also rebuilt front axle at this time) Yes, I broke in brakes after install...The wobble has gotten worse...flat out shakes the whole car violently when brakes are lightly applied. Seems oddly intermittent, but frequent. Maybe just an issue when brakes are warm? Definitely gets worse when car is loaded with 6 middle school guys... The wobble seems to dissipate when hard braking is initiated. I don't see any heat spots on rotors. For the record, the rotors are O'Reilly Auto el cheapo's.

I rotated tires to see if it could be a tire balance issue. No such luck. While I had the tires off I checked for play in bearings...found none. When spinning the rotors, I felt a slight, intermittent drag. I removed hubs on both sides to inspect the tightness of the wheel bearings...everything looked great. Spun both of the rotors with hubs off and they were both smooth as butter...re-installed hubs and the intermittent drag was back. both wheels...

What could this be? Are my problems related? Perhaps not. HELP!

You are in Breck and you put cheap Rotors on??? You basically threw money away. In that area of Colorado you need good Rotors. I have had good experiences with ebc rotors. Basically u bought cheap Rotors that have crappy metallurgy. So at different temperatures they warp different amounts. You could have them machined with a on the car lathe, but they will warp again in 2 or 3 months. Just cough up the dough and put some good Rotors on.
 
You are in Breck and you put cheap Rotors on??? You basically threw money away. In that area of Colorado you need good Rotors. I have had good experiences with ebc rotors. Basically u bought cheap Rotors that have crappy metallurgy. So at different temperatures they warp different amounts. You could have them machined with a on the car lathe, but they will warp again in 2 or 3 months. Just cough up the dough and put some good Rotors on.

astute observation! I did just move here 5 months ago...a little more than a month AFTER putting on the el cheapo rotors...and prior to moving here I was out of a job for 9 months...sometimes diapers trump quality parts;) You're right. It might be time for an EBC upgrade. BUT I wanted to explore other options before I committed the $$. The weird drag on the rotors has me stumped. I'm thinking separate issue than the death wobble, just wanted a few more opinions.

Subbed because mine do this too haha I replaced rotors and pads, I am thinking its a bleeding issue for the brakes. mine is more of a pulsation than shake, but sounds similar. I have yet to check rear drums yet though

Mine definitely has the shakes. The steering wheel goes bonkers. With quite a bit of force.
 
astute observation! I did just move here 5 months ago...a little more than a month AFTER putting on the el cheapo rotors...and prior to moving here I was out of a job for 9 months...sometimes diapers trump quality parts;) You're right. It might be time for an EBC upgrade. BUT I wanted to explore other options before I committed the $$. The weird drag on the rotors has me stumped. I'm thinking separate issue than the death wobble, just wanted a few more opinions.



Mine definitely has the shakes. The steering wheel goes bonkers. With quite a bit of force.
Check for play in your tie rod ends and sterring componenets. You could have something going on in your steering box. I just re read your post and didnt see that you checked.
 
Check for play in your tie rod ends and sterring componenets. You could have something going on in your steering box. I just re read your post and didnt see that you checked.

I thought that, too. Everything seemed tight when I had the front wheels off the ground...However, my PS pump is on its way out. It's leaking and has a horrible whine when cold. There is tons of air getting in the system (bubbles in reservoir). I'm guessing thats from the leak. Would that cause a bad wobble only when slightly braking?
 
I thought that, too. Everything seemed tight when I had the front wheels off the ground...However, my PS pump is on its way out. It's leaking and has a horrible whine when cold. There is tons of air getting in the system (bubbles in reservoir). I'm guessing thats from the leak. Would that cause a bad wobble only when slightly braking?

The way we test fleet stuff on fires is to have engine running and someone shimmy the steering back anf forth quickly because it will make it really apparent when a ball joint is going out. You might try that. It sounds like you are having a steering issue and it could be a couple factors adding up and PS pump dying is probably adding to it
 
How old is the steering dampener? Whereas I didn't have a shake or wobble, my steering felt dramatically better after replacing this very worn out part with a new one.
 
Before every purist goes dissing your rotors.
I took my rotors to get turned down at O'Reillys
They ruined one and gave me one of their $50 rotors as replacement free.
I have ran it for over a yr with no issues, so yes they will work.

  • Are you sure your Tie Rod and Drag Link Rod ends are tight. Mine were not and it gave a death wobble during braking?
  • Did you bleed the rear proportioning valve?
  • Did you get a Qt of brake fluid and bleed every caliper till a cup of fluid came out?
 
Cheep rotors are a hit or miss. I have had to re surface new rotors out of the box when I was working in an independent shop. The quality control isn't all that great, but a good majority work. I am currently running NAPA premium rotors with no problems (8 years). You can try having them surfaced, an on car lathe is best but off car will also work. There is also the possibility that the is a bad casting and they will just warp again but you wont know until you try. Cheapest fix is return the rotors to O'Reillys and get new ones under warranty.
 
How old is the steering dampener? Whereas I didn't have a shake or wobble, my steering felt dramatically better after replacing this very worn out part with a new one.
less than 1 year old. I installed a new one with the OME lift

Before every purist goes dissing your rotors.
I took my rotors to get turned down at O'Reillys
They ruined one and gave me one of their $50 rotors as replacement free.
I have ran it for over a yr with no issues, so yes they will work.

  • Are you sure your Tie Rod and Drag Link Rod ends are tight. Mine were not and it gave a death wobble during braking?
  • Did you bleed the rear proportioning valve?
  • Did you get a Qt of brake fluid and bleed every caliper till a cup of fluid came out?
I'm due a complete brake bleed/flush. I already have the fluid anticipating this. I'll get to that once this snow storm is over:) I need to get the wife in the car to hold the steering wheel while I wobble the tires and look at TRE's

Cheep rotors are a hit or miss. I have had to re surface new rotors out of the box when I was working in an independent shop. The quality control isn't all that great, but a good majority work. I am currently running NAPA premium rotors with no problems (8 years). You can try having them surfaced, an on car lathe is best but off car will also work. There is also the possibility that the is a bad casting and they will just warp again but you wont know until you try. Cheapest fix is return the rotors to O'Reillys and get new ones under warranty.
easier said than done. the closest O'Reilly's is now over an hour away. DOH
 
have you checked wheel bearings? Jack up the front end and try to wobble top/bottom.
 
have you checked wheel bearings? Jack up the front end and try to wobble top/bottom.

Try to wobble putting hands at 6 and noon, then 3 and 9.
 
Did you replace knuckle bearings? Did you get the races fully seated? What bout wheel bearings are they new? If you didn't seat the races all the way you will not be true causing wobble from the start. I also don't recommend cheap rotors now your gonna do it twice so how cheap are they?
 
Try rebuilding your calipers. I fought wheel shake braking issues for a couple years on my Cruiser and actually another vehicle of mine. I would usually buy all new pads and rotors and flush the fluid every 6-12 months depending on how bad the shakes got. Ended up rebuilding my calipers and sure enough there was pretty good pitting/rust spots on the sides of the caliper pistons. Cleaned them up and/or replaced the really bad pistons and no more issues since.
 
The weird drag on the rotors has me stumped.

Again, bad metallurgy. If the casting wasn't done right you can get uneven pad deposits that will just reform after being cleared, rotors that don't stay straight at different temperatures, etc.

Not that cheap rotors don't ever work well.. they are just much more likely to have problems than quality stuff.

Did you make sure the back of the hub was cleaned very well before bolting on the rotor? Anything in that interface will cause it to run out.

Brakes are one part that I am pretty convinced on running OEM, especially on a vehicle that has bigger tires/weight. They usually end up lasting longer and having less problems. That said, I'm very happy with the slotted EBCs on my Jetta.
 
You have 6 or 7% percent grades on i70 that are miles long in that area. The side roads can be steeper, those cheap Rotors don't stand a chance. If u lived in the Midwest, u might be fine with them, but not in Breckenridge. You will need high quality rotors, and make sure where the pads slide in the caliper has liberal brake lube added so the pads can return to their resting position freely.
 
As @ajax1 stated, did you seat the races properly? I am referring to the WHEEL BEARING races. They must be seated properly in the hub.

Second, depending on the method used to tighten and adjust the wheel bearings, you must make sure you are SEATING the bearings on the SPINDLE.

I just had a wheel bearing issue that I SWORE was worn out front brakes. I could BARELY feel the wobble in the RF wheel at 12 and 6. I had to have my son check it 3 times before he could feel what I was trying to show him. I was having intermittent wobble and the truck tended to want to wander all over the road and grab every seam. I also had brake shudder when applied heavily.

After I repacked the bearings and put everything together, I was tightening the wheel bearings and they were getting very tight, but didn't feel like they were seating. Finally, about 50 lb-feet, I felt them align and seat the inner races on the spindle. Then the wheel would spin like it was supposed to.

The procedure I use for wheel bearings is close to what is in the FSM, but actually follows directly the bearing setting for a 73-87 Chevrolet K20. This has proven out for me for many years.

Tighten the inner nut to 50 lb-ft while rotating the hub.
Loosen the inner nut 1-1/2 turns. Do NOT spin the hub while doing this.
Tighten the inner nut to 35 lb-ft while rotating the hub.
Loosen the inner nut 3/8 turn.
Install the locking washer.
Install the outer nut and tighten to 45 lb-ft.
Bend the ears on the locking washer, one inwards onto the inner nut and one outwards onto the outer nut.
Install the drive flanges accordingly and follow the FSM.

I had to re-do my wheel bearing at 28,500 miles since the last change because I forgot to clean and change my differential vent when I rebuilt the axle and it pushed all my diff oil into my birf knuckle as well as out the spindle and contaminated the wheel bearings on the RF side.

ALSO:
Check your steering arm nuts/studs. Torque to 71 lb-ft. Top and bottom, both sides. Tap the steering arm with a heavy dead blow hammer while torquing to get them correctly tight. The wheels should be off the ground when doing this.
 
Yes, I have checked the wheel bearings...pretty sure I mentioned that in original post. There in 0 play in wheel bearings. They are brand new and OEM. I got all new OEM races, bearings, seals, gaskets, etc from CruiserParts when I rebuilt the front axle. I took my time on install and would imagine that races are fully seated. Guess that could be a thing...

BUT! The weird intermittent drag when turning the rotors only happens when hubs are installed. When I took the hubs off to inspect wheel bearings, the rotors rotated SUPER smooth. Then after re-installing hubs the drag came back. Seems like that would dictate that the wheel bearings are fine and when the axles are engaged there is a weird drag & release thing going on...

@BILT4ME, that was the wheel bearing tightening process I have always used on my cruisers.
 
I'm not wondering bout if your wheel bearings are tight it's about if you fully seated the races when you pounded them into the hub, if they are not fully seated then you would be slightly clocked giving you a interment noise or drag
 
Back
Top Bottom