4" spring's or SOA ?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

What are the best reasons for either?

Ford powerd /C4 71 FJ40

looks like I'll be the first to say it.... search. It's in the upper part of the page. Read the recent threads on this and then you will be more prepared to ask specific questions.

This has been covered and recovered. That said, I'd go soa. Little more complex, but seems to be where most of us end up.

If you have the option, drive a couple of both that were done right and make your decision from there.
 
looks like I'll be the first to say it.... search. It's in the upper part of the page. Read the recent threads on this and then you will be more prepared to ask specific questions.

This has been covered and recovered. That said, I'd go soa. Little more complex, but seems to be where most of us end up.

If you have the option, drive a couple of both that were done right and make your decision from there.
Thank's!
 
SOA is cheaper, but requires some fab work. Plus you get some more lift, and just a better suspension offorad wise, And good onroad ride so I have heard..

SUA is more expensive but pretty much bolt on and easy. Depends on what ya wanna do :cheers:
 
where in whittier do you live, im on pickering by the 5 points if you want to stop by and see/ride a/in 3" lift let me know. @yahoo.com
 
Last edited:
having done both, i'd go sua with 33-35s, but i don't really wheel hardcore enough to require soa and having rolled before, i'm not fond of tippiness ;)

soa will be more expensive. minimum $250 for double arm or, as mentioned $500 for hi steer, better be a good welder to cut and turn front end, if not, that will be a couple hundred. torque bar will be another hundred unless you build your own, still have to buy longer brake lines and new ubolts which would most likely come in a $650-800 lift kit. now, you're running considerably larger tires, so you need to upgrade steering components. longer driveshafts are a possibility and lengthening is expensive. you've turned your diffs up, so weld new bung in the covers to move plug up....etc if you're a qualified welder, it might be cheaper, but look at the time involved. what's your time worth to you?
 
Just to help you gauge cost...
I went SUA 4" lift. New springs and shocks all around. I spent about $600 total for this. Extended brake lines where needed. Did not have to lenghten a shaft, cut and turn, mess with steering (already had saginaw type).

Truck rides well on 35" tires and brakes decently with original drums (can lock up all 4 wheels). I also did not have to recorrect any caster/camber toe in/out issues. I never drive it on pavement but I don't wheel it really hard either. If I was a more confident fabricator and was out 3 times a month or more on trails, I would go SOA.
 
What are the best reasons for either?

The best reason for SOA: you wheel hard and want articulation, you are a good fabricator or want to pay one, or you like the SOA look.

The best reason for SUA: you wheel mild trails and are happy with some clearance and somewhat limited flex, you are capable of bolting on the lift kit yourself but cannot cut/turn/fab, you don't like the extra 2" of lift from SOA and don't like tippiness:grinpimp:

though expections are abound, hope this helps!

my 60 is 4" SUA (daily driver) and my 55 is SOA (trail pig) but I plan to SO the 60 eventually becuase that's just me:flipoff2:
 
I've been losing sleep over this very issue now for over a week. It kept weighing on my mind till this point. So I made the decision to stay SUA for several reasons.

I daily drive my 40 and plan to drive it to Moab and Back from Ohio.

Can't stand a high center of gravity. If I were gonna SOA..it will be a coil/link system. Time to say goodbye to leafs at this point IMO.

Cost: It's cheaper to do the SUA unless you have a shop or access that can do a cut n turn, etc.

I do feel the work involved to get a good SUA to flex out right is about the same amount of work if your gonna lengthen you wheel base by moving the rear axle back.

So, I'm in the same boat, right now making my own spring packs from a combination of donors for the SUA to get the lift and ride I'm after.
 
A spring over can be a work of art if done by the likes of Mudrak or some other master of metal fab. However, if done by a shade tree mechanic slash hack welder who turns pro (like many 4x4 shops, especially on the east coast) it's a horrific display of booger welds holding together a dangerouse mix of accidents waiting to happen. I have seen some wicked scary stuff on some spring overs, even ones done by 4x4 shops, even ones done by Land Cruiser shops.

There is no way in hell you can do a good spring over for less than the cost of a Skyjacker Kit unless you think parakeet shiat welds are good and welding cast iron steering parts to A36 mild steel is a good idea (with a mig welder no less).

For hard core wheeling, SO is no doubt exactly what you need to get the job done if you need to run a large tire such as 36" or larger. Any attempt to do this SUA is a waste of time and if you have a truck like that you'd be damn handy or have a lot of cash to spend.

For anything else, SUA is going to get the job done and then some. I am not into hard core wheeling what so ever but I've also seen few trails that could not be traversed for the most part with SUA and 35's, in some cases even 33's.

If your waay into it, you won't even need to read this, I just think its annoying when someone is told they need a spring over to get the job done. I also think it's become sort of the Harley of the Land Cruiser world. If you have a Spring Over, even a very scary one, then your hard core and one of the cool guys. Yea right.

I will also say that i've seen my friend Wes work through his spring over 40 very carefully over a long period of time and it went from very sketchy to very solid. I am in no way saying that SO truck can't be driveable as they can be if you have the time and or money.

If I paid someone to do a spring over I'd want them to be certified and trained welder. Just like i'd prefer the guy who works on my wifes car to be a SAE tech.

Another consideration is that in some states (Like Virginia where I live), a spring over exceeds the bumper height laws and is not legal. CA has no bumper laws. You might be able to get away with it, depending on how much you actually drive it and where you live. Not an issue for a trailer queen.

-Stumbaugh
 
Last edited:
mr. green do you have any rub issues?

That's personal! ;p

Seriously, not to my knowledge. I haven't beat it enough yet to find out the weakest links but I did some minor flexing. I did however eliminate rust with a sawzall and make room for the tires. After seeing numerous threads on sheetmetal repair, I'll probably be relacing most of what I cut away though. I recall there being very minor rub on the front springs... or was that my 85 mini...? I don't remember.

mrblister, either way you go you'll be happy over what you have now.
 
The best reason for SUA: you wheel mild trails and are happy with some clearance and somewhat limited flex, you are capable of bolting on the lift kit yourself but cannot cut/turn/fab, you don't like the extra 2" of lift from SOA and don't like tippiness:grinpimp:
QUOTE]

sua can still wheel the hard trails. most of the leaf sprung rigs on our chinaman run in april were sua and they did just fine. chinaman is rated an 8 trail. and flexy...just look at treeroot's rig. his flexes better sua than many soa's.
 
x2

im sua and have run the hard stuff on the west cost, rubicon, moab, dusy-ershim, calico.... i might go out to the hammers this winter

The best reason for SUA: you wheel mild trails and are happy with some clearance and somewhat limited flex, you are capable of bolting on the lift kit yourself but cannot cut/turn/fab, you don't like the extra 2" of lift from SOA and don't like tippiness:grinpimp:
QUOTE]

sua can still wheel the hard trails. most of the leaf sprung rigs on our chinaman run in april were sua and they did just fine. chinaman is rated an 8 trail. and flexy...just look at treeroot's rig. his flexes better sua than many soa's.
 
Since I've had both, let me chime in

I ran 35's with 4" SUA for a few years, doing "normal" trails as well as Rubicon. I also daily drove it. Most 4" lifts are very, very stiff. I rubbed, but dealt with it. Drug a lot, but it still wheeled OK. I guess my biggest complaint was stiffness, and maxing out at 35's.

I went up to SOA about 4 years ago. SOA is more expensive, without a doubt. But for clearance, tire size, ride comfort and articulation, it can't be beat. My biggest problem was getting my big ass into the seat. It's quite a jump. But I know have box sliders with a step, and it's doable to get in/out.

You have to ask yourself what your final vision of your cruiser is. IF you aren't going to need 38's, or if it's not a daily driver, I'd find some used 4" lift springs... you might find some that have softened up a little.

And I obviously agree with Stumbaugh up above. Either hire someone who knows what they are doing, or get yourself some good welding traing before tackling a SOA. I've seen scary shadetree jobs myself. Broken down on the trail.

Gary (Mudrak) Kardum did mine. He's done many, and has had numerous people ship him their rigs from out of state to do the work. There are others out there that know what they are doing. It's not cheap done right. But what's it worth to you?
 
Back
Top Bottom