While doing the ever dangerous activity of window shopping wheels online on my lunch break at work, I stumbled across a deal I couldn't pass: set of four Rock Warrior wheels for dirt cheap. I private messaged the seller wanting to buy them, so that evening after work, I drove 90 minutes to meet the seller at his house. Few minutes later after inspection, they were mine and loaded in my R. $400 for four wheels without curb rash, four nearly new tires (date code 1925), and TPMS sensors! Seller wouldn't sell the fifth wheel because he wanted to keep it for spare tire/wheel. Bummer.
The tires are inexpensive Milestar Patagonia ATR in size 285/70R17 SL. Seller wanted something different with quieter tires on his Tundra for his daily commute. Haven driven my truck with the Patagonia tires at 33 psi for only a couple hundred miles, I can say they are slightly noisier than the General Grabber ATX. The Patagonia tread noise is slightly higher pitch and higher volume than General Grabber ATX and BFG All Terrain KO2. I consider the Grabber ATX and BFG KO2 as an off-road oriented all-terrain tires, but consider the Patagonia an on-road oriented all-terrain tire. Neither compares to the soft, cushy, silent ride of the Blizzak winter or Michelin Latitude Tour HP crossover tires. I can't really describe the wet or snow traction of the Patagonia ATR since I haven't driven in either type of weather.
Considering the short test drive of the Patagonia tires, when the General Grabbers wear out, I will likely go with something else in size 285/75R17 or 295/70R17 since the Grabber ATX are not available in 33.5" on a 17" wheel. Who knows, we'll see. I have many months to figure it out.
Interesting measurements for the three different size tires shown below. I wasn't expecting the significant visual difference between nearly new 17" Patagonia ATR vs. half worn Grabber ATX. All three are SL load rated.
Measurements with tape measure against a level atop each tire.
Furthermore, the sidewalls of the Patagonia ATR seem rather, umm, not ready for off-roading. Sidewall slashes or punctures seem rather likely.