The ABS mod?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

So my point stands even more: computers are capable of allowing a vehicle to outperform an otherwise unequipped vehicle when programmed right. If ABS systems were simply "slow and safe" it wouldn't be banned in F1.

The latest TG mag shows the computer controls for a rally car. Multiple ridiculous levels of control over things like e-diffs, etc. My point is this: equal car, one with computer aide, one without on something as slick as ice... the car with computer help is going to be faster if the computer systems are done right. Nothing any human can do can help the fact that computer systems are instant. Now, I'm not saying you can go out and flog a volvo around and expect to go anywhere fast... clearly they are going nanny you in too much, but the idea of "people should learn how to drive and computers should not be a part of cars" is nonsense! If you want to extract every ounce of performance from a car you are going to need a computer there holding your hand and letting you push ever closer to the limit of adhesion.
 
So my point stands even more: computers are capable of allowing a vehicle to outperform an otherwise unequipped vehicle when programmed right. If ABS systems were simply "slow and safe" it wouldn't be banned in F1.

The philosophy is why it's banned. This is the cutting edge of vehicle technology. A programmed ABS box for a given track isn't going to give cutting edge to production vehicles. Most winning WRC rally cars don't use ABS, because differentials are locked or biased too far. And Left foot braking, rear ebrake and steering inputs makes ABS ineffective.


The latest TG mag shows the computer controls for a rally car. Multiple ridiculous levels of control over things like e-diffs, etc.
ediffs is to allow tuning of the front rear balance to the conditions of the car setup. I crew chief for a Evo 7, and prior to that a Group A S2 Audi quattro. Both have locked center diffs, the quattro 3 permanently locked diffs. There is computer control of engine functions, not any computer control of driver functions.


My point is this: equal car, one with computer aide, one without on something as slick as ice... the car with computer help is going to be faster if the computer systems are done right.
That's a tall order. How do you measure yaw and pitch on ice to correspond with wheel speed input to make it faster? About the only point that goes to your favor is straight line acceleration with Torsen Center diff, with Traction control and Engine torque control. Turns and computers shift the advantage back to the driver.

Nothing any human can do can help the fact that computer systems are instant. Now, I'm not saying you can go out and flog a volvo around and expect to go anywhere fast... clearly they are going nanny you in too much, but the idea of "people should learn how to drive and computers should not be a part of cars" is nonsense! If you want to extract every ounce of performance from a car you are going to need a computer there holding your hand and letting you push ever closer to the limit of adhesion.

I disagree. Computers are REACTIVE to inputs, humans can predict inputs. I've been at Steamboat 11 years, in road racing and prorally before that. At Steamboat the latest quattro hardware and software is there. The fastest guys are the ones that have the skillset and the experience to drive at the limit. ABS is disabled, EDL and ESP are too. I understand your position, I just don't agree with it. These computers are in street cars for SAFETY. And the safety is not designed to be AT the limit of adhesion. To your own point, computers will react BEFORE/PREVENT the limit of adhesion. That's their design!

I say get the skillset at the limit of adhesion in controlled conditions before you need it. All this electronic stuff may allow more vehicle control. That doesn't mean any given driver has control because he has computers. Research shows quite the opposite in the case of ABS and avoidance maneuvers.

ST
 
Last edited:
I dunno, but there are a hell of a lot less serious accidents and serious injuries in our district, these days, then there used to be. I don't doubt that some of it is due to computer aided design of passenger compartment and computer activated airbag systems as well as computer activated ABS and probably even traction control and computer aided design that makes a more secure passenger compartment. I am glad that all those "idiot" drivers out there have those computer aids, makes me feel a little safer. I don't care if "driver training" would make them safer, as they are not interested in it.

Maybe I am fortunate not to have any vehicles that have traction control/stability control, but even if I did, I am a very conservative driver, and I doubt they would ever activate unless it was a situation when I truly needed them (due to my inexperience drifting a big heavy SUV through high speed turns).
 
I dunno, but there are a hell of a lot less serious accidents and serious injuries in our district, these days, then there used to be.

Maybe I am fortunate not to have any vehicles that have traction control/stability control, but even if I did, I am a very conservative driver, and I doubt they would ever activate unless it was a situation when I truly needed them (due to my inexperience drifting a big heavy SUV through high speed turns).

SAE 99-01-1288 and 99-01-1290 are worthy of reads. They first quote NHTSB stats that ABS increases Single Vehicle Fatalities while reducing Mulitple vehicle Fataliies *only* in wet conditions compared to non ABS vehicles. This supports that ABS <not equal to> car control or "less" accidents.

The controlled evnvironment Accident Avoidance Studies in these papers tries to attribute some insight into *why* those statistics are sobering. Like drunk driving, or other significan factors. They found none. They *propose/suspect* that ABS allows more steering control which allows you to steer around the guy you would've hit, but that causes a single vehicle accident. That's a driver training problem.

And although you feel folks don't care, I disagree. Enrolment in marque driving schools has never been higher, and several clubs (including the ones I'm involved with) are having great success with Teen Driving Clinics in the same settings. Part of these schools is accident avoidance, lane change maneuvers, and folks (like me last year) manning the water truck in the slolom course.

I may be accused of preaching here, but I practice what I preach, and have for several years. Driver Education is the biggest factor to vehicle safety, not computers.

Rant off.

ST
 
SAE 99-01-1288 and 99-01-1290 are worthy of reads. They first quote NHTSB stats that ABS increases Single Vehicle Fatalities while reducing Mulitple vehicle Fataliies *only* in wet conditions compared to non ABS vehicles. This supports that ABS <not equal to> car control or "less" accidents.

The controlled evnvironment Accident Avoidance Studies in these papers tries to attribute some insight into *why* those statistics are sobering. Like drunk driving, or other significan factors. They found none. They *propose/suspect* that ABS allows more steering control which allows you to steer around the guy you would've hit, but that causes a single vehicle accident. That's a driver training problem.

And although you feel folks don't care, I disagree. Enrolment in marque driving schools has never been higher, and several clubs (including the ones I'm involved with) are having great success with Teen Driving Clinics in the same settings. Part of these schools is accident avoidance, lane change maneuvers, and folks (like me last year) manning the water truck in the slolom course.

I may be accused of preaching here, but I practice what I preach, and have for several years. Driver Education is the biggest factor to vehicle safety, not computers.

Rant off.

ST

I'm sure there is a plethora of reasons why we see fewer severe injury accidents in our district, I suspect, but can not prove that VSC, ABS, airbags, passenger compartment design, and driver education all have something to do with it. Computers are involved in all but the last one.

You will have to define marquee driving schools because if it is what I am thinking of, enrollment may be an all time high, but I bet the attendance at all of those combined does not approach 1% of the US population. Last I remember, here in WA teen drivers are required to take "Drivers Ed" or wait an extra couple years to get their license (most teens don't want to wait), and I agree education is a great thing.

I will, again, give the best driver training for driver accident avoidance: Never get in a car.
 
Marlin,

If your cul de sac is smooth ice I think it would be even money studs vs studless. But if it's patches of ice, rough, wet, slush, snow or combos the studless would prevail. I've now run studless for 3 winters and studs for the 10 winters prior on the 80 and before I made the switch I called a buddy who used to run an ice driving school. I know the concept that a fancy rubber compound can grip better than a carbon steel pin dug into ice is hard to accept. Definitely. But now that I've had some experience after learning the why's and the ins and outs of ice traction I understand. It's been a fast developing part of tire technology, so would take some time to learn about. Neat stuff.

We can run studs here, and I chose to switch not because of road damage or any other factor than safety of my family. It's not very socially responsible of me to say, but I really couldn't give a crap that studs rip up the roads when I'm making a winter safety decision. The new studless tires are grippier on more winter conditions than the studs are.

Here's just one quick aspect of it. Studs decrease traction on wet roads because they create a circle of rubber around the stud that has reduced pressure/grip and the single metal point doesn't offset the loss of grip it produces. Ditto dry roads. Studs also offer zero benefit in snow. It's an interesting topic.

So, I'll pass on your challenge today but if we did it every day for a typical winter I'd probably win 95 times to your 5. You guys must be REALLY cold up there at the moment, eh? I see 6 degrees on the thermometer at the moment and the cold air mass is coming from your area. Brrr....

DougM
 
Marlin,

If your cul de sac is smooth ice I think it would be even money studs vs studless. But if it's patches of ice, rough, wet, slush, snow or combos the studless would prevail.
DougM

2x

I have ran both studded and studless. The new Studless are amazing, better than the studded tires in all conditions I have driven. But, the rub is that the studded tires will last 4 to 5 years and the studdless is shot after 2 years due to the soft/different compounds. To me cost vs lifetime is still the issue with studless tires.

BTW, I bought a new 2006 sienna with ABS, VSC and Traction Control. I worked it over in a large ice/snow covered parking lot using crappy all season tires. Flat out vcs and traction control work. I had to work like hell to get the front or rear to slide at all. I wish the 80 had VSC and traction control. The sienna is better in the slush/ice mix than 80 with BFG AT KO's. Deep 12"+ powder the 80 wins. Any car I buy in the future will have VSC, traction control.
 
2x

I have ran both studded and studless. The new Studless are amazing, better than the studded tires in all conditions I have driven. But, the rub is that the studded tires will last 4 to 5 years and the studdless is shot after 2 years due to the soft/different compounds. To me cost vs lifetime is still the issue with studless tires.

BTW, I bought a new 2006 sienna with ABS, VSC and Traction Control. I worked it over in a large ice/snow covered parking lot using crappy all season tires. Flat out vcs and traction control work. I had to work like hell to get the front or rear to slide at all. I wish the 80 had VSC and traction control. The sienna is better in the slush/ice mix than 80 with BFG AT KO's. Deep 12"+ powder the 80 wins. Any car I buy in the future will have VSC, traction control.

CD, a good comparo might be all those electronic toys vs just Blizzacks or just Rsi's. IME, tires on the 80makes a bigger difference to safety and handling than ABS VSC and traction control.

I'll also put on the record that Blizzacks on an 80 last a LONG time, even with my locked center diff daily driving. I'm at 20k with mine (including that 24foot camping trailer haul last june), and they are still in the "ice" tread (I suspect they won't be after steamboat, but that's 25k). They don't last that long on my street cars, but I'm pretty convinced that's because 2 solid alxes only needs to have correct toe spec.

That Sienna must be *really* good. My comparo with the 80 is to Audi Quattros on Ice in controlled conditions with very high levels of driver experience as a constant. Last year at Steamboat, my 80 with SC and Blizzacks had no quattro challengers. Even the LT1Q waved me by (which I deferred as I was the camera car). What amazed me was how simple the 80 was to control compared to the turbo quattros (flat torque rules). I'll also say it takes a lot of kahunas to really step an 80 out with Blizzacks intentionally. BTTT:cool:

I also note that the stock suspension is well tuned to keeping the tires planted, a key in winter driving. You can see some of the unexcitement comparos of my 80 chasing the wild q's follow the inks at www.gruppe-q.com . That's 12in of ice under the wheels.

I'll take some better vids at Steamboat this year, and happy to test out more comparisons (ABS, CDL, etc) while there.

ST
 
Last edited:
You will have to define marquee driving schools because if it is what I am thinking of, enrollment may be an all time high, but I bet the attendance at all of those combined does not approach 1% of the US population. Last I remember, here in WA teen drivers are required to take "Drivers Ed" or wait an extra couple years to get their license (most teens don't want to wait), and I agree education is a great thing.

I will, again, give the best driver training for driver accident avoidance: Never get in a car.

Then you don't have a driver by definition? My focus last year (now that I have a 15yo in DE) was less on advanced driving education, and more on the surge in Teen Driving education. Seat time is a big factor to teen safety, but proper training in avoidance is most important in that safety. More time on the road, you develop experience to comfort level. Teens don't have that. Train them.

Then as a parent, I have the confidence that my kid has at least some training in what to do and the limits of the car. My best hope as a dad, is it also gives them confidence to make the right choice in getting in a friends car.

What we find in the Quattro Club is that the recruitment of newbie *parents* increases after they watch Jr do a lane change avoidance maneuver in water. I also take the attitude that sharing education in driving is a great thing, and newbies give the best positive feelings that you are making a difference as an instructor.

1% or .001%, I claim only I practice what I preach in Vehicle Dynamics and Control, and making *any* difference, is all good.

ST
 
ST
I agree tires are the most important factor in traction in any driving situation.

My point is that when a 2+ ton car/truck is at the edge of control due to road conditions, VSC and traction control improve the odds of the "less trained" driver keeping the car/truck under control. I.E. my experiance in the Sienna vs the 80.

Note, in the last post that the BFG are winter/snow flake rate tires and all season are not. I have typically ran winter tire on all of the car I have owned. The Sienna will likely be no different next year. I have a difficult time justifying the snows this year due to the crazy weather and timing here.

Are the new blizzacks for SUV's better wearing than the passenger tire version? I was lucky to get 2 years (12K miles) out of the WS-50's ice tread. I also disliked the super soft sidewall on the blizzaks, created really bad turn in with the WS-50's.
 
ST
I agree tires are the most important factor in traction in any driving situation.

My point is that when a 2+ ton car/truck is at the edge of control due to road conditions, VSC and traction control improve the odds of the "less trained" driver keeping the car/truck under control. I.E. my experiance in the Sienna vs the 80.

Non Blizzack constant on the tires? Ok

Note, in the last post that the BFG are winter/snow flake rate tires and all season are not. I have typically ran winter tire on all of the car I have owned. The Sienna will likely be no different next year. I have a difficult time justifying the snows this year due to the crazy weather and timing here.

I had MTR on my 4R. Great in deep snow, a bit of excitement on wet or ice.

Are the new blizzacks for SUV's better wearing than the passenger tire version? I was lucky to get 2 years (12K miles) out of the WS-50's ice tread. I also disliked the super soft sidewall on the blizzaks, created really bad turn in with the WS-50's.

Big time better. I expected to have no tread coming into winter, and I'm still in the ice section with 20k. I have WS-50's for my quattros at Steamboat. They were so goosey that I put inner tubes in them. I also run them at Steamboat only, take them off and wait another year. Others at that venue that run them say they are good for about 5-6kmax, then they go to all season tread.

The SUV version uses a much stiffer sidewall (to get the weight ratings I suspect) and the stock size I run on the 80 are wearing perfectly. No feathering, rollover wear, just flat even wear, and lots of dry road abuse (trailers, SC, cornering, and CDL).

I commented to the Bridgestone boys at Steamboat (their instructors have a lot of 4R supercharged) and they confirm that the SUV tires are much better in wear and handling. Still a bit squirmy for my taste on dry pavement, especially compared to the LTX, but overall, one of the best tires I've owned.

As Christo correctly commented however, I'd make it prolly 200feet at Moab with them. This is ice/snow only.

HTH

ST
 
I'm just starting the 4th winter with the Michelin Arctic Alpins and I'm happy with the treadwear - about 60% left. I have them on separate rims though, which helps with treadwear. You tend to leave them off until actual snow arrives versus putting them on weeks in advance. Same on the other end - mine are back in the garage when it warms up even though the State says you can use studs, etc until April. Agree they will not last like a studded LT which starts with nearly twice the tread depth, tho.....

DougM
 
I've now run studless for 3 winters and studs for the 10 winters prior on the 80 and before I made the switch
DougM

Doug,

So I am talking to the right guy, (I should prolly start a new thread on this topic to draw comments from the masses).

I wanted someone that has run both on thier 80........ your it.
I can only speak from my previous 20yrs of experience but had never driven an AWD vehicle in the winter untill this year.
lots of 4x4s, a volvo RWD and one 76 chevy 2wd that won't move without studs.
The difference between all seasons and studs on our Suzuki was like night and day (very short wheel base and not much weight). The 80 is longer and heavier and has AWD.

Do you think tire size is a factor?
Did you run stock size with studs or smaller?
I will be buying two sets of tires this year, my new 35" mickey Ts for the fun stuff and winter tires for survival, it will be hard for me not to stud them.......convince me.

On every vehicle except my FJ40 i ran a winter set of tires, My take was I will buy 2 sets of tires in 8 yrs no matter, and a spare set of rims gives you more flexabilty, and is cheaper in the long run.

I understand the compound used to make new winter tires combined with max siping creating smaller tread blocks with lots of corners is a good thing and very effective........no argument from me.

The tires i just put on my work truck look just like that........only they also have studs ......why not? I figured the manufacturer but those little holes in the tire for a reason.......And I do have to admitt I drive in the most extreme conditions over mountain passes covered with ice that can see snow any day of the year........... I guess I am old school.

Geordie R.
 
Wow, the topic has grown quite a bit.

To clarify things a bit... Cary, I'm not a techno nanny. I have driven all my life manual tranny cars without ABS, so I know how to modulate and how to feel the limits of traction (especially during 4 months of winter). I am just so happy about my first ABS vehicle that I want to make the best use of it, but it seems that CDL and ABS don't go together.
 
Wow, the topic has grown quite a bit.

To clarify things a bit... Cary, I'm not a techno nanny. I have driven all my life manual tranny cars without ABS, so I know how to modulate and how to feel the limits of traction (especially during 4 months of winter). I am just so happy about my first ABS vehicle that I want to make the best use of it, but it seems that CDL and ABS don't go together.
No they don't. When you took the VC out Mike, you lost the ability to have Limited Slip Locking on the center diff with the ability to retain ABS. That's the only reason Mr. T added the VC to the HF2A transfer case.

You can *test* ABS with CDL on, it won't take long to scare the hell outa yourself.

ST
 
Geordie,

Maybe we should start a separate thread to cover this tire issue. Go ahead and do that and I'll give you my thoughts. Thanks!

DougM
 
No they don't. When you took the VC out Mike, you lost the ability to have Limited Slip Locking on the center diff with the ability to retain ABS. That's the only reason Mr. T added the VC to the HF2A transfer case.

MikeL I missed the history where you pulled the VC. I would be interested to see the discussion thread about that if there is one as I thought you had to give up ABS if you took out the VC. more specifically i thought Mr. T added the VC tcase to ABS trucks because it was necessary for the ABS system to work properly, not as a bonus traction feature (although that was a side effect)
 
MikeL I missed the history where you pulled the VC. I would be interested to see the discussion thread about that if there is one as I thought you had to give up ABS if you took out the VC. more specifically i thought Mr. T added the VC tcase to ABS trucks because it was necessary for the ABS system to work properly, not as a bonus traction feature (although that was a side effect)

A very good tech procedure actually
https://forum.ih8mud.com/showthread.php?t=124794

The VC can be removed and still have fully operational AWD with ABS. The VC in the HF2AV was put in to allow some lockup of the center diff while allowing ABS function (VC unlocks under braking)

Without the VC, the ABS can still be run. The ABS cannot be run effectively with center diff locked.

HTH

ST
 
Back
Top Bottom