From a mechanical reliability perspective, J80 or 4runner?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Oct 19, 2016
Threads
1
Messages
5
I'm in the market for a J80 or 3rd Gen 4runner. This is to be my daily driver and a long-term expedition build project.

I am absolutely in love with the J80 styling and features and would, given the choice, choose it over a similarly equipped 4runner.

However, unless I suddenly run into a bunch of free time, I will not be servicing these vehicles myself. Mechanical service and upgrades will be handled by auto shops around me.

Given the above, which of the two vehicles would be a more sensible purchase for me taking mechanical repair and maintenance costs into account? From my research it appears that 4runners parts are plentiful and relatively inexpensive. 3rd Gen 4runners are also far more abundant at the dealerships and local listing in my area than are J80 cruisers.

This would be my first time owning either vehicle so advice is appreciated. Do I follow my heart and own a J80 or stick with a more sensible and probably more affordable (long-term) 4Runner (which would definitely still be a fun vehicle)?

Both vehicles can be found for under $10k at roughly around 200k miles around me in Eastern Missouri.

Thanks
 
Always follow your heart, the brain is useless. :P
 
I will tell you my personal opinion.....you will spend less time on the 4runner. The j80 can be brought up to top shape and then driven for a very long time before you have to do anything to it....But considering how most original and second owners never maintained their vehicles correctly, you will have a lot of baselining to do. The 4runner has a much simpler but less capable suspension and front end.
 
I'd hate to have to pay someone to do all the baselining I did on my first and am now doing on my second LC. Toyota sold 10x as many 4R in that era as LC. I'd say those two facts together, plus the lesser specs of a 4R, make the 4R a cheaper vehicle - but I've never owned a 4R nor wanted one.
 
It is a myth that the 80 series is expensive to own. That simply isn't the case. At all. On the contrary they are actually quite reasonable to own. My 92 has cost me just over $200/month since I purchased it new in 92. That includes the original purchase price.

Any vehicle that is 20 years old is going to require maintenance (unless it was done by the previous owner at which you will pay more for the vehicle at purchase).

You have to remember that 80 owners on Mud are the exception to the rule. They obsess about every drop of oil, creak, squeak, rattle. I know I have done "maintenance" items simply because of someone posting about doing said "maintenance" item. Anyone that says they haven't is lying.

4Runners are cute. 80s are legendary.
 
Do you NEED the size/capacity of an 80?
Do you NEED a solid front axle?

If not, get a 4 Runner so long as it has a 3.4 liter V6 (a fantastic engine, one I would put up against any LC engine) or a 22RE if you want an older truck. If you aren't willing to get the right engine then get a LC. And you can wheel the snot out of a 4Runner just like you can a Cruiser. You can also drive to South America. But you won't have the size and you won't have the bomb proof build. You may not need it - very few people do, frankly.
 
Agree with above. Also, in terms of how much you'll have to put into it, it really depends on the vehicle itself. You can find an 80 that will cost next to nothing to baseline or a 4Runner that is it bad shape and needs a lot of tlc, or vice versa. Figure out what you really want/need like mr natural said and then go from there.

Also just get an 80
 
Last edited:
As a guy who just recently discovered MUD after buying my first fzj80 I'll say that finding parts is more time consuming. There's lots of resources on this site but haven't found any junkyard sources yet for little things. However, hunting for parts online is a good way of learning what's best for your cruiser.... but as a daily driver I'm getting like 250 miles out of a 20 gallon tank so maybe a 4Runner with possible 2wd could save you some money
 
Thanks for all the responses so far. Parts availability is a concern for sure as I do intend to use the LC as a daily and would not want to be without a vehicle for longwhile I hunt for parts.

There are probably two dozen toyota dealerships and service shops in my area but I'm not sure how well equipped they would be to service a 20 year old vehicle.
 
Get whichever one you can find at the best price in the best condition. That'll probably land you a 4runner but as someone else said, I would be penniless had I paid some one to do all the PM on my 97; and ive done it over 6 months. I don't know, the labor really adds up.
 
They are both Great Vehicles, designed by the same company.
Most do not need the Solid Front Axle, but it's easy to convince yourself you do.
If you need the space the LC, if you prefer the Mileage Runner.
I have had both and I think too many split hairs on this.
Whatever you do not get a Jeep or Range or let us find out about it!
 
The 4 runner :deadhorse: will save some cash, but the 80 will put smiles on you face :).
 
As a guy who just recently discovered MUD after buying my first fzj80 I'll say that finding parts is more time consuming. There's lots of resources on this site but haven't found any junkyard sources yet for little things. However, hunting for parts online is a good way of learning what's best for your cruiser.... but as a daily driver I'm getting like 250 miles out of a 20 gallon tank so maybe a 4Runner with possible 2wd could save you some money

@Snoozecruiser97 meet @arcteryx aka Jason aka Cruiser Yard. I buy virtually all of my used parts from him. Never been disappointed.
 
The 4 runner :deadhorse: will save some cash, but the 80 will put smiles on you face :).

I don't think that's wrong. But what puts a smile on my face is reliability. They're both (assuming the 4Runner has the right engine) crazy reliable WITH MAINTENANCE. The 80 will cost more UP FRONT to baseline and maintain but once important work is done with OEM parts there is no real difference.

It's pay me now or pay me later. Bite the bullet and get the best parts and expertise you can find (not afford...FIND) then they'll take you around the world with nothing more than wiper blades and an oil change now and then, but the cruiser will take much more abuse. Be honest with yourself about what you mean by "expedition" - for most people these days that means car camping trips that they could just as easily do in a Subaru. That's 100% fine. But don't think you need an 80 to drive to Alaska or Baja, and certainly not Yellowstone.
 
I've had both. The T4R purchase price was less. Maintenance was less expensive. Oil changes were cheaper. Gas was cheaper to fill. But it does have less cargo space and I personally didn't care for the seating position. Now if you're comparing on a comfort level, get a GX470. Same as a fourth gen 4Runner but way better.
 
Thanks for all the responses so far. Parts availability is a concern for sure as I do intend to use the LC as a daily and would not want to be without a vehicle for longwhile I hunt for parts.

There are probably two dozen toyota dealerships and service shops in my area but I'm not sure how well equipped they would be to service a 20 year old vehicle.
New parts availability is not an issue. It's used parts that are tougher to find
 
Now that my supposedly already totally baselined and built 80 is actually baselined, running and stopping great, I really like driving it and owning it. ...but, damn what a pita for a few months. It's only worth the price of entry if you actually use the vehicle for it intended purpose. If I don't go wheel or camping at least I'll once a month, the Focus RS starts to look like a good replacement!
 
this dilemma has been already debated many times here....

wellll..... ask yourself:
Do I want the spend time outdoors.... actually driving, exploring, having fun? the answer is simply forth gen 4Runner or something newer than 10 years for sure.....without any doubt....

or
Do I enjoy spending time in the garage "fixing" things and talking long discussion about how to fix things and feeling good about "what a big mechanic I am...." ...? then an older car/truck makes more sense specifically one as emblematic as a TLC or LX

these are the questions you have to answer......
 
Now if you're comparing on a comfort level, get a GX470. Same as a fourth gen 4Runner but way better.


THIS

If you're considering an 80 or a Runner, the GX470 should also be on that list.

Great vehicles and they've come down in price quite a bit :cool:
 
Back
Top Bottom