Wheel bearing failed!

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Grease doesn't compact very well. If you overfill the cavity you risk pressurizing the grease when you put the hub on the spindle. This can lead to resistance, both in the seating of the bearings and rolling friction. I remember seeing a diagram somewhere of the hub, and a note that the cavity between the races should not be overfilled, and that there should be a pocket for air. My memory is not good, so I can't tell you where that was, in the forum, FSM, owner's manual, or some Haynes or Chilton's book.

I have never heard (from a reputable source) that leaving the bearings loose is better than overtightening them. In fact I've heard just the opposite. A tight bearing keeps the surfaces in contact, disbursing the load over the full width of the roller and race, while a loose bearing will ride on the corners putting all the force on one tiny spot at the edges of the roller and race. Bearings only get looser, never tighter, so where do you want to start? Obviously, if the bearing won't turn at all the preload might be excessive, but that's pretty extreme.

-Spike
 
If a bearing has no clearance when cold, when it gets hot it has no where to expand, which can cause the bearing to wear more rapidly, also to much grease will make the bearing run hotter, I know it sounds odd, but it does.

The fish scale method is crap, there are to many things that can influence things.

The best way I have found to load the bearings is, install the bearings, the washer and the 1st lock nut, put the wheel back on with two nuts and tighten, you can then get a large screwdriver to jam against one flat of the nut and the inside of the hub, as you turn the wheel it tightens up the nut, when you can feel that it is quite tight, remove screwdriver and turn wheel a few times to squish out the grease between rollers and bearing surfaces, do the same again.

Get hold of wheel top and bottom, you will feel no movement in the bearing at all, then loosen the nut one flat, get hold of the wheel top and bottom and try again, you will now see physical movement on the wheel and also feel the looseness of the bearing.

Now gradually tighten the nut back up using the screwdriver method until you see and feel no movement on the wheel, you now know that all surfaces of rollers and bearings are touching in all the right places, then tighten the nut again but only by two or three degrese, then lock everything up as normal.
 
In the end, I think loss of lubrication is the reason that bearings fail. Whether its water wash out like this case, or just a lack of maintenance.

The factory diagram doesn't lie, and that's how I do mine. Even that takes more grease than you might think.

The rollers themselves get fully packed, as in can't hold any more. I don't understand how more grease would help, but I also don't see how more would cause it to heat up.


Just a personal anecdote: I was doing the front end on my newly acquired FJ62, and found 1 of the bearings (an inner) was clearly on the way out. the rollers looked OK but the race was worn and starting to pit. Since I bought it from the original owner, and I had all of the records back to 1989, I knew the bearings had never been done. The old grease was dried out and very dark, yet it stayed together for 117k miles.

Bottom line-these bearings can go a long, long time even with adverse service conditions, which is what makes me think that 747 here had contamination first, and failure second. Arguing about how much grease is a religious argument, and the safest course is to follow the bible (FSM) generously provided in the diagram from ToolsRUs.
 
Bottom line-these bearings can go a long, long time even with adverse service conditions, which is what makes me think that 747 here had contamination first, and failure second. Arguing about how much grease is a religious argument, and the safest course is to follow the bible (FSM) generously provided in the diagram from ToolsRUs.

The bearings can go a long time unless they are frequently overloaded, frequently immersed in water, , or are improperly installed. I don't think the former happened, we don't know about the second, which leaves the third. The question then is what was done improperly so the mistake is not repeated.
 
Nope, the second is the most likely culprit. Driving in creeks and through water is some of my favorite wheeling. I am used to changing out diff fluid and greasing my driveshafts all the time....does this mean re-packing my wheel bearings is going to be a tri-monthly affair?

The dust caps over the ends of the birfs and c-clip weren't seated fully....and I think this is where all the water probably came from. I followed the FSM to a T, but did use a fish scale....there wasn't any play in the wheel when I did the job, but I made sure not to over-tighten them too.
 
Nope, the second is the most likely culprit. Driving in creeks and through water is some of my favorite wheeling. I am used to changing out diff fluid and greasing my driveshafts all the time....does this mean re-packing my wheel bearings is going to be a tri-monthly affair?

The dust caps over the ends of the birfs and c-clip weren't seated fully....and I think this is where all the water probably came from. I followed the FSM to a T, but did use a fish scale....there wasn't any play in the wheel when I did the job, but I made sure not to over-tighten them too.

Keep the water out, follow the FSM, use quality bearings, you should be fine....... repack after 30 K.
 
VT sounds like water ingress did do all your damage, bearings really don't like water and soon fail if it can get in easy.

I only pointed out that grease does make a bearing run hotter but it will never make a bearing fail, well not in a wheel of an LC, wheel bearings are not really under much load at any time on car, if they have just the slightest bit of lubrication they will last for ever.
 
...
I am not a master mechanic, so I am having trouble wrapping my head around what you folks are saying here. ...

Grease isn’t a lubricator, the oil contained in it is. The lubrication (oil) need for bearings is very small, as the bearing operates a small amount of oil is liberated and lubes the bearing. The bearing should never have to push grease after the initial run in, it should be pushed out of the rollers path, but be close to them. Excessive grease makes the roller push, churn grease all of the time, causing higher drag, temperature numbers.

The best description that I found, from here;

What is the problem with over lubrication? If a little lubrication were good, wouldn't a lot be better? Not really! Think about it this way. Picture yourself on a hot day walking along the beach. You go into the water up to your ankles, and as you walk along rapidly you feel cool and refreshed. Now walk rapidly in water up to your waist and you see the problem. It takes a lot of energy to get through the same temperature water and this would make you hot and fatigued instead of cool and refreshed

It's the same thing with lubrication. Too high a lubrication level and the bearing will consume energy as it plows through the lubricant. This energy will show up as heat added to the lubricant causing it to first lose its viscosity and then the lubricant will begin to form varnish and coke as it gets hotter. Varnish and coke are another name for solids.

From SKF, here;

Excessive amounts of grease will cause the operating temperature within the bearing to rise rapidly, particularly when running at high speeds. As a general rule, when starting up only the bearing should be completely filled, while the free space in the housing should be partly filled with grease. Before operating at full speed, the excess grease in the bearing must be enabled to settle or escape during a running-in period. At the end of the running-in period the operating temperature will drop considerably, indicating that the grease has been distributed in the bearing arrangement.

From the Society of Manufacturing Engineers, here;

With grease, more is not better. Excessive amounts can cause heating due to churning, which will deteriorate the grease. Approximately 20–30% of the open area between the races should be filled. Following the grease fill, a careful run-in period is required to fully distribute the grease within the bearing.

From here;

The over-packing and over-greasing of bearings accounts for more failures than any other factor. Excess grease in a bearing cavity increases internal friction, which in turn raises the bearing temperature above the dropping point of the grease. This causes oil separation and eventually lack of lubrication. When packing a split housing pillow block bearing ensure that the grease cavity is only one-third full.

NTN bearing, here;

The amount of grease used in any given situation will depend on many factors relating to the size and shape of the housing, space limitations, bearings rotating speed and type of grease used.

As a general rule, housings and bearings should only be filled from 30% to 60% of their capacities.

Where speeds are high and temperature rises need to be kept to a minimum, a reduced amount of grease should be used. Excessive amount of grease cause temperature rise which in turn causes the grease to soften and may allow leakage. With excessive grease fills oxidation and deterioration may cause lubrication efficiency to be lowered.
 
Great thread. Bookmarked for when I rebuild my front axle.

When I was having my front brakes done, we noticed the race was pitted. After pulling the race, it was from a different manufacture than the bearing. R&R with a factory race and bearing. Make sure you replace both race and bearing when rebuilding them.
 
I was searching for the SKF bearing/grease info page, well done tools r us for finding it, I am an engineer in a paper making plant here in the UK and have a lot of dealings with bearings and SKF

The bearings in an LC turn very slowly compared to the bearings that run fast in industrial situations, 2000 rpm and above are the norm, in an LC I would still go with having a bit to much rather than not enough grease, especially if you do a lot of water dunking, all the places in the knuckle with no grease will probably fill with water, so best to leave as little space as possible if you do a lot of deep water driving, this is where to much grease is actually better in the long run.
 
Interesting thread.

Assuming that the bearings are fully seated, one technique that I learned was tighten the hub down then spin it in both directions several times. Then loosen the nut, tighten back down.... spin.... repeat.
 
Last edited:
Any quote of Norm Needham mandates the reply that he is a Cruiser God whose words are sage.

Doug
 
Apparently this same thing happened to my PS front hub on my new '97. My mechanic (weak, I know) just called me today and said the hub had water and mud in it. The PO gave me records going back to 60k miles of the 101k that are on it and I don't see any bearing maintenance at all. :bang:
 
The PO gave me records going back to 60k miles of the 101k that are on it and I don't see any bearing maintenance at all. :bang:

How about front axle service (or rear, for that matter). Any axle service would include repacking the bearings, hopefully.

-Spike
 
Back
Top Bottom