Too hot - ideas?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

I would be very curious about the HG and follow up with a Blackstone oil analysis.
 
The cooling system cannot work effectively if there is any air. The expansion tank is there to ensure all air is out of the system. If your expansion tank is dry then you have a leak somewhere (inc HG) or one or more of your hoses are soft. Water pump a possible but

I know I have a small leak behind the timing cover plate

let's start here?

Regards

Dave
 
So I had a radiator go bad and I replaced it with a CSF all metal after the first 2 aluminum ones I ordered wouldn't fit. I've like the quality of the unit but its been running hot since I did it, not too hot around town and because its still spring in utah but if I go up into the mountains I would see 199 and 195 around town. I replaced my fan clutch with a new Aisin blue hub thinking that my old one was toast and had someone flush and burp the radiator. This last weekend I took it to Moab and even though the temps were mild (60's) I hit 221 before hitting the heater going up over price canyon. any hill at all and temps would climb up to around 208-210, without AC on. Down there I removed my light bar in front of the grill, double checked my fan shroud (fitting snug now) and tried to burp the system again as when I arrived my res tank was sucked dry. Still hot, in fact driving up shaffer trail I had to crank the heat to keep in below 220. The fan is roaring at idle, but I can't hear it on the road as roaring. It seems to me like the fan clutch is working because if I stop when its hot and open the hood the check on things I raise the revs and I hear it roaring again and the temps come down. Its acting a lot like when I first bought the truck and the radiator was bad. Hot on the highways mostly and slow to bleed heat.

Is there a chance the radiator I bought could be faulty? Its not leaking. Can you reverse the flow to the trans heat exchanger by mistake? The aux cooler felt really hot. Any other thoughts? The T-stat isn't that old.


You've got something other than radiator manufacturer/design going on. I've had a CSF 2517 on my '97 for a bit over 4 years and not had any trouble from it (save for a bad radiator cap recently).

My Cruiser is coming up on 300K miles and normally runs between 186° F and 190° F. A little bit warmer in the summer months (HOT here in Texas), up to 195° F. If pulling a long hill...(TC unlocked) I've seen it reach 200° F, but not more than that and it quickly recovers afterward.

I run 20K silicone in my Blue Hub fan clutch, have an aux. pusher fan (summertime use) which is connected to a pressure switch on the A/C system, so not running all the time. But other than that....I just keep my engine maintained and am well satisfied with the performance of the radiator.

What concerns me most about your scenario is that you lost all the coolant from your over-flow tank.

You either have a leak someplace...or the radiator was under filled initially. When your vehicle is shut down and the system cools sufficiently...the radiator (now under negative pressure) will draw coolant from the over-flow tank back into the cooling system.

You need to pressurize your system and check for leaks. Replace your radiator cap with a new OEM (ONLY). Check the tubing to your overflow tank, the tank cap and pick up tube to be sure they are not obstructed.

Check the condition of your radiator hoses. Replace the thermostat (with OEM).

There is no way you should be seeing the temps you are experiencing under those conditions. (60 degrees ambient)

Despite what the Brass/Copper radiator detractors say....they can be more than 'sufficient' for a lot of folks under most conditions. I don't think the design or use of material in your radiator is the problem here.

Hope you get it sorted out.

Flint.

 
So here is the cooling system history to answer some of the questions:

1. factory rad was toast when I bought the truck at 226k
2. Factory rad replaced with another OE rad at around 230k, complete top end rebuilt at this time as well including new fan clutch and waterpump.
3. I replaced the Rad a few months ago (298k) with a CSF 2517 when I noticed the OE rad was leaking from the tank, also a new pressure cap (CSF). At the time it looked like there was also some water coming from behind the timing cover below the water pump. After I replaced it I didn't notice any coolant losses in the res tank. I used some coolant system tabs at the time with the OE tank as a temporary solution.
4. I had a shop flush and refill the tank this week when I noticed it was still running hot. At that time they did the flush but advised a new fan clutch, so I bought one and installed it right before my trip. The temps seems to be in check but climbed too high when towing. When I got to camp and let it cool the res tank was empty. I filled it, parked it on a hill and attempted to burp it, but got no air. I drove the rest of the trip like this and the res tank still has the proper coolant. I also haven't noticed any wet behind the timing cover like it had before. No wet spots on the ground either. My tank is collecting a lot of gray crud at the bottom (maybe an 1/8th a cup), what I suspect is the cooling system tabs working their way out. No gas smell in the coolant, no coolant in the oil. Power is good. On the way back I took off a lightbar that was slightly obstructing airflow and I never got over 210 but it was never warmer than 50 and as cool as 30 so that helped obviously.

My theories at this point are:

1. Water pump
2. bad CSF rad (just bad luck)
3. a coolant blockage someplace
 
I just got back from a trip to town (40 mile round trip). I have the exact same radiator in my 97. Right at 300K on my engine. Ambient temp here today (low 70's).

Highway speed 65 mph (the limit on that stretch of road). For the first 10 miles my temp never got over 174° F.

There is a steep hill about 1/3 mile long that requires I shift out of O.D. (if I want to maintain my speed). At the top of that hill my coolant temp had risen to 180 and my transmission temp raised 4 degrees (to 131). Going on the down hill side, the temp dropped back down to 177 and then leveled out at 184 by the time I reached town.

On the trip back (engine good and warmed up now) it ran at 186° F. Moved up 2 degrees on the hill climb...but immediately went back down once on the other side.
 
I just got back from a trip to town (40 mile round trip). I have the exact same radiator in my 97. Right at 300K on my engine. Ambient temp here today (low 70's).

Highway speed 65 mph (the limit on that stretch of road). For the first 10 miles my temp never got over 172° F.

There is a steep hill about 1/3 mile long that requires I shift out of O.D. (if I want to maintain my speed). At the top of that hill my coolant temp had risen to 180 and my transmission temp raised 4 degrees (to 131). Going on the down hill side, the temp dropped back down to 177 and then leveled out at 184 by the time I reached town.

On the trip back (engine good and warmed up now) it ran at 186° F. Moved up 2 degrees on the hill climb...but immediately went back down once on the other side.

What are you using for Trans temps? NOTE: Im in Utah at 5000 feet so that stresses cooling systems a little as do the many hills and mountains. Just by way of information for comparison. That being said, I've never gone hotter than 190 on the OE stuff so I have a hard time seeing how the CSF could be THAT much worse in cool temps than the OE was in high temps and loads. This is good beta, thank you.
 
What are you using for Trans temps? NOTE: Im in Utah at 5000 feet so that stresses cooling systems a little as do the many hills and mountains. Just by way of information for comparison. That being said, I've never gone hotter than 190 on the OE stuff so I have a hard time seeing how the CSF could be THAT much worse in cool temps than the OE was in high temps and loads. This is good beta, thank you.

Yes, your altitude and driving conditions will make a difference. The only time I see any significant temperature increases are during fairly long hill climbs and in slow moving traffic (HOT summer days with A/C blasting), but even then.... exceeding 195° F. is unusual.

I monitor coolant temps via my ScanGauge and my Trans temp with a digital Auber Gauge using their best temp sensor (pan mounted).

Digital Trans Temp Gauge Install........
 
Last edited:
I have the same problem just got back from a week of over landing full Israel national trail 900 miles in total 600 miles on trail with a lot of steep mountains rock gardens rock crawling very heavy payload (10 gallon gas 25 gallons of water food tents etc.) and we hit extreme hot summertime weather
No one goes to the desert on summer and we got 2 days of 104 F in the shade air temp, in the sun objects like the rig and rocks get to 170F
My rig run hot could not operate the AC most of the time and got working temp of 194-205 on long uphill I got to see 221F drive was continuous 150 miles on trail everyday.
My cooling system is brand new including new oil cooler water pipes, pump, rad cap OEM except CSF rad and the thermostat 172F and new stock blue fan clutch

I have an OEM electrical fan connected to the AC upfront
Fan shroud is perfect
I have a transmission oil, air cooler in series to the radiator, do American model have this?? Funny thing this cooler is almost cold all the time
I have engine hood vents
I measure engine temp by OBD and digital thermometer connected to the engine block
I run Toyota, Red, no messing fluid.

Next steps
1. Blue fan clutch mod - how much 20k fluid should I use? @inkpot ?
2. Another electric fan manual control
3. OEM thermostat




IMG_4675.webp
IMG_4713.webp
IMG_4738.webp
IMG_4750.webp
 
I have the same problem just got back from a week of over landing full Israel national trail 900 miles in total 600 miles on trail with a lot of steep mountains rock gardens rock crawling very heavy payload (10 gallon gas 25 gallons of water food tents etc.) and we hit extreme hot summertime weather
No one goes to the desert on summer and we got 2 days of 104 F in the shade air temp, in the sun objects like the rig and rocks get to 170F
My rig run hot could not operate the AC most of the time and got working temp of 194-205 on long uphill I got to see 221F drive was continuous 150 miles on trail everyday.
My cooling system is brand new including new oil cooler water pipes, pump, rad cap OEM except CSF rad and the thermostat 172F and new stock blue fan clutch

I have an OEM electrical fan connected to the AC upfront
Fan shroud is perfect
I have a transmission oil, air cooler in series to the radiator, do American model have this?? Funny thing this cooler is almost cold all the time
I have engine hood vents
I measure engine temp by OBD and digital thermometer connected to the engine block
I run Toyota, Red, no messing fluid.

Next steps
1. Blue fan clutch mod - how much 20k fluid should I use? @inkpot ?
2. Another electric fan manual control
3. OEM thermostat




View attachment 1674410 View attachment 1674413 View attachment 1674420 View attachment 1674421



Add 60ml of 20k or even 30k fluid in the clutch and you should be good to go. I was in death valley that hit 104F 8am in the morning and 108F(or higher) mid day going up hills and had AC on the whole time.
 
Add 60ml of 20k or even 30k fluid in the clutch and you should be good to go. I was in death valley that hit 104F 8am in the morning and 108F(or higher) mid day going up hills and had AC on the whole time.


^^^^^^ I'm sure it varies depending upon how thoroughly one is able to drain the old fluid out, but I put about 48ml in mine and that seems to be just about right. I don't know what the 'limit' is....but I do know you can put too much in the fan clutch and end up with it running all the time. Your figure might be right.....just throwing that out there.
 
Food for thought: When I deleted my cats and opened them up they were fairly well clogged. subsequent engine temps dropped 10+ degrees across the board (at idle and climbing etc)

Imho.....the cooling system is the sum of the systems parts. A partially opening thermostat....clogged cats....slightly light fan clutch.....winch blocking airflow to radiator......missing radiator felts.....missing splash guard.....larger tires.... etc etc....the list goes on:

If each only contributes a few degrees you can add 20-30degrees real fast. this is why Robbie mandates a cooling system overhaul when he does Headgasket jobs.
 
Food for thought: When I deleted my cats and opened them up they were fairly well clogged. subsequent engine temps dropped 10+ degrees across the board (at idle and climbing etc)

Imho.....the cooling system is the sum of the systems parts. A partially opening thermostat....clogged cats....slightly light fan clutch.....winch blocking airflow to radiator......missing radiator felts.....missing splash guard.....larger tires.... etc etc....the list goes on:

If each only contributes a few degrees you can add 20-30degrees real fast. this is why Robbie mandates a cooling system overhaul when he does Headgasket jobs.

Truthfully I'm pretty sure my cats are toast... But... The big temp changes came all at once so it happened in this last colonic system change. Not saying you're wrong I'm sure it's not helping to have my exhaust so badly clogged.
 
Truthfully I'm pretty sure my cats are toast... But... The big temp changes came all at once so it happened in this last colonic system change. Not saying you're wrong I'm sure it's not helping to have my exhaust so badly clogged.
If the plates in your cats are loose, they may be clogging the outlet partially when working it hard. My neighbors 94 has a plate loose and he will lose power and heat up when itsi blocking.
 
The CSF radiator should be more than sufficient. The PO installed one in my 97 and it had no problems towing 6000 lb of car and trailer last year. That was 500 miles of interstate driving in 80F weather.

Do you have the rear heater installed? If so, are those lines bled? Have they ever been replaced? Those lines are known to leak.
 
The CSF radiator should be more than sufficient. The PO installed one in my 97 and it had no problems towing 6000 lb of car and trailer last year. That was 500 miles of interstate driving in 80F weather.

Do you have the rear heater installed? If so, are those lines bled? Have they ever been replaced? Those lines are known to leak.

I do have the rear heater but I've recently inspected those lines and they are in great shape, no leaks.
 
Back
Top Bottom