Head Gasket Questions

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Oct 24, 2016
Threads
18
Messages
69
Location
Astoria, OR
Good Day Mud,

I have been losing coolant from somewhere on my FZJ, I suspect a very minor HG failure, and am looking at getting the gasket swapped out. Here is the problem, I live on a small island in AK, and there is no machine shop in town to test the head, and make sure that it is not cracked. Would it still be worth it to get at the gasket and not worry about the milling and smoothing of the head and block? Also, none of the shops in town are willing to do a full rebuild. My FZJ is a 97 has 157K miles, and I know that the HG tends to fail around 150K so this seems like the problem. The PO did not do much beyond basic maintenance, so I have done things like the coolant hoses (including rear heater, and PHH bypass) and replaced the radiator. Any advice on this would be appreciated.

- Jay
 
Yeah, I have looked at all the common points for coolant to be leaking, and cant find any drips, I have run it for 45 minutes with cardboard under and had no drippings or anything, but I have had to add appx 3 gallons of coolant over the last 4 months. Also, it wont hurt to have the HG done in case I try to sell it in AK, as I like the idea of getting a HZJ-73 at some point.
 
I’d do a leak down test before tearing into it. If there are no shops in your area then it sounds like you may be doing it yourself. If it has always been a slow leak, I would probably tend to think that the head isn’t cracked unless it was ran without water. It would be preferred to bring it to a machine shop, but if not possible there are ways to check the head yourself. The FSM covers it fairly well.
 
I’d do a leak down test before tearing into it. If there are no shops in your area then it sounds like you may be doing it yourself. If it has always been a slow leak, I would probably tend to think that the head isn’t cracked unless it was ran without water. It would be preferred to bring it to a machine shop, but if not possible there are ways to check the head yourself. The FSM covers it fairly well.
Ok, I will dig into the FSM, and hopefully figure it out. There are shops in town, but just no machinists. The engine has never run without water, but does need to be consistently refilled. I have never even had the temp gauge go above center.
 
Can you rent a combustion gas test kit locally? I'd also do a leak down test. Can also have Blackstone do an oil analysis with a kit they send to you. But it does sound like a head gasket issue. I doubt the head is damaged unless overheated.
 
Can you rent a combustion gas test kit locally? I'd also do a leak down test. Can also have Blackstone do an oil analysis with a kit they send to you. But it does sound like a head gasket issue. I doubt the head is damaged unless overheated.
Nobody local has the combustion gas test kit. Thank you everybody for the ideas.
 
I think usually cylinder 6 is the problem when the head gasket goes. You could see if that plug is a lot cleaner than the others (steam cleaned)? I know when I did my head gasket I read every post by Robbie PowderPig on the subject here, he knows his stuff!!!

I had my head just barely machined when I did mine. You don't want hardly any taken off at all. My head wasn't warped, but just 'cleaned' it up. They did the valve seals too which you should probably do too. Good luck!
 
Would a minor HG failure not present any other symptom besides coolant consumption? I thought it also would show smoke on start up or acceleration.
 
You can ship your head out. You can check the block with a proper straight edge.

Three gallons of coolant just doesn’t disappear in four months. Your hunch is probably right, you are burning it. Do the leak down and compression test before you dive in. You can also test you cooling system for combustion gasses. All the tools to do this are relatively cheap besides the proper straight edge.

Cheers
 
Given the relatively low mileage and your lack of accessible machining help.....you might consider using one the premium Head Gasket Leak products. They do actually work....even if not the best/permanent solution. Depending on where and how you are losing the coolant (most likely into a cylinder) this would probably solve that issue.

IF you continue to lose coolant after trying the Stop Leak product, you're only out $50.00 and need to dig further into the issue. I wouldn't spend the time sending off any samples to Blackstone. You already KNOW you are losing coolant. The amount you are losing isn't being lost externally (hose leaks, water pump, Oil cooler, etc) or you'd see on the ground or on the engine. So its internal. IF it were going into the oil pan you would know that too (unexplained volume increase and milky looking oil). So its likely being burned off into a cylinder. This situation (along with coolant leaks to the edge of the head) are exactly what the stop leak products are made for.

I don't normally promote their use but yours sounds like a good candidate.
 
Pressure test the cooling system for hours with the plugs out and oil drained/drain plug left out. pump to max-pump as needed to keep up. . - chk each cyl for coolant and drips out the oil drain plug. I'd be most concerned about warping. use a good straightedge.
 
Do you get shipments from Amazon up there?

Order the test kits online as well as any tools. You may spend $100 in tools, but it's worth it to properly diagnose the problem.

Compression tester with Leak-down gauges
Cooling system pressure test kit
Exhaust Gases Test Kit
Replacement hoses
Radiator Cap (OEM only)

Check the #1 bypass hose that goes from the left side of the block up to the bottom of the throttle body. They are also known to get oil-soaked and fail.

I found it was relatively easy to replace, but some here cuss and swear at it. I bought the OEM hose (as well as new OEM clamps) and it has the marks where the clamp goes, so you spit in the end of the hose with the clamp already on it, and you push it on.

What happens if you remove the head and find out it isn't flat? Then you have to machine it anyway.

I would hedge my bet and order a used replacement head from someone on this site, possibly pay to have them refurbish it, and have it shipped in to you. This way, you pull your head, and you're ready to install a freshly rebuilt one that is known good, clean, and correct. I would recommend shipping it well secured in a wooden crate.

Internet makes a lot of things possible when you're that remote.

I like the suggestion made by @Howard705 . It's free other than the cooling system pressure tool kit.
Pull your spark plugs, post pics on here, make sure to identify #1 thru 6, and we can all armchair QB it from there.
 
Would a minor HG failure not present any other symptom besides coolant consumption? I thought it also would show smoke on start up or acceleration.
If you have a coolant leak in a head gasket it doesn't always make it's way into the combustion chamber. Sometimes it'll leak out past the gasket and down the outside of the block. An external coolant leak in a head gasket is not nearly as common as one that leaks into the combustion chamber, but it does, and can happen.
 
You can ship your head out. You can check the block with a proper straight edge.

+1 on SNLC, Just this morning I shipped my head out with the camshafts and valve cover on to a machine shop as the small town I live in doesn't have anything to do such work. I ordered a straight edge from Amazon for myself. I included the FSM and some general instructions and my phone # from them to just contact me with any questions they have about the work they're doing on it. An acquaintance of mine just did the same thing with his 22RE engine with the same machine shop all went smoothly for him and hopefully will for you too if you decide to go this route!
 
Not much to add other than I lived in Ketchikan for a couple summers and am determined to live there again...on of my favorite places in the world.

I'm surprised you don't have access to a pressure test kit...the napa and o'reilley's couldn't get it for sure?
If you do end up needing to machine your head, you may just have to send it up the way to Juneau, I'm pretty sure they have machine shops there. Is the AMH running?
 
Thank you all for your replies. I have a few tests to run, and have a tentative appointment set up for a shop in about 2.5 weeks. Yeah, Ketchikan is amazing, and I would love to stay here longer, but both Napa, and O'Reillys sounded super confused when I asked about both types of test kits. in regards to hoses and radiator cap, both have been fully replaced in the last 1.5 years, all the hoses still look brand new, and there is very little oil leaking from this engine (I did the valve cover within about 2 weeks of owning it and that was the only oil leak aside from a bit of blow by on top of the cover). Looks like I just need to order the pressure tester on amazon and hope that it ships in a timely manner. I worry about ordering a replacement head in that it greatly increases the cost on a job that the wife is already questioning.
 
Thank you all, I got the exhaust gas test done on the coolant, it turned out that the heater control valve had failed, but only with a hairline fracture that atomized the coolant when the engine was running under high pressure(hence why i didnt see any drips, it was a super fine mist...). I got that replaced, and the tranny flushed due to a shudder around 45-50 mph, think that it is due to a stuck solenoid. Thanks again for all the help and insight.
 
OMFG - an OP who actually comes back and provides the resolution and doesn't just leave us all hanging. You are a hero.

^^^^

Yep, nice when someone actually follows up on an issue. It's for the benefit of others down the line.

Good job OP!
 
Back
Top Bottom