Birfield questions

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Dec 18, 2018
Threads
5
Messages
25
Location
The woods
Apologies, as I know that there are lots of threads dealing with this subject, but I couldn’t find any that succinctly answer my questions, so here goes.

So......birfield choices.

Here’s what I’ve read so far:

1. Stock axles/birfs are made of a harder steel, so they can last a long time if they’re kept off of rough terrain. However, they can break if used very roughly, in part due to their design (30 spline diameter necked down to 24), and in part due to their hardness.

2. Chromoly axles/birfs are made for rough terrain, and offer more ability to deal with extra drive torque and bashing around without breaking. These aftermarket style axles can be purchased as 30/30 spline setup to beef things up.

My 80 will be used as a daily driver. It may not always be that way, but for now, assume roughly 20-30K on the road in a year. It will have 285/75/16 MT’s on it (roughly 33”). I will be on some rough trails with large rocks to hop over, but not “rock crawling”, per se. I would describe it more as overlanding.

Here are my questions:

1. Are stock-style birfs robust enough to handle the conditions I’ve described above?

2. Will Chromoly birfs wear out too quickly? I’ve found several threads on this site dealing with this subject, but I can’t seem to find any mileage estimates for a Chromoly axle when driven mostly off-road. An ih8mud vendor said “many thousands of miles” for their chromolies, but what does that mean, approximately? 10k? 50k? I understand that driving conditions are an uncontrollable variable here, but an estimate from someone who has gone through a set or two would be nice.

Anyway, I’m not in a hurry, as the 80 isn’t even finished yet, but I do want to figure this out before I take the family out on the road in a few months.
 
Stock will work fine. Stay off skinny pedal. I have 315 for over 100k on mine with no issues. You can break anything but the factory ones will work good for your description
 
You don't need longfields for your description. The few birfields i have seen bust have been on big obstacles almost always involving turning and wheel hop. You can, and i have, put a ton of pressure on your driveline with good results. You especially don't need 30 spline. I have a trailer queen 60 that i run 37's on and a crawl box. I did put longfields in it, but Bobby would not sell me 30 splines for it. Told me if you are not running 40's you don't need 30 spline.

Get the chromoly if you WANT to get them but you don't need them. My understanding is they do wear much better than they did in the old days, but you do not NEED them in a overland truck with 285's. Personally if your birfields are operational i would put the money towards something else.
 
For the daily driver you describe I am confident that you would be fine with OEM.
 
My original birfields are at 207,000 miles with over 130,000 supercharged. It has been on 35 inch tires with 4.88 gears for about 6 years. Prior to that it had 33s since almost new.
I'd say they do fairly well.
 
Know of a bunch of factory birfs that have been run long term on 37" tires. Some do dumb stuff like towing trailers full of rock, offroad, so they are pretty durable. :hillbilly:
12-26-2016_19-jpg.1639358
 
There is no reason why alloy joints should wear faster than OEM joints.

Both 1045 steel and 4140 chrome moly can be induction hardened to the same surface hardness while retaining a softer, more ductile core.

The idea that “super” Birfields were soft started with the original Bobby Long joints where he welded a ring on the bell of an OEM joint and the heat from the welding drew the hardness from the bell.

Later 4140 joints were so strong that the star became the weak link, so they are now made of 300M steel to compensate. Although this alloy is through hardened rather than surface hardened, the hardness is comparable to that of the 4140 bell, so it isn’t clear that the star would wear any faster than the bell.
 
That and the early '80 series Longfields didn't last long, some being clickers in 20-30k miles. IIRC, he said the effect of AWD wasn't taken into account, well understood. Even with the newer ones, said don't expect OEM life from them. For most, especially with small tires, don't see the need, well maintained stock birfs work well, take a beating.
 
The '80 axles don't "neck down", both ends are about the same size.
They do "neck down" but not necessarily to accommodate the 24 coarser splined section
 
Know of a bunch of factory birfs that have been run long term on 37" tires. Some do dumb stuff like towing trailers full of rock, offroad, so they are pretty durable. :hillbilly:
12-26-2016_19-jpg.1639358
This rig has original birfs with 211000 miles. SC for about 175000, and 37's for nearly 100000, so far. The combined gross vehicle weight in the picture is around11,000 #. I'd do it again in a heartbeat. Most important thing is to keep the tires hooked up to the ground. Wheelspin can encourage breakage. Two-pedaling and/or lockers helps a lot.
 
Maybe it's just me, but using an 80 as a daily driver where you put 30K a year on it seems crazy.

Why is that? I bought mine a quarter century ago to be the go-to whenever you need it for whatever you need it for.
The ONLY reason to park it is fuel economy. It does everything else so competently that it is worth the fuel penalty to me.
 
Maybe it's just me, but using an 80 as a daily driver where you put 30K a year on it seems crazy.

I think driving anything 30k a year is crazy
 
  • Like
Reactions: ppc
Back
Top Bottom