Diagnosing overheating?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Mar 2, 2009
Threads
20
Messages
769
Location
CA
My rig is overheating and I want to try and find out why.
It’s a 2002 with ~225k and is our family hauler DD.

Today my father in law called me and said he drove it to his house (~5 miles away on country road) and it overheated into the red on the temp gauge. I forgot to ask him what temp the Scangauge read for *fWT since I keep it hooked up on the steering column. He said he popped the hood, everything was normal except the coolant reservoir was empty. Radiator level was fine and normal looking red/pink for Toyota.

Thinking it was for sure a busted heater hose tee, as it’s the originals at 225k, I went and bought two new ones on my way home at Toyota. Upon looking at things the tees are still intact, but with a little pink crust on them, so I’ll change them anyway.

Since the tees were fine I decided to install the new battery we got for the Cruiser the other day, then take it for a spin around the block to see if it gets hot for me.....and it did.

Only drove maybe 1/2 mile and immediately started to see a quicker than normal rise in temp on Scangauge. I only let it get to 227* before I turned around, normal for our rig is about 190* in warm weather, it’s about 50* outside when I just drove it. Parked it, no codes thrown and then inspected engine bay for any leaks or abnormal stuff and the only thing that looks odd is there is a visible drip of water (coolant?) coming from a little stub of a hose coming from firewall on passenger side, dripping down onto the skid plate. It’s the hose pigtail adjacent the firewall heat shielding for the passenger side header. I thought this was a drain for the AC? I did hit the windshield defrost button on my test drive to unfog. Could it be coolant instead? Looked like water to me, no smell either.

Wondering what to check?

Some sort of blockage in the cooling system is what I’d guess next, like a stuck thermostat - which I’d assume was replaced in my tbelt service with the water pump at 190k from Toyota. I suppose I could pull it and test - I’ve gotta drain some coolant to do that, right? I just moved into a new house and it’s gravel driveway repairs until I build a shop in a few years.

Any other ideas before my in laws just decide to take it over to Toyota because I don’t have a lot of free time these days and it’s our kid hauler.
 
After driving around for awhile, feel the upper and radiator hoses, both should be warm, signs of coolant circulation.
 
Pull those splash shields and check for leaks. Those shields can mask leaks by allowing stuff to puddle up inside. If you don't have any leaks, I'd start by replacing the T-stat with a new one from Toyota. Get a new gasket as well. Make sure the little check valve is rotated to the 12-0'clock position. You will need to drain a couple of gallons of coolant. Thermostat is a easy 30-min swap.
 
My money is on a bad fan clutch.

If you blast all the heat on high, does that help control temp? Does the car give you heat in the cabin? If so, that indicates there's some flow through the system. If it overheats before cabin gets warm, you've got either air in the system or no coolant circulation.

Regarding your drip, coolant should be obviously non-clear. If it's still hard to tell, maybe grab some printer paper and dab the drop on that to see if it has any color.
 
After the earlier suggestions are cleared, you might, just might have warped the head if it got hot enough. No need to ask me how I know this. :bang:

Not sure of the cause but if you start it and take off the radiator cap, look for small (really small) bubbles coming out of the rad. That'll give you a likely indication that something is up with the head.
 
Last edited:
How could it be a fluid leak problem if the coolant level checked out fine?
 
If the reservoir is empty its using/loosing coolant.
 
Thermostats are rarely replaced with T-belt job a Toyota Dealer. You can often see parts list at Toyota with VIN, or just call the Dealer that did the job and ask. But they do go bad even replacements.

Make sure you note ambient temperature as you check coolant level each morning after 8 hour cool down. 5f deg difference can change level and 1/8 of inch. Radiator should hold it's level at top of neck and reservoir should be at low line each morning once system properly burped. "Any" adding of coolant needed indicates a leak. Leaks must be found and stopped first thing.

Coolant must be a 50/50 mix.

If fan keeps spinning after shutting engine off, it's likely fan clutch is bad.

Check your front (lower timing belt cover) and rear (bell housing) weeps holes for coolant.

While undershielding off, head gasket is visible from below. I also use a mirror from above. Check oil for signs of milkshake (coolant/water in oil)

Use an infrared heat gun on thermostat housing to confirm overheating.

Dealer maintained is no assurance job done right, check all work done.

If not coolant system or sensor not malfunctioning. Then look to fuel air ratio, which "should" set off CEL. Starved for fuel and cylinders/heads heat up.
 
Last edited:
Thermostats are rarely replaced with T-belt job a Toyota Dealer. You can often see parts list at Toyota with VIN, or just call the Dealer that did the job and ask. But they do go bad even replacements.

Make sure you note ambient temperature as you check coolant level each morning after 8 hour cool down. 5f deg difference can change level and 1/8 of inch. Radiator should hold it's level at top of neck and reservoir should be at low line each morning once system properly burped. "Any" adding of coolant needed indicates a leak. Leaks must be found and stopped first thing.

Coolant must be a 50/50 mix.

If fan keeps spinning after shutting engine off, it's likely fan clutch is bad.

Check your front (lower timing belt cover) and rear (bell housing) weeps holes for coolant.

While undershielding off, head gasket is visible from below. I also use a mirror from above. Check oil for signs of milkshake (coolant/water in oil)

Use an infrared heat gun on thermostat housing to confirm overheating.

Dealer maintained is no assurance job done right, check all work done.

If not coolant system or sensor malfunction. Then look to fuel air ratio, which "should" set off CEL. Starved for fuel and cylinders/heads heat up.

On our 1998 Honda Odyssey with 390K miles, we (my ex) ended up warping the head after a blown rear hose but we got no coolant in the oil, we did end up with a higher coolant temp that caused overheating (ceased rings, main leak, coolant, etc).

I'm not much of a mechanic but I'm thinking that it's not viable to tear it down and rebuild the tired engine.

Your thoughts? Thanks in advance.
 
Some good suggestions on things to check later tonight, thanks.

When I did the test drive, the rig had only been off for about 2 hours before I got home. I did have heat in he cabin and I did grab the upper radiator hose to check, but not the lower one.

When I looked underneath at the skid pan it was bone dry except for the small puddle where that drip was coming from the firewall tube. Puddle about the size of a dollar bill, visible by looking down at skid past chassis on passenger side.

Coolant level in the radiator was up to the neck/overflow tube and looked normal, no milkshake, no bubbles. I could see the fins inside the radiator with my flashlight shined down into it.

I have the paperwork somewhere for the tbelt job and will look at the parts list to see if thermostat was replaced or not. I’d think if it was stuck there wouldn’t be any heat in the cabin at all?

Will also check the fan clutch. I did take note that with my head under the hood with it running, that she was like really really quiet running compared to my 22re truck I just tinkered with over the weekend. If the clutch on it works, it should kinda “roar”, right? Checking to see if the fan keeps spinning after shut down seems like an easy task. Is that all that’s needed to check it?
 
Fan clutch: Yeah, should be loud when it's warmed up. To check it you can try to spin it by hand. If you can get a full rotation or two by hand when cold it may be worn. If the engine is warm and you turn it off and have a partner watch the fan, it should stop quickly (within a second maybe). A bad clutch will slip and will spin freely after shutdown. My clutch was bad recently and spun for a good 3+ seconds when the hot engine was turned off.
 
Fan clutch, ding ding ding!

Just went out to check. I can freely spin it by hand on cold engine. Started it up and watched it spin a good 3-4 seconds after shut down.

Looks like I’ve got some research to do today while at “work”
 
Fan clutch, ding ding ding!

Just went out to check. I can freely spin it by hand on cold engine. Started it up and watched it spin a good 3-4 seconds after shut down.

Looks like I’ve got some research to do today while at “work”

was the truck hot enough for this test?
the clutch will spin much freely when cold, as it warms up it "engages" more to the axle to spin faster to cool more.
if the engine is hot, you will feel resistance to spin it manually (how much resistance is very subjective).
with a cold engine if will be very easy to spin it
 
truck was NOT hot, water temp under 100*F.

I can easily repeat the test later this evening to confirm, but from yesterdays examination I'm definitely recalling fan was much quieter than usual after my test drive which got it up to 225*F. Also, while I had it idling and revving slightly i could see the temp shooting up much much quicker than while i was driving it.

in my other vehicles i can feel some resistance trying to spin the fan clutch, it sorta chugs along as you rotate and you've gotta put at least several pounds of pressure to get it to move. On the 100, it had like hardly any resistance at all, I put maybe 1/2lb of pressure on it to spin it.

oh yeah and when i spoke to my FIL this morning, he said he did look at the temp reading and it was at 242 when he pulled over, then it dropped to the 230s fairly quickly after he stopped moving and it stayed in that range as he limped it back home.
 
are you related to Spike555. sorry, just kidding.
treat it like a bmw cooling system and you'll never need to worry about it. Replace all that 15 year old s***.
 
was the truck hot enough for this test?
the clutch will spin much freely when cold, as it warms up it "engages" more to the axle to spin faster to cool more.
if the engine is hot, you will feel resistance to spin it manually (how much resistance is very subjective).
with a cold engine if will be very easy to spin it

Much agreed. It is very subjective and a cold test may not be enough to be 100% on it.

truck was NOT hot, water temp under 100*F.

I can easily repeat the test later this evening to confirm, but from yesterdays examination I'm definitely recalling fan was much quieter than usual after my test drive which got it up to 225*F. Also, while I had it idling and revving slightly i could see the temp shooting up much much quicker than while i was driving it.

in my other vehicles i can feel some resistance trying to spin the fan clutch, it sorta chugs along as you rotate and you've gotta put at least several pounds of pressure to get it to move. On the 100, it had like hardly any resistance at all, I put maybe 1/2lb of pressure on it to spin it.

oh yeah and when i spoke to my FIL this morning, he said he did look at the temp reading and it was at 242 when he pulled over, then it dropped to the 230s fairly quickly after he stopped moving and it stayed in that range as he limped it back home.

I just went out and tried to whip my fan around. At best I got 1/2-3/4 rotation on a fully cold engine with about as much force as I could put into it. Granted, my fan clutch is pretty new, but a good clutch should be similar. When it's hot, it doesn't really spin at all by hand. As soon as my hand leaves the blade it's essentially already stopped.

If you know your clutch is over 50k miles it's probably a good idea to replace anyway. For $125 for the Aisin part, it's a reasonable first step in cooling system diagnosis.
 
I found an Aisin fan clutch on Amazon for only $80, I might get that one.

Here's the video I took this morning, showing how it just keeps free spinning after shut down:
 
I would still carry out all of the checks, if it is a coolant circulation problem like a thermostat then the truck will overheat no matter what, if it is the fan clutch then it would be worse in traffic and when moving slower. Not sure of your ambient temps but over here in the UK at winter time I bet I could take my fan off and it still wouldn’t overheat. The heater has nothing to do with the thermostat, it will get warm inside the cab with a closed stat so that isn’t a good test. If in doubt do both, stat and fan clutch.
 
I'm betting against the clutch. If it warmed up as quickly as you said - while driving it - I'm thinking there should have been enough airflow through movement to keep it from heating up. Not saying it might not have eventually heated up, but I'm thinking not that quickly. Prolly a t-stat, but could be the water pump...even if not leaking, due to the plastic impeller.

I'm betting t-stat.
 
Back
Top Bottom