Strap vs. Chain for extracting 80?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jun 18, 2004
Threads
259
Messages
1,501
Location
Pacific Northwest
We are headed into Durango, Mexico for a vacation and plan on some good wheeling. I will be with two Grand Cherokees--nobody has a winch. Sometimes straps break---we have 3 10 meter straps. My cruiser is heavy--dual batteries, compressor, bumpers, sliders, etc. What do you guys think about galvanized chain 1/4, 5/16, 3/8? I realize chain is dangerous if it breaks.... other thoughts?
 
I would want to know what the straps are rated for. You can use vehicle momentum with a strap, not supposed to with a chain.
 
well, even if rated properly (and the usual ones are only something like 5K lbs IIRC), chains are heavy. I carry a couple of 20' and they weigh a ton. Straps probably better (better check to see if snatch or tow straps) if only in that respect. Main redeeming feature I use of chains is that I like to use (twin) chains to wrap around rocks to save the straps when light winching, and also to drag stuff (trees) etc on the ground. This is not really relevant for truck to truck towing, however.

So, straps?
 
Sometimes straps break---


So do chains. I have to believe that a chain would have more energy stored in it than a strap would.
 
So do chains. I have to believe that a chain would have more energy stored in it than a strap would.


OK, maybe semantics, but the amount of energy stored depends only on how much you put into it (how hard you pull). The type of "storage" (elastic vs plastic) would matter as far as how much is released in case of breakage, though, and that depends on the material. E.g. snatch strap vs synth line or rubber band vs clay thread...
 
So my thinking is the chain would be a spare in case we have to pull with two trucks........ If one of us gets really burried up to our bumpers.....We will have shovels. No place to buy more straps down here......
 
OK, maybe semantics, but the amount of energy stored depends only on how much you put into it (how hard you pull). The type of "storage" (elastic vs plastic) would matter as far as how much is released in case of breakage, though, and that depends on the material. E.g. snatch strap vs synth line or rubber band vs clay thread...
Not so fast... it is also a function of the weight of the object being pulled. It doesn't seem like the chain has the same or more energy because you must pull slower and ultimately less hard, but you just give it gas with no realization that the chain was heavier and harder to lift, stretch, etc. Once all that weight has the velocity of a good snap, it's going to do damage before it stops.
 
What is your biggest concern, snapping a strap/chain, or safety WHEN it happens?
 
IMO, chains are to be used with something that pulls slow and steady. If one of you had a winch, chains would be handy (VERY bad form to use a recovery strap on the end of a winch cable since it stretches). Also, if you happen to have a bulldozer, chains are perfectly acceptable.

In your case, you're relying on two much lighter vehicles to be able to tug you out if you sink. Lighter vehicles will need to use momentum to be able to transfer enough force to pull you out. So - proper recovery straps and proper recovery points are the answer here.
 
Chains are for rigging anchors when winching. Chains are not for rigging between two vehicles and pulling. Not if you are doing anything more than moving a dead rig around in a parking lot or just getting it off of the roadway. If you are extracting a stuck rig, using a chain is begging for damage.

If you are hitting a stap hard enough to break it... That same yank would either snap your chain or trash whatever it is rigged to.

You don't have a winch so LEAVE THE CHAIN AT HOME.

Straps are meant for snatching. Chains arn't.


Mark...
 
Straps all the way, buy two more. If you break a new or slightly used strap you are doing something wrong. I have been using the same beat up old nasty strap for years now...
 
also, when comparing ratings, watch out for differences in definition.
Not sure, but I suspect that the 5K lbs of your typical chain is WLL, and if so likely around 15K breaking maybe. (I'd make sure before staking my life on that.) I would not be surprised if some of your typical snatch or tow straps are rated by failure loads OTOH, i.e. a "30K" strap will supposedly break at that level. (check the australian review of strap testing showing lower than that even).
 
The straps are also easier to wash. 40' of muddy 3/8" chain in the washing machine is no fun!

Seriously, though, if are going to drag logs across rocky ground, chain is great. If you are hauling 40' of chain through waist-deep mud and then have the chain fly around when the attachment point fails, straps start looking appealing. 20' (less than 10m) of 3/8" grade 80 chain is about the most you want to lug around when the reach or footing is awkward.
 
Buy a stronger strap. I have an 8 year old 20,000 lb rated strap, and I just used it to snatch jerk a 42 foot furniture delivery truck out of a snow stuck on my flaglot driveway. Go 30,000 lbs if you want to be extra safe, but you cannot safely snatch jerk with a chain because it cannot stretch.

Most organized runs prohibit the use of chains or even straps with metal hooks. There is no decision to be made here. A chain gives you less capability, more weight, and far more danger.
 
A tree strap is not the same as a recovery strap.
 
Since you say you cannot get more straps in time for the trip, then I would buy a 20' chain or two (3/8") and use them with the hi-lift if you get in a jam.

You say you don't have a winch but you probably have a hi-lift and that is a reasonable hand winch in an emergency. Read up on the proper rigging to use one as a winch. You'll need a choker chain and a length or two of shorter chains.

-B-
 
I have to believe that a chain would have more energy stored in it than a strap would.

Really? I would have thought just the opposite. I don't have any personal experience with breaking chains, but my thinking is that energy release in the form of a snap back would depend upon the elasticity of the cable/chain/strap. Less elastic, i.e. chain, less energy upon breakage.

If you've ever actually broken a chain, please chime in. I am curious about this.
 
Back
Top Bottom