We replied to Theron's post in his other thread regarding the tent, but we felt it was appropriate to reply here as well.
Thank you for the valuable feedback. Ultimately the damage on the roof of the shell was deemed to be caused by the user after an internal inspection and two separate independent inspections. Admittedly this process could have gone smoother on our end and we thank Theron for his patience and understanding. This issue hasn't been seen before so it was critical that it was inspected properly in case there was a flaw in our design or in our manufacturing process. There are a countless number of our tents not only in North America but also around the globe, some in the harshest environments this planet has to offer, none of which have suffered stress fatigue or weather fatigue as claimed.
In regards to the ladder failure - yes, there was a batch that had issues. We never tried to hide it nor would we ever deny that there was an issue. It took some time to address why they were failing, to discover which batch(es) were affected, and to come up with a viable solution for the future. A knee jerk reaction to a handful of isolated cases without properly assessing the situation could've caused more issues. To be clear, we used the same manufacturer for the plastics in our ladder for over a decade and never experienced any issues. When it was discovered they changed their manufacturing process and that was the cause of failure, we fired them. After this occurred, we felt the only acceptable approach was to go back to the drawing board and improve the design all together. All our new tents are using a completely new design that not only utilizes aluminum over plastic but the mount has also been redesigned. Trust us when we say its embarrassing and we aren't happy that there was an issue with the ladders, but we are confident this will never be an issue again in the future with the improved design.
Some of our customers use their tent exclusively on weekends to get away and others (like Theron) call them home for months on end while he explores roads less traveled. Customer satisfaction is a priority for us and that's why we offer a five year warranty on our hard shell tents. However, we cannot honor the warranty when failure is deemed to be caused user error. We understand and agree that failure is unacceptable and we hold our products to the highest standard. Lastly, to be completely transparent, we paid shipping both ways (truck freight) and we offered Theron a $500 credit towards a new tent. While this process took longer than we had hoped, we feel we've been more than fair accommodating Theron despite denying the warranty.
If anyone has any concerns, please feel free to call us at (908) 387-6701.