hard top or soft top?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jul 16, 2004
Threads
120
Messages
768
Location
Vancouver, BC
help me out here. My cruiser has no top or doors. Right now it's only a summer toy that sees action from April to September. I love driving topless, but on rainy days the bikini top doesn't really cut it. We get lots of rain although the past few summers have been pretty dry. I think the look of the hardtop is what really gives the cruiser its distinct look that sets it apart from jeeps cosmetically, but many cruiser owners i've talked to say the soft top is the better choice. I've been looking for a late model hardtop, but they seem tough to come by in decent shape and i'm not really skilled enough or equipped with the proper tools to do a hard top resto project. What would you do if you were in my situation?
 
hard top resto might not be as hard as you think... most of the top is a single layer of steel that would mostly just need hammering to remove dents, sanding the rust, spray primer and then splash some paint on. my suggestion would be find one (in any condition) and throw yourself at it, probably turn out easier than you think. barring that, a soft-top could be used but that leaves you pretty susceptible to theft/vandalism (you live in surrey, no?) i've never ridden in a soft-topped cruiser, but i've heard it's very noisy, very windy, and generally not as nice.

that being said my top is off right now too, waiting about a week for my bikini top to come in. not sure that i'll put it back on until the fall, and i love it :cheers:
 
I say soft top, You can be fully coverd or just the opposite, Its mostly for the better weather months. On mine and like many others you can roll or zip out the windows for more air flow or fold the whole thing down.
I think there is alot of noise in both hard or soft top, Soft has wind noise, hard has rattled from ALL sorts of things. If security was an issue I wouldnt drive it at all, It dosnt take much to get into hard doors, I have learned to drive mine wit only the bare neccesity*sp
Good luck
 
I'd stick with a soft-top- gives you a lot more options when the weather is nice, or if you need to take it off for some reason its a hell of alot easier. I went with the Bestop for mine. Also, if you're wheeling it at some point, keeps the weight down and lower center of gravity.
 
My hard top has been in my shed for over a year. I ran my soft top year round. But, I keep it in the garage and it is not my DD. I did take it on a Snow Run and drove the highway for an hour in cold (15 deg) weather to get there. I have a good heater and had no issues.

The Top is going to stay in the shed!
 
When my 40 was my daily driver, I put my hard top on every October. I'd usually be itching to go topless by March and pull it off on the first nice weekend. Now that my 40 is my toy rather than my everyday transportation, I leave the soft top on exclusively, except when it has no top at all. Here are some things to consider:

1. If you plan to take the hard top off for the summer, do you have a place to store it? It's way big, especially if you leave it intact as one piece.

2. Do you do lots of highway driving? Soft tops are very noisy at faster speeds. I actually wear earplugs on my annual journey to Moab.

3. How much wheeling do you do? Hard tops are heavy. Wheeling is more fun with a soft top -- you have a lower center of gravity.

4. Keep in mind that many hard tops leak! My soft top is more water tight than my hard top, believe it or not! And even after new rubber and a bunch of silicone caulk, my hard top still leaks.

5. I HIGHLY recommend the newest version of the Fasttrac top from Specialty Top Co. here in Denver. I have owned three soft tops in 10 years, and this new top beats all others hands down. (Unless you are looking for the OEM style top, in which case your options are much different.) The coolest part is that all the windows in the back zip out -- you end up with a bikini top that is the full length of the Cruiser. It's very slick.
 
Hi All:

Which top to chose for your 40 Series depends a lot on where you live and what you use the rig for.

You live in Vancouver, B.C. which is similar weather-wise as well as 'wheeling-wise to where I live, which is Seattle, WA. so my comments may be applicable.

The hard top is much more preferable in wet and cold weather than the soft top. Also, a soft top that gets wet and stays wet for weeks/months WILL have mold and mildew issues (ask me how I know this!) At least in the case of a Kayline Fast Trac soft top.

That said, the soft top is quite flexible, and if you have a garage or other covered parking spot for the truck (so the soft top can dry out on a regular basis) mold/mildew situation is much less of an issue.

With the soft top you can have the top fully deployed with doors for almost as much weather protection as the hard top but a bit colder inside. Then on nice mild Fall or Spring days you can roll-up the back and/or the sides for more of an open-air driving experience. If it is really a warm and sunny day one can lower the soft top completely and toss the soft doors in the bed! With the hard top it is either "on" or "off" - no in between possible, and you better hope you gauged the weather correctly!! ;-)

When it comes to which top to run when off-road, it really depends on what sort of trails you run. More mild, open trails the hard top is fine. On off-camber trails the hard top will affect the truck's center of gravity. On really tight trails there is an excellant chance of busting out the corner windows on the hard top.

The typical tougher 'wheeling trail here in the Pacific Northwest is muddy, rocky, rutted, off-camber track weaving tightly through big fir trees. Many of my buds will take-off the soft top to prevent damage from tree limbs. On one trail at the Evans Creek ORV park here in Washington State both myself and the other guy I was 'wheeling with got our soft tops torn on a tree branch.

So, there you go - easy choice! ;-) I agree that the hard top gives the 40 Series one of its distinctive "looks." I have a six year old Kayline Fast Trac, which is O.K., but I'd go for one of those OEM replicable soft tops imported from Pakistan if buying a soft top today.

Regards,

Alan
 
I had the specter extreme top with the back and that did pretty good job of keeping the rain out. I hear it rains in Vancouver, I agree that hard tops are nice and yes they are not that tough to clean up.. Get a $60 Makita Grinder with a wire wheel and you will be good to go :)
 
Have you got somebody handy to help you lift the hard-top off when you want to go topless ? Its heavy and ackward and takes up a lot of space.
Get a Paki-top from Eshan. :D
 
i'm having a weather top made

SizzleChest said:
how are those paki-tops for rear visibility? (shoulder checking and whatnot)
from a buddy of mine.he can put windows in it if i want.so you would still be able to run a trail and still be able to see. i'll post pics in a couple of weeks, maybe after moab.
 
nuclearlemon said:
as much as i love the hardtops, i would say got soft. much more versatile.


Concur. OEM soft if you can help it.
 
My junk never had a hard top since I bought it .... but they do look cool. :cool:

Had me a soft top for a while ... but it blew off goin' across Wyomin' 'bout 10 years ago. :mad:

Had me a cool camo bikini top .... but it got all screwed up when I rolled.

Ain't got nuthin' now. :D
 
dude id deffinately go with the soft top. if somebody dosent know the difference between a jeep and a Landcruiser, then they dont. it dosent matter any way. I have almost the same kind of landcruiser you do and landcruisers are what set us apart from those jeepsters. we know we have the better toy and thats all that matters. go with what you want and most of all have fun with it. you only have the luck of owning an LC once in your life. enjoy it!
 
My BJ-42 has the hardtop, and I like the look a lot. And, since both my 40's have AC, I'll probably be leaving the hardtops on. I have to admit to lusting after an open, windshield down experience sometime though. Maybe I'll have to get a dedicated trail rig.
 
It's a tough choice. I love my hard top. They look awesome, which is prolly the only reason I put it back on in the fall. Ya gotta go topless in summer. I only run a bikini, but I'm gonna spring for a soft top soon.

Don't know which one yet, but the oem style looks best.
 
Back
Top Bottom