Engine oil lacking ZDDP?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

If we're going to talk a swap to roller lifters you can get Edelbrok O.E. style Hydraulics (Edelbrock O.E. Style Hydraulic Roller Lifters - JEGS) with the spider for less than the Comp Endure-X lifters (Comp Cams Endure-X Mechanical Roller Lifters - JEGS) and not have to bother with setting valve lash. Then add a hyd-roller cam for 230-270ish. The Endure-X lifters are great but for a basic SBC are completely unnecessary. Rollers are awesome but they cost twice as much as a hy-flat tappet and for the most part operate in an entirely different rev range than most guys would want with a cruiser since mass production roller profiles are meant for more highstrung motors. I've seen some guys run hydraulic roller lifters with flat tappet cams before, can't vouch for if it works well or not :meh:
 
There's a good write-up on Team Chevelle, by Scott Wheaton about this, in the Performance and Engine forums. He has done ALOT of research, and spent a few bucks having various oils tested for Zinc/Phosphourus content. As you can imagine, these Guys are running anything from a stock build to extreemly radical so this has been a real issue for them. With the camshaft Manuf's coming out with camshafts with more aggresive ramp rates on the lobes ( Comp XE series, Lunati Vodoo series, and others ), and the need for stiffer springs it really created a problem. Go to Team Chevelle and read Scotts oil article, lists oils to use that are still OK with flat tappets, and gives a breakdown of ingrediants found by Blackstone Labs. HTH, Al
 
Here are some pictures of what I found...still not sure what the brass ring is from...don't remember it...but looks like it may fit around the rod and crank shaft...? Help me remember...ha!

Broken lifter and brass ring.
Ware Plate, Lifter.webp

Picture showing what a good lobe looks like. (4th lobe from the right is showing it's highest point)
Cam with good lobe.webp

One of three flat lobes. The lobe to the far right is showing it's highest point...flat in this picture. Should look like the lobe noted up top.
Came with bad lobe.webp
Ware Plate, Lifter.webp
Cam with good lobe.webp
Came with bad lobe.webp
 
Last edited:
OK! I'm happy now!....Think I found where the brass ring came from. Looked up the timing gear kit I put in...and there it was right in the picture.

Think on an other note I'll change back to a timing chain... :lol: :idea:

Now all I have to do is pick out a new cam duration and go wheeling!

Thanks for all the imput!
Gear Drive Timing.webp
Gear Drive Timing.webp
 
Last edited:
Holly smokes man, you got some extra money lying around . . . that stuff is $12/QT!

I can get the Castrol 20W-50 for $20/5QT and the Lucas additive is $17/16 fl oz on Amazon.

Thats retail. Its expensive but when you order you get 25% off and free shipping.

You get what you pay for....you may want to peruse this:
What oil brands offer the best protection ***Good read***

$44 vs $37...seems about equal. But my truck uses more than 5 qts...might be a good idea to fill yours up :)
 
Last edited:
Why does Lucas have this qualifier?

  • Designed for race applications
  • Not designed for passenger car use
I generally don't race my FJ40, and occasionally I have a passenger with me. So will that set off an engine warning light if I use the Lucas? :meh:
 
Thats retail. Its expensive but when you order you get 25% off and free shipping.

You get what you pay for....you may want to peruse this:
What oil brands offer the best protection ***Good read***

$44 vs $37...seems about equal. But my truck uses more than 5 qts...might be a good idea to fill yours up :)
I know it take more than 5qts. I will give you that the Amsoil Z-Rod appears to have some great ratings!

Let's do the math -

Castrol w/ Lucas - $20/5qt =$4/qt - $4*8qts = $32 + $16 lucas (didn't realize it required the entire bottle) = $48

Amsoil Z-Rod - $12/qt * .25% off = $9*8qts = $72

Cost does not appear to be equal . . .
 
Why does Lucas have this qualifier?
  • Designed for race applications
  • Not designed for passenger car use
I generally don't race my FJ40, and occasionally I have a passenger with me. So will that set off an engine warning light if I use the Lucas? :meh:
Yes, it can put enough metal into the exhaust to poison a cat or O² sensor.
 
If you don't want to mess with the additive, Lucas also makes a line of high-zddp oils for a *reasonable* price

Either the Diesel 10w40, a CI rated oil, at about 1600 ppm zinc (good enough for a low-rev flat-tappet)
SAE 15W-40 Magnum High TBN CI-4 Oil

Or a 'Hot Rod' oil (mo' money) with about 2500 ppm zddp:
PF - Hot Rod & Classic

I get the diesel stuff with amazon prime for about $50 2 gals. You can get it cheaper if you consume mass quantities.

Here's a list of Lucas' oil with zinc values:
https://lucasoil.com/pdf/Zinc_Values_MotorcycleOil.pdf
 
Yes, it can put enough metal into the exhaust to poison a cat or O² sensor.
Dang Jim I was trying (poorly) to be a smart aleck but your response is very informative. In fact, that's what they ought to put on their labeling as it makes complete sense. Thanks for the great info (and also Spike Strip). I'll work harder at the smart aleck-ness next time. :)
 
If you don't want to mess with the additive, Lucas also makes a line of high-zddp oils for a *reasonable* price

Either the Diesel 10w40, a CI rated oil, at about 1600 ppm zinc (good enough for a low-rev flat-tappet)
SAE 15W-40 Magnum High TBN CI-4 Oil

Or a 'Hot Rod' oil (mo' money) with about 2500 ppm zddp:
PF - Hot Rod & Classic

I get the diesel stuff with amazon prime for about $50 2 gals. You can get it cheaper if you consume mass quantities.

Here's a list of Lucas' oil with zinc values:
https://lucasoil.com/pdf/Zinc_Values_MotorcycleOil.pdf

Thanks for this. Napa has the magnum for $20/gallon.
 
Jim - you said: The newest diesel oils have no metal anti-wear additives, just like spark oil. Note that a few years ago diesel oil was rated CH/SJ, indicating that it would only pass the SJ spark engine standard, due to the high metal loading.

CK4 is the current (new) diesel engine oil standard. Here's the chart from PQIA for Delvac 1300 Super (image capture below). Still has lots of zinc and phosphorous, FWIW. (Not trying to be a jerk - but what other metals were you referring to?)

zinc.webp
 
Back
Top Bottom