The ARB was not the issue. I have been in touch with Phil at ARB USA, and he has been very helpful. After going over everything and stripping the axle to it's bones, this is what I think has happened.
Both hubs have had a full service very recently. I mean within the last 1500 miles or so. Understand that I have nothing to back what I think up. This is all hypothetical except for the bit about the spotty install of the ARB.
Anyone that knows this rig and saw it on
EBAY knows that it was built initially by another ih8Mudder. This rig was built very well and I have no problems with it other than the obvious. I also do not imply any fault on them for the issues I am having. I believe that the previous owner (the one that bought it from the original builder.) Thought there was an issue with the axle hubs and had them rebuilt. When that changed nothing, I think that he got rid of it.
The noises that I experienced were very intermittent initially. This is why I also thought it was the passenger side hub. Which makes sense being that is the short axle side. I think this is what happened to the person that owned it before me, as well. I just don't think he went the extra mile and tore into the 3rd member.
As it is I had just bought the rig, and tearing s*** apart never did scare me much. After getting everything torn apart and cleaning everything, by the way there where so many metal shavings in the axle housing and bottom of the diff case, I think the last owners mechanic might have been a stripper.
All jokes aside. I have got everything spotless and glitter free.
So that brings us to the ARB install issues. Everyone that has said that thread locker was probably not used is correct. There is no trace of thread locker in this unit what so ever. I will also be tearing the rear diff apart and going through it.
So like so many have said, it was the installer and not the unit.
So when everything is said and done the truck is going to cost me a grand more than I actually paid. Not concerned because you couldn't build one as nice as this one for the amount I paid for it.
I will give another update when I here from my differential specialist. And no his name is not Porsche or Mercedes and he has no brass poles in his shop.