Head gasket second time

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Mar 12, 2014
Threads
31
Messages
368
Location
Philadelphia
So I did the HG on my '94 last spring, and it blew again this week. I haven't checked cylinder 5 compression yet but cylinder 6 is at 30psi and the plug is covered in black soot- it's a dead hole. The first time around my machine shop sold me a shim- basically a precision cut piece of sheet metal- that got sprayed with copper HG sealant and went between the head and gasket. This was because they shaved 15 thousandths off my head due to pitting. The shim was .020 thick to make up for this. I also used a cheap gasket (idiot). I never had the block decked and I'm not sure I want to this time either because of the cost. I realize there's a lesson in here to be learned.

I'm wondering now what guys know about Cometic head gaskets,( @scottryana I've read some of your comments about them, maybe you could chime in?). Maybe I should look into a .015 Cometic and forget the shim? It seems to me maybe it would seal better than the shim/ gasket combo. I've never priced one, maybe it's cheaper to deck the block and run Toyota parts this time and forget the shim/spacing. Short of going all out on this engine, what can I do differently this time? Can I skip the shim and use a Toyota gasket?
 
I have only heard bad things about aftermarket gaskets. The Toyota one is the one to go with if you don't want to do it again. I am not sure about this shim, but I am not an engine expert. I would get a 2nd opinion if that makes sense.
 
I just did my head gasket, decked the head along with a valve job, Toyota gasket, new Toyota head bolts and valve shims hope it lasts because that job was a pain in the a$$. I feel for you, I wouldn't want to do that again any time soon.
 
Seeing that your 18 year old engine probably doesn't have the same compression it did when new (lower now), and 0.020" taken off the head won't cause interference with the pistons, and you have an EFI engine that can optimize timing, and you could have the option of just using higher octane gasoline if it did ping...

I would chuck that crappy shim, clean up the head and block deck again, don't use copper coat, and use a genuine Toyota head gasket.
 
something makes me cringe when I hear the word "shim" on a head gasket. I am fairly sure my machine shop would never recommend shimming here but would tell me instead that the head is not usable and I need to get a new one. I am not an engine expert though.

At this point I would pull the engine and just completely rebuild it. That way you can be sure the head and block can be decked to match. Use a toyota head gasket.
 
I went the shim route on a 22re 8 years ago.sold the truck after 5 of those years to a painter, it it's still on the road.so shims ain't all bad
 
How many miles are on the engine? Does it use oil? Does it leak much? Was there visible cross hatching on the cylinder walls last time you were in there? Your budget is the biggie. What would be best for me might not be so good for you.
In order to use and MLS gasket like the cometic, you must deck the block as well so it's perfectly flat but if you are not running forced induction an MLS gasket is way over kill.
 
The machine shop is a reputable place, and they have had a lot of success with these shims which a is why they recommended one to me. Apparently there's no spec for how much can be removed/ overall height and this uncertainty was another motivating factor for recommending it. I wasn't too excited about the copper coat stuff but that was what the instructions said to do.

A full rebuild is not an option right now, neither is a Cometic gasket since I learned that it's best to have 2 freshly machines surfaces for MLS gaskets. I'm not pulling this engine; unless I'm really surprised when I pull this head off and bad stuff happened in 20k miles. It still had cross hatching on the cylinders the first time I was in there.

I'm going to do some searching about timing chain retard and valve/ piston clearance. If it confirms that there's nothing to worry about I'm gonna skip the shim this time. I should get a chance to pull the head off this week and then I will know exactly what failed/ where.
 
@baldilocks great minds think alike.

It uses like 1 qt. in 7,500 miles, leaks none, has 235k on it.
Sounds like all you really need to do is replace the HG with OEM. How much has been removed from your head total? If the .015" you had removed previously is all then I don't see why you need anything but the new OEM gasket.
I did my 94 last spring as well. I went with ARP studs. They are cheaper than the bolts and I don't believe it is possible to get the threads in the block 100% cleaned out so as not to affect your initial torque of 29lb.ft.
I chased the threads out of mine. When I went to installed the studs in the block some went in by fingers only and some required the use of an Allen wrench. This told me that obtaining even clamping force on the HG would be impossible with the use of bolts. I figured that the use of OEM gaskets and the studs instead of bolts would removed some of the mystery if mine were to blow again as yours has.
Btw, the PO had my engine rebuilt 16k miles prior the HG failure. I called the shop and found out that they used FelPro gaskets and seals. And of course re-used the head bolts because they were in spec.
 
Last edited:
@baldilocks thanks for sharing, I think I'm gonna go the same route of Mr. T gasket and ARP studs. I had a weird feeling about the torque specs, they all felt slightly different as I torqued them down.

I have basically the same history as your PO: chased the threads, reused in-spec bolts and cheapest gasket on Rockauto.

Can I ask, what did you do to prep your block surface? What ARP kit did you use, Opel, Supra or paradise racing?

Also I'm thinking of just checking my head for straightness and cleaning it up good. Like you said, budget is making some decisions here but I'm not into doing this again for awhile.

Thoughts?

Edited for spelling
 
Last edited:
I used the Opel kit on mine. You torque it to 80ft. ft/lbs using the OEM sequence in stages per ARP's instructions. I am sure the cheap gasket was the source of your failure if the head and block were both straight. The shim probably had little to do with it, and I agree with the others that the engine will run OK without the shim. You can calculate the difference in valve timing if you want to know what change you are making and then decide. If you use a cometic MLS, you will need to deck the block. As long as your engine is not overheating, I'm sure that putting an OEM gasket between two straight surfaces with proper clamping will get the job done.
 
I used the Opel kit on mine. You torque it to 80ft. ft/lbs using the OEM sequence in stages per ARP's instructions. I am sure the cheap gasket was the source of your failure if the head and block were both straight. The shim probably had little to do with it, and I agree with the others that the engine will run OK without the shim. You can calculate the difference in valve timing if you want to know what change you are making and then decide. If you use a cometic MLS, you will need to deck the block. As long as your engine is not overheating, I'm sure that putting an OEM gasket between two straight surfaces with proper clamping will get the job done.

Thanks for the input. Did you have to trim any of your studs with the Opel kit?
 
@baldilocks thanks for sharing, I think I'm gonna go the same route of Mr. T gasket and ARP studs. I had a weird feeling about the torque specs, they all felt slightly different as I torqued them down.

I have basically the same history as your PO: chased the threads, reused in-spec bolts and cheapest gasket on Rockauto.

Can I ask, what did you do to prep your block surface? What ARP kit did you use, Opel, Supra or paradise racing?

Also I'm thinking of just checking my head for straightness and cleaning it up good. Like you said, budget is making some decisions here but I'm not into doing this again for awhile.

Thoughts?

Edited for spelling
I used a gasket scraper and red scotch brite while my shopvac maintained contstant vacuum to keep the crap from falling down into the block. Mine had no pits and was pretty easy to clean up since it had only 16k miles on it.
I borrowed my machinists Sterret straight edge to check my deck for flatness per the FSM.
I used the 1FZ-FE stud kit from Paradise racing even though he said I did not need to because my engine is normally aspirated. I realize that there is a lot of talk about the 1FZ kit being "too short". I called and spoke with an ARP engineer and he said there is no need for the stud to bottom out in the hole. The main thing was that the stud was into the hole something like twice the diameter. Elsewhere I read that most of the holding power of any stud is in the first ten threads. My head studs are 16 turns into the block which left enough for two threads to protrude past the nut. I used the OEM washers because they are larger diameter than the ARP washers. Hope this helps.
 
Last edited:
Not an expert in this area, just had a thought on the concerns some people have mentioned about milling the head and/or block and how that loss of height might affect the timing:

Assuming that the timing chain tensioner is designed to take up slack in the chain due to wear or stretching over time, and knowing that it is designed to push out more (tightening the chain up) than it needs to compared with a new chain. Then assume if the chain gets a bit more slack in it by milling the head and/or block slightly shortening the distance between the cam shafts and crank shaft, couldn't the tensioner take up that slack ending up with no effect on the timing??

Below is a photo of a timing chain tensioner just after it was removed, the timing chain in this engine had well over 200,000 miles on it. You can see that only about 1 cm of the plunger (varnish on the exposed tip) had been poking out of the tensioner body with at least 2 cm's of travel remaining.

So what's the consensus of the forum, can the timing chain tensioner take up slack in the timing chain that might result after milling the head and/or block (to a point) resulting in no change in the timing??

1FZFE timing chain tensioner.webp
 
Last edited:
Right on @baldilocks I'm going the same route then.

@Kernal I hadn't though much about timing chain play, but you do have a point that there seems to be plenty of travel left in that tensioner.
 
If you use a cometic gasket you will need to machine both the block and head surface to cometic's specs or else its going to leak.

If you dont want to machine the block i would use a OEM headgasket.
 
Back
Top Bottom