How to test coolant

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Mar 10, 2008
Threads
70
Messages
435
Location
Baton Rouge
got a cheap coolant tester made by Prestone:

prestoneAccessories0.jpg


the instructions say this and this only:

1) Test when engine is cool.

2) Draw up fluid, inspect. If rusty or dirty, drain, flush and refill cooling system.

3) Pointer must be totally immersed. Fluid should be level with horizontal line at top of tester. Tap to dislodge air bubbles. Pointer shows degree of protection.

No directions on adding coolant or H20. Freaking retarded Prestone company...

The pointer indicates -22* to freeze and IIRC 250* boil over. It does not tell me the ratio of coolant to H2O nor do the instructions tell me how to adjust the mix either way. Anyone got pointers? Should I buy a different tester because this one is s***?
 
...No directions on adding coolant or H20. Freaking retarded Prestone company...

The pointer indicates -22* to freeze and IIRC 250* boil over. It does not tell me the ratio of coolant to H2O nor do the instructions tell me how to adjust the mix either way. Anyone got pointers? Should I buy a different tester because this one is s***?

It's not crap. It provides all the information most anyone is going to need to know. One side is 'boil over protection' and this is with a 15 psi cap, just like the lable says. When you raise the pressure, you raise the boiling point. The other size is 'freeze point'. The lable says it's for a 50/50 mixture good for -34F. This is not dependant on pressure. It has a scale to show different freeze points so you can read/set anything you want. For example, if you measure OF freeze point and you want something higher, add more concentrate.

I think they assume the user has a minimum understanding/skill level.

Does a tire gage come with instructions on what to do if you read to low or too high a pressure?
 
Last edited:
I think they assume the user has a minimum understanding/skill level.

Does a tire gage come with instructions on what to do if you read to low or too high a pressure?

Well, very minimal understanding here. I just figured that the tester would give the ratio so I could adjust accordingly. But by your info, more coolant = lower freeze point. They should just put that on the package. they should probably put instructions on a tire gauge too :flipoff2:

did you mean if you want something lower (i.e. below zero) than 0*F, then add more coolant? A little confusing, just saying.
 
You aren't worried about cold down there are you? That little snow storm was a once every ten year event.:p
 
If one is buying the pre-mixed version of coolant then you get what you get. If you are buying the concentrate and adding distilled water, then you can add more/less of one or the other to come up with whatever ratio you desire/require.

The 50/50 ratio is only a guideline. What one should ultimately be concerned with freeze/boil over protection. Leaves less for interpretation.
 
Well, very minimal understanding here. I just figured that the tester would give the ratio so I could adjust accordingly. But by your info, more coolant = lower freeze point. They should just put that on the package. they should probably put instructions on a tire gauge too :flipoff2:

did you mean if you want something lower (i.e. below zero) than 0*F, then add more coolant? A little confusing, just saying.

If you want something lower than 0*F you use more antifreeze.

anti- : prep. Opposed to; against.

freeze : verb. To convert into ice.
 
Obviously what everyone is saying is true: the higher the concentration of anti-freeze, the lower the freezing point of the fluid. However, you don't want to go too high in concentration as water is actually a better heat transfer fluid than anti-freeze. So it's a bit of a trade-off. Otherwise, everyone would just run 100% anti-freeze and not worry about it (neglecting the marginal cost of course).

I think the "best" concentration is the minimum that gets you to the freeze protection that you're looking for plus a little extra to be conservative.
 
To simplify what all have said:

60 per cent antifreeze / 40 per cent water = better freeze & boil over protection than 50/50 mix.

40 per cent antifreeze / 60 per cent water = less freeze and boil over protection than 50/50 mix.

In other words, the more pure anti freeze or greater the ratio, the better the protection. However, you can not run pure antifreeze alone, because that will freeze/boil over at approx same temp as pure water. Antifreeze must be mixed with water for it to work. HTH
 
Last edited:
However, you can not run pure antifreeze alone, because that will freeze/boil over at approx same temp as pure water. Antifreeze must be mixed with water for it to work.

I don't believe that. The higher the antifreeze concentration, the higher/lower the boil/freeze point, period. (Edit: Not quite correct; see post #10)

WarDamnEagle's got it right: It's a trade-off between boil/freeze protection and cooling/heat transfer capability.

Curtis
 
Last edited:
In other words, the more pure anti freeze or greater the ratio, the better the protection. However, you can not run pure antifreeze alone, because that will freeze/boil over at approx same temp as pure water. Antifreeze must be mixed with water for it to work. HTH

Not exactly but close. Ethylene Glycol concentrations lower the freezing point of the mixture up to a concentration of 70% (Ethylene Glycol to H2O) at which point the freezing point is less than -60F. Above concentrations of 70% the freezing point increases until it's 10F at 100% Ethylene Glycol (vs. 32F for pure water). The boiling point on the other hand, increases throughout the concentration range and 100% Ethylene Glycol has a boiling point of 390F (vs. 212 for water).

I haven't looked it up but I still recall that the heat transfer coefficient is higher for pure water than pure ethylene glycol. Therefore, even though at high ethylene glycol concentrations the fluid won't boil over, the engine temperature will increase versus a lower concentrations as not enough heat can be removed from the system in the radiator (due to the lower heat transfer coefficient of the fluid).

Use 50:50 +/- 10% and be done with it. :D
 
.

I haven't looked it up but I still recall that the heat transfer coefficient is higher for pure water than pure ethylene glycol. Therefore, even though at high ethylene glycol concentrations the fluid won't boil over, the engine temperature will increase versus a lower concentrations as not enough heat can be removed from the system in the radiator (due to the lower heat transfer coefficient of the fluid).


Minimum - 50/50 mix protection: -34 F freeze; +265 F boilover

Maximum - 70/30 mix protection: -84 F freeze; +276 F boilover

From off the back of the Prestone Extended Life concentrate container.

Spillman, don't let all this techno-babble depress you. Follow the instructions that are usually on the back of a high quality coolant container. They can be used with the instructions that came with the tester. IMHO Prestone is a reliable brand.


 
Not depressed. This is just the information I needed and given (by most) in a manner that is easy to understand. Thanks.

Darwood: I understand the etymology of the word antifreeze, but recalled from HS physics class that different concentrations produce different results. Instead of contributing to the thread, you came off like a dick. Hope you feel better about yourself.
 
Not depressed. This is just the information I needed and given (by most) in a manner that is easy to understand. Thanks.

Darwood: I understand the etymology of the word antifreeze, but recalled from HS physics class that different concentrations produce different results. Instead of contributing to the thread, you came off like a dick. Hope you feel better about yourself.

Someone has to take over for Junk.
 
isn't toyota red something other than ethylene glycol?
if so, then wouldn't the prestone doodad be calibrated wrong?

Since freezing is basically impossible here, I usually go with the exact scientific ratio of "dump a gallon of concentrate in radiator, fill with water" that should give somewhere near 25-30%

if you want somewhere near 50%, dump two gallons, fill with water.

Do you anticipate parking outdoors in -34* temps? If not, then pretty close to 50% is probably going to work just fine for you.
 
Back
Top Bottom