The ABS mod?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Not quite... the story is not that simple.

Computer's reaction times are way way faster than humans, and computers can multi-task while humans cannot (don't believe me? try to draw a circle and a square at the same time with each hand.)

A computer with independent control of all 4 wheels can keep a car stable using sensitive accelerometers and by measuring yaw and pitch...

There is no excuse for good driving, but there simply are situations where a computer can control a car in a way no human can.

Actually computers are slaves to us human drivers, garbage in garbage out. We tell them to panic stop, they panic stop.

Now if they had eyes and free will they would have slowed down a while ago and not needed to panic stop.
 
I've posted this before:
http://stage6.divx.com/members/222398/videos/1044084 (primarily worry about the bit at the end)

I agree defensive driving is the best practice for saftey, but there are unknowns while driving and people and things and do unexpected stuff. There really are situations where a computer can simply do what a human cannot.
 
I think something may have been missed here.

My basic understanding is that ABS activates when there is a difference in the turning speed of a wheel. If you have the CDL locked, you are most likely going to lock all 4 wheels, or none, because the axles are synched. If you lock all 4 wheels, there's no difference in wheel speed, therefore the ABS will not activate- whether or not it's on.

-Spike

That is *not* how ABS works on the 80 Spike. ABS only senses impending lockup of any one wheel. So if you have ABS and CDL on, you will have ABS reacting to impending lockup, which will cause another wheel to have impending lockup, and the ABS just chatters your foot to the floor, because it's own algorithums are in a state of constant random lockup thru the driveline. BTTT (aud 4 sensor 3channel abs, center diff locked - one very confused set of pintle valves). Exactly why you touch CDL, ABS light goes on (ABS off).

Put more technically, the ABS can never keep up with Total Brake Capacity (locked center diff), as changing brake capacity with ABS will immediately affect lockup of the other axle, ad nauseum.

Cars (like my wife's v8 quattro for instance) that have electronic locking CDL, sense wheel speed differences thru the ABS sensor to lock the center diff under acceleration, but ABS under braking works on impending lockup.

ST
 
Last edited:
Not quite... the story is not that simple.
Computer's reaction times are way way faster than humans, and computers can multi-task while humans cannot (don't believe me? try to draw a circle and a square at the same time with each hand.)
A computer with independent control of all 4 wheels can keep a car stable using sensitive accelerometers and by measuring yaw and pitch...
There is no excuse for good driving, but there simply are situations where a computer can control a car in a way no human can.

That isn't proven in the research data. I referenced a couple of accident avoidance SAE studies that conclude that ABS and car control are not correlated. Under braking the ABS computer doesn't control 4 wheels independently, it controls only the front wheels independently, and the rears jointly. A computer can control stability up to a point. You have to think of the human variable that affects that, steering. A computer can never steer, so it can never control a car completely, or better than any human. A computer can't predict the deer in the headlights, it only reacts to your reaction to the deer in the headlights. I believe and teach the reverse, there are simply no situations where a computer can control a car the way a human can.

Well how am i going to win this one.

I will bet you $1,000,000 and 1 beer ...
I will beat you off the line.
I will beat you in the corners.
and most importantly i will be able to stop without hitting the neighbours fence.
And bring your woolies cause its -15 C here.

Tempting it might be to collect just the beer, I challenge anyone with preconcieved notions to bring *talent* to my ice event at Steamboat Center For Driving Sciences next month. Studs doesn't make better vehicle control, training and experience does. I still have spots available www.gruppe-q.com . A lot of ProRally drivers can change any thinking that studs makes a better or faster vehicle on any surface.

What CfDS doesn't allow you to do, is put studs on their course. Any other tire is welcome. I've also seen a lot of telented drivers with Blizzacks and Hokka Rsi's on lake ice tracks beat studded tires regularly. Bolted tires are a different story.

ST
 
Last edited:
Ok. Well ST you missed that I was replying indirectly to cary who said "People rely to much on the electronic nannys now days rather than learning to drive."

Now, I am well aware that our system does not use 4WABS, but there are vehs that do. And beyond just ABS, traction control systems and stability control systems do use independent 4 wheel braking, something that no human I'm aware of can accomplish.

It would be unfair to challenge your skill to a slalom against an otherwise equally equipped car with an ESP system engaged, it wouldn't even be a fair fight....
 
Now, I am well aware that our system does not use 4WABS, but there are vehs that do.

Not true at all. All ABS equipped vehicles as of this model year use Select Low Rear Braking. 4 solenoids yes, but under ABS activation, the rear channels are done in unison. I just double cked this with a couple of traction control engineers a few days ago. I got an interesting ABS graph from a unobtanium Factory race car that is working on independent rear braking. Suffice it to say, 4 wheel independent ABS under braking is *far* (as in maybe never) from production vehicles.

And beyond just ABS, traction control systems and stability control systems do use independent 4 wheel braking, something that no human I'm aware of can accomplish.

Be very careful. TCS and SC use braking force to distribute engine applied torque during acceleration. Under braking, these systems are back to 3 channel Select Low ABS. No known exceptions.

It would be unfair to challenge your skill to a slalom against an otherwise equally equipped car with an ESP system engaged, it wouldn't even be a fair fight....

ESP gets confused easily. ESP does not allow left foot braking with Drive by wire throttle control. It wouldn't be a fair fight because ESP isn't optimal, it's just safe. Safe to most engineers is understeer all the time. Remember, if you drive at the limit of adhesion, ESP will fight you doing that all the way. ESP is not a performance device, none of these computer systems are. They are safety devices. Some work better at their intended function than others.

I agree with Cary, we tend to rely on marketing of computer toys, when there is no substitute for just tightening up the loose nut behind the wheel with a bit of training. LT also had a good thought. You panic as a driver, the computer reacts to the panic. I say the computer should assist you with proper reactions to your trained input. Then you might be able to buck the SAE studies that claim ABS doesn't correlate any higher to vehicle control vs Non ABS.

ST
 
Last edited:
ST, you are telling me on sheet ice you can outperform an ESP system? I doubt it... but good luck.

Now, I do agree that ESP is engineered for safety with a bias towards (safer) understeer. However, I don't agree that you can outperform it on a truly slick surface like ice.


And about indept. 4wheel brake control: I *just* watched some MB documentation about their traction control and esp systems which control all 4 wheels independently. And it has been on all of their models for years now. In fact, to quote MB
ESP compares the driver's intended course, via steering and braking inputs, to the vehicle's response, via lateral acceleration, rotation (yaw) and individual wheel speeds. ESP then brakes individual front or rear wheels and/or reduces excess engine power as needed to help correct understeer (plowing) or oversteer (fishtailing). ESP also integrates all-speed traction control, which senses drive-wheel slip under acceleration and individually brakes the slipping wheel or wheels, and/or reduces excess engine power, until control is regained.
 
What CfDS doesn't allow you to do, is put studs on their course. Any other tire is welcome. I've also seen a lot of telented drivers with Blizzacks and Hokka Rsi's on lake ice tracks beat studded tires regularly. Bolted tires are a different story.

ST

They will let me run bolts but not studs? Im sure I misread that.

You take two indentical vehicles, like an IROC sort of thing, as equal as can be.
you take two equally talented drivers.
you take Hokka Rsi's (I think I just got a set of these w/studs on my work truck) so I think they come stud ready.

One car with em
One with out.

You would actually put money on the studless competitor or you do not think that he has an advantage.

I am pretty sure anybody with track expierience and talent will kick my ass, with studs on my vehicle (I would give it a shot with bolts).

The point I was originally trying to make was that studs offer up winter traction for your AWD/ABS systems when straight rubber fails.......this is not a myth...it is a fact.
 
ST, you are telling me on sheet ice you can outperform an ESP system? I doubt it... but good luck.

I know it, I've turned off Bosch latest ABS 5.3 on quattros at Steamboat more times than I can count. Most do. Try ESP on ice, it shows you how primitive the programming is. We had a guy toot around with it on at Steamboat without issue, but he was driving very slowly around the course. ESP didn't need to do anything the blizzacks did the work.

Now, I do agree that ESP is engineered for safety with a bias towards (safer) understeer. However, I don't agree that you can outperform it on a truly slick surface like ice.

Come up to Steamboat. We have the newest Audi RS4 fresh off the boat that will be there. ESP won't be on long.


And about indept. 4wheel brake control: I *just* watched some MB documentation about their traction control and esp systems which control all 4 wheels independently. And it has been on all of their models for years now. In fact, to quote MB

The problem with the quote you referenced "...and/or reduce engine power" makes that a claim under power, not braking. Under braking, specifically ABS braking, if the brakes are on with drive by wire, the throttle is not.

Select Low Principle rear ABS is the technical term for combined rear ABS solenoid activation under braking. Marketing it is a bit tougher, since all 4 channel abs is really 3 channel by definition. IIRC MB uses Bosch 5.3 ABS/EDL/ESP/TCS box. That box uses Select Low rear braking. The reason for Select Low is to reduce the tendency for oversteer, which is understeer, which is consistent with the marketing blurb they put out. Don't confuse applied engine torque properties with Select Low ABS properties.

ST
 
Last edited:
...
You would actually put money on the studless competitor or you do not think that he has an advantage.

I always put my money and ride with a trained driver, not equipment.

The point I was originally trying to make was that studs offer up winter traction for your AWD/ABS systems when straight rubber fails.......this is not a myth...it is a fact.

So do Rsi's and Blizzacks. And aren't "just" snow and ice tires. They also have better grip in water, slush and dry pavement. And will outperform studs on roads that are slick, because studs need ice to grip better, winter 'ice' compounds don't.

ST
 
I would love to get an MB engineer on this, because I think the phrase "ESP then brakes individual front or rear wheels" is pretty direct.

I'm not saying it's 4 wheel indep. ABS. I'm saying it's 4 wheel indep. brake application. There isn't a whole lot of advantage to indep control in an ABS situation of the rear....

And for the record not all ESP systems have to be painfully obtrusive. BMW, Ferrari, MB, etc have been designing stepped ESP system which allow varying degrees of ESP input.
 
Sumotoy,
you did not read my post........both drivers are equal.

further we are talking about BOTH competitors with brand name RSIs one with studs one without.
I do not believe that on dry pavement studs will change your stopping power , again on the same tire one with studs one without. Studs do not occupy enough of a tires contact surface to change dry pavement conditions.

The reason they are not allowed or restricted seasonally in states and provinces is because they destroy the road surface not because they cause your vehicle to loose its ability to stop safely.
 
Well how am i going to win this one.

I will bet you $1,000,000 and 1 beer ( this seems to be the average wager) and I don't want to take your landcruiser, that would be low-down and dirty.

you take your 80 with any 275/70/16 high tech winter tire you like.

I will take my 80 with any 275/70/16 wall-mart special with studs.

and we will do a lap around my culdesac at high noon tomorrow.

I will beat you off the line.
I will beat you in the corners.
and most importantly i will be able to stop without hitting the neighbours fence.

I forgot to mention that my street is covered mostly with ice , couple of bare patches, and a big snow pile in the middle so you can't cheat and cut the corners, ........mostly just lumpy frozen ice and snow like a costco parking lot in alaska.


And bring your woolies cause its -15 C here.

I'll put $100 on Doug. Compounding beats studs.
 
Sumotoy,
you did not read my post........both drivers are equal.

further we are talking about BOTH competitors with brand name RSIs one with studs one without.
I do not believe that on dry pavement studs will change your stopping power , again on the same tire one with studs one without. Studs do not occupy enough of a tires contact surface to change dry pavement conditions.

The reason they are not allowed or restricted seasonally in states and provinces is because they destroy the road surface not because they cause your vehicle to loose its ability to stop safely.

Go back and read your post (it is right above this). You said studded walmart specials vs. any other studless tire.
 
I was refering to post 28 not 18.........i guess i should use more quotes.
 
I would love to get an MB engineer on this, because I think the phrase "ESP then brakes individual front or rear wheels" is pretty direct.

I'm not saying it's 4 wheel indep. ABS. I'm saying it's 4 wheel indep. brake application. There isn't a whole lot of advantage to indep control in an ABS situation of the rear....

And for the record not all ESP systems have to be painfully obtrusive. BMW, Ferrari, MB, etc have been designing stepped ESP system which allow varying degrees of ESP input.

There are only 2 current strategies for rear ABS braking: Select Low or Select Low + Select High. Honda just announced it's latest (Japanese market only for now) VSA in the accord uses both SLo and SHi, but it's still equal braking to both rear calipers. In Select Low, ABS pressure to both rear calipers is equal to the pressure of wheel with the least amount of traction. VSA uses Select Low, unless a sudden (yaw/pitch defined) lane change maneuver under braking is sensed, then it switches to Select High. Select High means ABS pressure to both rear calipers is equal to the pressure of the wheel with the greatest amount of traction (outside wheel) to help oversteer. It will be interesting to watch the progress (or not) of that technology to the US market.

Regardless of Select Low (ABS rear correct to understeer) or Select High (ABS rear correct to oversteer), ANY abs activation of the rear calipers is equal. So all 4 channel ABS is 3 channel ABS by definition.

4 wheel independent braking only needs 4 lines from the master cylinder. If you speak to computer 'intervention' under braking, equal rear brake pulse applies in Select Low or Select High. I disagree that there aren't advantages to 4 wheel independent ABS. It's just not practical yet, and 'how' you control the rears is still up for grabs from the testing graphs I looked at.

Agree ESP isn't painfully intrusive, I find it wants to correct you too quickly, and drive by wire allows no driver LFB for vehicle balance. On ice ESP has a propensity to be intrusive, as does ABS. IME, the algorithums for low mu get confused because the yaw and pitch inputs don't match the ABS lockup inputs on low mu surfaces.

Regarding your driving challenges. I only challenge driver skill at Steamboat Center for Driving Sciences. I understand tire technology, I wrote winter tire reports for each of the last 11 years I've gone to Steamboat. Studs are fine for roads that don't ever see pavement in the winter.

Nerdin away with a beer in Chitown...

ST
 
Last edited:
If you can get past the confounded drivelogic transmissions in the new BMs you should check out the MDM traction control settings. It cuts in about as late as I'd say they can while still calling the traction control.


Interesting on the select low/high principles of RABS, but certainly there has to be more dev in this area?

As proof if the fact that there are just some things humans cannot possibly be as good at as computers, I leave you with the example of F1 cars and their completely tricked out launch control and computer wizardry. Those drivers are about as elite and professional as they come, but they are still aided by a slew of the most high tech bleeding edge computers.
 
Since, I seem to have started the little discussion about drivers vs. the electronic nanny's, I will fill in what my thoughts are.

1) I will often see on boards (like the original post here and on the BMW boards) comments like "I turned into this corner and the car ran off the road, isn't the ESP supposed to prevent this?" It seems the further we move along in time, the more younger drivers rely on these systems, rather than learning proper driving skills. Then they are shocked when they exceed the limits of the systems, usually at much higher speeds than if they didn't have them.

2) ESP, Traction Control, ABS, etc., are great tools for most drivers when they accidently exceed the the limits of their vehicles, i.e. hit an ice patch, etc., but their purpose is to keep the vehicle under control, not to help it go faster.

3) All the electronic nanny's drive me nuts. It is very disconcerting to me to have a car cut thottle, or change direction from what I am telling it to do because the nanny want's it to. I know that they say the new systems are better, but even the one's I have driven on the new BMW's are way to intrusive for me, thank goodness I can turn them off.

4) On snow and ice, the nannies are great for helping most drivers keep control on the street, that is what they were designed for. Because they are designed for that, they do not allow wheelspin, or high drift angles, the keys to driving fast in the snow. I know for me, there is no worse feeling on low mu surfaces, than that of the front end plowing. The old rally guys used to say, understeer is when your passenger is comfortable and you are scared, oversteer is when you are comfortable and your passenger is scared.
 
Interesting on the select low/high principles of RABS, but certainly there has to be more dev in this area?

Not really. Safe is understeer. I'd be very surprised if Select High catches on frankly. It supports the SAE studies on ABS vs non ABS cars in terms of increasing a given steering angle input, but that's some tricky programming. I know a few traction control engineers, and was introduced to one that is on the cutting edge in racing. He's reprogramming what the factory race car engineers did. Crazy stuff, and pretty far out there in testing.

As proof if the fact that there are just some things humans cannot possibly be as good at as computers, I leave you with the example of F1 cars and their completely tricked out computer wizardry. Those drivers are about as elite and professional as they come, but they are still aided by a slew of the most high tech bleeding edge computers.

Except that specifically does not include ABS, it's not allowed by F1 rules. Here's why... A couple of factory backed teams started to put in computer boxes in that would draw the track in the box and take driver skill out of the equation. Banned in other racing too. In fact, it was 'heard' that some awd cars had electronic boxes that would vary F/R torque split based on track venue as well.

However, those are 10 turns taken 1,000 times in 1 weekend. Look at what's in a World Rally Car, that's 10,000 turns once. The highest tech computer is operated by the codriver.

Food for thought.

ST
 
Back
Top Bottom