Stuck caliper piston

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Dec 10, 2005
Threads
45
Messages
1,448
Went to a dealer today while traveling; got new studs put on a drive flange; mechanic came back and said that I need front pads (I do). I say OK, go ahead, I'm traveling, the car is full of stuff, and it's only $80 on top of the other work, the front wheels are already off--; mechanic comes back 10 minutes later tells me I have a stuck piston; 1 of 4 stuck; will not push back. He showed me the caliper; thing is, he was using a C-clamp and said he had pushed them back one at a time. While I stood there he had the C-clamp in the stuck piston and showed me that it would not go back. He then beat on it a couple of times to show how it was stuck, but he never opened the bleeder valve or took off the hose.

The pads were very thin, maybe 2 mm, and the little wear nubbin had just started touching the rotor. Both pads are wearing evenly, and the vehicle does not pull to one side or the other; tracks perfectly also.

Question; the process I am familiar with is that the pistons are pushed back two at a time while the pads are still on and using the rotor for a fulcrum?? Or, using the Toyota SST that does them all at the same time?? (never seen one)

I always thought that if you pushed the pistons back one at time, you were likely to get a stuck piston??

So here is the question: is this mechanic stupid, trying to pad the bill with unneeded repairs, or do I really have a stuck piston??

I did not have them do the work, just put it back together and drove off; still stopping and tracking fine.


Any suggestions or thoughts would be appreciated ; I am on the road with a very slow connection.
 
Last edited:
No, it sounds like the tech was doing the right thing to me. Brake calipers are really not that complicated, you can move the pistons independantly without harm. And, you don't need to open the bleeder to move the piston back into the caliper, when the brake master cylinder is in it's "relaxed" position it allows fluid to flow backwards thru the system and it just fills up the reservoir.

I also typically use a big C-clamp to push pistons back into the caliper, it's no big deal. You can rebuild the caliper (kinda a pain, slow process, can be a lot of work, but I've done it many times), or just do what most people do and swap a new reman'd caliper on. Eventually that sticking piston will cause the pad on that side of the caliper to wear unevenly, it will become tapered. At least that's been my experience.
 
Adding to above; anyone have a good, or bad, experience with non-OEM calipers?? The OEM price is around $360 each, $270 each with discount. The aftermarket prices run from $45 at O'Reilly's (Cardone) to $65 at Advance and AutoZone (Cardone also i think), to $80 at NAPA, all with various core charges from $25-$80. The first three come with a lifetime warranty, whatever that is. All above aftermarket prices are not loaded. Anyone ever use any of these aftermarket calipers??

I haven't had a bad piston in over 20 years, and that was on a Plymouth. I may try to push one side back at a time with the bleeder open and see what happens when I get where I'm going, if it is not below zero that is.
 
Any other thoughts on how to push the calipers back? ie: your favorite method? I have used (separately) either a prybar or a large screwdriver between the rotor and pad. Anyone know how the Toyota SST works?
 
Last edited:
If the caliper is off, I use a big C-clamp and a block of wood. If still on the truck, ya I just use a prybar like a wedge to push it back.

I have NAPA calipers on my pickup now. I'm disappointed with how fast they are rusting.
 
Adding to above; anyone have a good, or bad, experience with non-OEM calipers?? Anyone ever use any of these aftermarket calipers??

FWIW, I had bought a truck from up North and decided to just replace the rusty calipers. I was dreading ordering OEM ones so while at O'Reilly's for fluid I asked to see their remans. Bada bing...they were OEM cores, same exact casting marks as mine. And whoever rebuilt them was nice enough to include OEM Toyota pins and anti-rattle springs in the boxes, stilll in their little OEM bags with Toyota PNs. Not saying this could happen to you, but it might. I even bought the rear ones at the same time because they were OEMs too.

Steering knuckle rebuild, new rotors and painted calipers with 100 Series pads. Bee-u-tiful.
fronthub.webp
 
Interesting about O'Reilly's,they had the lowest price of everyone I checked. That must be why they want the core back; to rebuild more from OEM cores. I noticed on NAPA's website they had two grades; one for around 58 each, another for double; about 114 each, but these were loaded. I also found some Akebono's online, fully loaded with their ProAct pads; about $150 each. If I were not on the road, I would buy the rebuild kits just for the fun of rebuilding them, on the other hand, much quicker to pick up a couple of rebuilds and run. Might be doing the work in my broinlaws unheated barn; at least that limits the frostbite.
 
Last edited:
Without turning the rotors I will probably just put some cheapo pads on until I get home and can do the full front axle service; then put on my new "Kangaroo Paw" DBA rotors along with new 100 pads at that time. Nice photo; I saw some prepainted calipers online; forget the company name.
 
Use a "C-clamp" or what ever else works, I open up the brake fluid resevoir cap and then compress the piston with a clamp, then pump the brakes in order to push the piston out. Now try cleaning up the piston with penetrating fluid ... I used an old tooth brush then lubed her up. Repeat the compression and extention process on the caliper piston till you are confident of smooth operation.
 
Thanks all, made it 1500 miles with no problems. Will pull it apart in the next few days and see what I get.
 
FWIW, I had bought a truck from up North and decided to just replace the rusty calipers. I was dreading ordering OEM ones so while at O'Reilly's for fluid I asked to see their remans. Bada bing...they were OEM cores, same exact casting marks as mine. And whoever rebuilt them was nice enough to include OEM Toyota pins and anti-rattle springs in the boxes, stilll in their little OEM bags with Toyota PNs. Not saying this could happen to you, but it might. I even bought the rear ones at the same time because they were OEMs too.

Steering knuckle rebuild, new rotors and painted calipers with 100 Series pads. Bee-u-tiful.

I got mine from O'Reilly's, they look to be OEM also.
calipers.webp
 
IIRC Toyota sells remans for $70ish? No??
I have a pair that I bought for the 40, but still cheap with NO core.

My .02

Shane
 
IIRC Toyota sells remans for $70ish? No??
I have a pair that I bought for the 40, but still cheap with NO core.

My .02

Shane

I dont remember (maybe cdan will chime in) but I'm pretty sure the Oreilly way was much cheaper otherwise i would have got for the yotas. Maybe not, maybe i was pressed for time.
 
Toyota has remans

Toyota does indeed sell remans ! And at a fraction of the price of new. I bought some from CDan. Your local dealer never seems to be able to find that part number. I put some on a couple of years ago about this time of year. Call Dan and get them. The price difference compared to these non-OEM remans isn't worth it, nor is it worth your time to rebuild.

Glad you made it home safely !
 
Put remans from NAPA on my '40 a few years ago; they are fine. I believe, but can't be sure, that they are originals that were rebuilt by NAPA. They wanted to cores back for reman. Just my .02:cheers:Ned
 
I got an OEM rebuild from Auto Zone. So far so good. I think you can buy a rebuild kit from Toyota and do your own.....i think........
 
Looks like maybe I paid CDan about $110 per remaned caliper after netting the core. My Excel sheet on that job is a little vague as I did other items at that time so the figures aren't super exact.

Just remember, "Brakes and Steering are required, everything else is optional !!! "

I am sure the local parts store's calipers are Toyota cores. IMHO, that's not really what you are buying. Instead you are buying their "rebuild", as in seals, boots, reassembly, tender love and care, etc. etc. I have had bad luck with Cardone rebuilds on other Cruiser items (air pump for my 60) , so I am not a believer in the "save $XX and get a lifetime guarantee". I had to replace that part three times due to their poor rebuild.

Gotta do what lets you sleep well at night though.

Merry Crimmas !
 
The OEM price is around $360 each, $270 each with discount. The aftermarket prices run from $45 at O'Reilly's (Cardone) to $65 at Advance and AutoZone (Cardone also i think), to $80 at NAPA

Amazing aftermarket pricing. My local AutoZone quoted north of $140.

I've used aftermarket on the daughter's Camry and the son's Bronco. No issues.

Interesting info on the O'Reilly's remanufactured using original cores.
 
Back
Top Bottom