Wheel bearing failed!

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Feb 2, 2005
Threads
263
Messages
4,508
Location
Albemarle NC
Well, after only 10k miles since replacing them when I installed the 5.29s, my PS front wheel bearing failed. The tabs were straight on the lock washer (I know for a fact they were bent onto the hub nuts both directions). The washer with the tab for the notch in the spindle was flattened and worn heavily. And there were pieces of the bearing in the hub. Water obviously had gotten in there as a few things were rusted and there was still water in there. I didn't do anything but take the drive plate, washers, nuts, and lock washer off because I had extreme play in the wheel bearing. My $$$$ gold slotted/drilled rotor is probably gone too...the play caused it to wear unevenly on the outer edges.

What is the most likely cause of this? Too little or too much pre-load on the bearings?

I'll take pics when I have my mechanic tear into things next week.
 
Typically too much preload will cause premature failure. Other causes can be contamination due to poor greasing, poor grease packing of the bearing itself, changing bearings and NOT changing the races. I'm sure there will be other suggestions.

As told to the original 80sCOOL list by Norm Needham, better to err on the loose side than on the tight side of preload. Words to live by, but keep in mind that a turn of 1 flat (1/6) can be the difference.
 
Water obviously had gotten in there as a few things were rusted and there was still water in there. What is the most likely cause of this?


That is most likely your answer. Water in a wheel bearing and rust and water coming out when you open it up is a bad sign. Nothing will smoke a set of bearings faster than water, high speeds, and a heavy load. well maybe not anything. Throw in a slightly overtightened bearing and bad things will happen. BTDT
 
Used a fish scale....and went with the loose won't cook 'em like tight would, I guess I did that right. Now how the heck can water get in there? Everything is sealed, right? Or are my wipers probably worn and need replacing?
 
Brakes started to feel goofy about 100mi ago, so around then is when it must have hit the dirt. Today was when I took it to get the brakes adjusted (trying to go to Snowshoe) and we noticed the wheel had tremendous play. So no Snowshow, and a likely full axle rebuild.....again. I hope I can scrounge up enough for Longs and maybe an ARB before I get impatient of not being able to wheel.
 
Now how the heck can water get in there? Everything is sealed, right?

In reality nothing is sealed. From the rear of the hub you have a large wiper seal that goes around the outer rear of the hub. and an inner seal for the inner wheel bearing. If both were not replaced and those areas were not sealed with grease then water most likely will get in. On the outer all you have is a press fit grease cap. That outer area should be filled with grease as well as the cap.

It is also important to fill the void between the inner and outer bearings with grease. That area should be packed tight.

Essentially you're relying on the grease to keep water out. It is important to keep it packed and clean those seals and coat with grease before putting the hub back on.
 
In reality nothing is sealed. From the rear of the hub you have a large wiper seal that goes around the outer rear of the hub. and an inner seal for the inner wheel bearing. If both were not replaced and those areas were not sealed with grease then water most likely will get in. On the outer all you have is a press fit grease cap. That outer area should be filled with grease as well as the cap.

It is also important to fill the void between the inner and outer bearings with grease. That area should be packed tight.

Essentially you're relying on the grease to keep water out. It is important to keep it packed and clean those seals and coat with grease before putting the hub back on.

I disagree with most everything posted here.

You have a seal in the back of the rotor that does a fine job of keeping water out even though it should be positioned to keep grease in. If you put the rig in water enough you will introduce water to the bearing, but normal use will not cause water to enter the bearing area.

Packing the area between the bearings tight is not necessary and a frequent DIY mistake.It causes the bearings to run overly hot and can leak on to your braking surfaces. No manufacturer recommends it and many warn against it.

Water will not leak in through the pressed in dust cap. If you don't have one on it will leak. It should not be packed with grease. It should not be lubed.


My guess is that the hub did not seat properly when tightened down. It's very easy not to get the hub all the way in so the inner seal is tight against the lip on the spindle. That would cause too much looseness, no sealing and exactly the wear you're describing.
 
Then the FSM is wrong as well. It clearly states in text and pictures to fill the void between bearings with grease. It clearly states to coat wipers and seals with grease.

Wheel bearings are not air cooled, but you are entitled to your opinion.
 
Then the FSM is wrong as well. It clearly states in text and pictures to fill the void between bearings with grease. It clearly states to coat wipers and seals with grease.

Wheel bearings are not air cooled, but you are entitled to your opinion.

I agree 100% with Gumby's post, that's how I was taught and did it for years as a professional mechanic.

The amount of grease has nothing to do with air cooling, the hubs/bearings are air cooled, the wheels, brake rotors etc do this job. If the hubs are fully packed, the bearings have to push excessive grease, this this causes drag/heat, can cause rollers to slide, leading to bearing failure.

I don't see where anyone said that seals shouldn't be greased?

My FSM clearly shows the proper method of filling the hub, even with the races, not packed full.
Hub-grease.webp
 
Wheel bearings are not air cooled, but you are entitled to your opinion.

Of course they are, to the extent that they are cooled at all. Do you have liquid coolant lines to your wheel bearings?

I'm not sure where the subject of air cooling came up anyway.
 
Typically too much preload will cause premature failure. Other causes can be contamination due to poor greasing, poor grease packing of the bearing itself, changing bearings and NOT changing the races. I'm sure there will be other suggestions.

As told to the original 80sCOOL list by Norm Needham, better to err on the loose side than on the tight side of preload. Words to live by, but keep in mind that a turn of 1 flat (1/6) can be the difference.

In my experience loose wheel bearings are much more prone to damage, reduced life than tight. Loose bearings get pounded, the play allows for leakage, etc, loose = weak, tight/preloaded = strength.

I know of a couple that have misinterpreted the FSM procedure and torqued the nuts to 54 ft-lb and run them thousands of miles, one took a couple of long cross country road trips without issue. Both showed no bearing wear, they were cleaned, packed, properly preloaded and are still running today.

For rigs running bigger tires, off-road, I always preload higher than the FSM calls for, makes for a stronger, longer lasting setup. The bearings used on these rigs are way oversize when compared to what's used on most vehicles, if properly maintained, not run loose, they should last pretty much the life of the rig.
 
The mechanism that causes water in the hubs is vacuum. The hubs run relatively warm, they cool rapidly when dunked in water, this causes the air in them to contract creating vacuum. If there is a leak water will be pulled in destroying the grease/bearings.

It's hard to say what failed on yours? It could be loose bearings causing the seals to leak, a seal that got folded/damaged on installation, seal spring missing, the dust cap is deformed, loose, scared, etc? But the hubs should be sealed and not have this issue.
 
Check your spindle before getting parts. If it ran loose for a while, a lip may have been pounded into the spindle in the exact spot where the new bearing will need to sit. Also, the fried bearing may have spun on the spindle enough to ruin it. I try to check the front wheels for looseness before long trips just to avoid this failure. That reminds me, I should go check them now.

My guess is they were loose for a while and the hub moving up and down caused the rear seal to fail, then the water came in from there. Either way, it sucks.

Put me down for not loading up the hub copletely with grease. You waste Mobil 1 grease and once water is in that far, the bearing has already moved water through itself anyway.
 
I used more than a full tube of moly on each side, made sure I packed the hell out of those things....I think it leaked through the dust cap, it wasn't fully seated when we pulled it. Didn't think about it till someone said dust cap.
 
I used more than a full tube of moly on each side, made sure I packed the hell out of those things....I think it leaked through the dust cap, it wasn't fully seated when we pulled it. Didn't think about it till someone said dust cap.

Shouldn't the wheel bearing get regular grease or does it matter?
 
“If the hubs are fully packed, the bearings have to push excessive grease, this causes drag/heat, can cause rollers to slide, leading to bearing failure.”

I am not a master mechanic, so I am having trouble wrapping my head around what you folks are saying here. The wheel bearing rollers are in contact with the races, the actual needle bearings of each roller are inside the internal bearing cage which we took great care to fully pack with grease either using the palm of your hand or a bearing packer. The races are pounded into the hub, and the inner surface of the wheel bearing is in contact with the spindle. The only moving parts here are the rollers, needle bearings and cage.

Any excess grease has been pushed out of the inside of the hub when it gets seated on the spindle. As you tighten the spindle nut while rotating the hub, any grease that needs to get squeezed out between the spindle and bearing rollers is getting squeezed out. So now the hub is seated on the spindle and the only excess grease is in contact with the spindle and hub between narrow end of the bearings. Grease is pretty slippery stuff and is a thermal conductor. I cannot visualize how this can cause an overheating condition or cause the rollers to slide on the races.
 
Back
Top Bottom