Starting problem

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jan 6, 2003
Threads
64
Messages
1,216
1975 with the stock 2f engine. Began having a starting issue a while ago. The problem is occasionally the solenoid would click but starter wouldn’t spin. Voltage would drop from 12.6 down to <10V, so it was pulling current, just not spinning at all. Figured the original starter has a dead spot and was probably on its way out, so I replaced it with a new gear reduction starter and at the same time also replaced the battery with a new one.

Worked fine for a little while but now having the exact same problem. Turn key, solenoid clicks, voltage drops, but starter doesn’t even try and turn over. Kinda stumped now, any ideas. I’m assuming the ignition switch isn’t the problem since the solenoid activates, and the voltage drop means something is drawing current. Could it be a bad starter again?
 
Just checking. You are putting the meter leads directly to the battery posts themselves and not anywhere else correct? Putting them on the lugs or at the starter could read a voltage drop from a bad connection and not necessary a big current draw.
 
Double check the grounds. Then jump the starter AT THE STARTER. Then you'll know if it's a starter issue or or an ignition switch.
 
Ground strap is still there connected to the frame, but I’ll double check everything again to make sure. Doesn’t happen often so it’s hard to track down, sometimes it may do it once or twice then start suddenly.

Thanks for the help.
 
“Looks connected “ does not equal connected. The corrosion hidden under the contact belies what you see. And MANY of us have learned the hard way. Here’s mine

My ARB failed on Rubithon in 1993 and cost me a fender in the Big Sluice. I swear I checked everything in Rubicon Springs before deciding it had to be a faulty solenoid.
One replaced solenoid later, I discovered the real problem.:censor:. Lesson learned.
 
Ground issue your battery ground goes to the block?

I think my battery ground goes to the frame in front of the tray, and I also have a ground from the starter to the frame right below the charcoal cannister. My memory is a little hazy on the other ones, but I'm pretty sure there's a ground from the block to the frame somewhere, either at the motor mount or directly on the block somewhere. Maybe should re-wire or add a few more grounds directly from battery to starter to eliminate some of the failure points.

Just checking. You are putting the meter leads directly to the battery posts themselves and not anywhere else correct? Putting them on the lugs or at the starter could read a voltage drop from a bad connection and not necessary a big current draw.

I have a digital volt meter hooked up in the dash, it's reading the voltage from an aux fuse block which is connected to the battery. So maybe not a direct connection, but should be pretty close to the true battery voltage.
 
[QUOTE="ducktapeguy, post: I have a digital volt meter hooked up in the dash, it's reading the voltage from an aux fuse block which is connected to the battery. So maybe not a direct connection, but should be pretty close to the true battery voltage.[/QUOTE]

Well no, that may not necessarily give ya true battery voltage. Your reading the battery voltage through several wires and connections. The 2.6 voltage drop you mentioned may not be a current draw by the starter but "could" be a faulty wire or connection some where between the dash meter and the battery. A drop test with a multi-meter right on the battery posts would tell ya if you're truly getting a large current draw on the battery.

By taking a voltage drop test at various locations, you can track down bad grounds and connections. If you’re meter shopping, one with a “min/max” function and some alligator clips make it easy to do it single handed or without a remote starter.


I once had a brand-new battery cable with a faulty connection inside the molded-on lug. Drove me nuts for a while but a voltage drop test pointed it out.

Fluke 111.webp
 
I posted this in the diesel section awhile back but I believe it applies to your issue as well (not sure if gassers had a stock starter relay?):

Most starters do, yes. Beside switching power to the starter motor, the solenoid also acuates a plunger that is moving the pinion gear into contact with the flywheel ring gear. The problem is the ignition switch is handling the load from the battery to this solenoid. Adding a second solenoid (technically a relay) to this system is lessening the amperage through the ignition switch and ensures you’re getting consistent power to your starter.

FWIW an auxiliary relay solved my starter gremlins as well.

My ignition switch was working well enough to actuate the plunger with a “click” but wouldn’t always turn the motor depending on how cleanly the pinion gear lined up with the flywheel teeth. You can try and verify this by rocking the truck back and forth in 3rd gear next time the starter clicks, moving the flywheel just enough to take some load off the starter gear.

A small generic relay fixed this issue for me.
 
Check all the plugs (3 on my 79) where they come out of the steering column. My contacts looked good, but occasionally the starter would fail to turn the engine over until I unplugged and re-plugged the connections. Also the two plugs near the battery.
 
starter contacts go bad with time . . . serviceable item

I had gotten a gear reduction starter in which the contacts were not installed properly - started to act up on me just about a year after installing it in the truck . . .
 
Last edited:
Won't have time to work on it until this weekend, but thanks for all the input

Well no, that may not necessarily give ya true battery voltage. Your reading the battery voltage through several wires and connections. The 2.6 voltage drop you mentioned may not be a current draw by the starter but "could" be a faulty wire or connection some where between the dash meter and the battery. A drop test with a multi-meter right on the battery posts would tell ya if you're truly getting a large current draw on the battery.

By taking a voltage drop test at various locations, you can track down bad grounds and connections. If you’re meter shopping, one with a “min/max” function and some alligator clips make it easy to do it single handed or without a remote starter.

I once had a brand-new battery cable with a faulty connection inside the molded-on lug. Drove me nuts for a while but a voltage drop test pointed it out.

I'll try testing at the terminals this weekend, but if there was a bad connection between the voltmeter and battery I would think I'd also see a low voltage at all times. As it is it reads anywhere between 12.6-12.8V while sitting, which is pretty close to my normal battery voltage. It only drops while starting the engine. I'll double check anyway.

starter contacts go bad with time . . . serviceable item
I had gotten gear reduction starter in which the contacts were not installed properly - started to act up on me just about a year after installing it in the tru8ck . . .
[/QUOTE]

How did you know the contacts were not installed properly? Did you have to replace them or just reinstall? I just installed the new gear reduction starter about 3 weeks ago, so haven't really had much time to test it.

I posted this in the diesel section awhile back but I believe it applies to your issue as well (not sure if gassers had a stock starter relay?):

My ignition switch was working well enough to actuate the plunger with a “click” but wouldn’t always turn the motor depending on how cleanly the pinion gear lined up with the flywheel teeth. You can try and verify this by rocking the truck back and forth in 3rd gear next time the starter clicks, moving the flywheel just enough to take some load off the starter gear.

A small generic relay fixed this issue for me.

I think you might be onto something. This sounds exactly like the problem I'm having. Is high resistance in the switch in the switch causing the solenoid to not have enough power?

With my old starter, when it would have a problem, I would shift through the gears and usually it would start. I thought maybe the slight shift in position of the ring gear was causing the starter to engage on a different spot, so I assumed it was the commuter or brushes that were worn. It only happened a handful of times, but I figured it was a good time to upgrade to a GR starter anyway. When it just happened last week, the usual trick of shifting gears didn't work and I started rocking the truck a little. Afterwards I noticed my fusible link was slightly warm, but didn't think much of it, but maybe that's due to the solenoid drawing too much power.
 
I think you might be onto something. This sounds exactly like the problem I'm having. Is high resistance in the switch in the switch causing the solenoid to not have enough power?

With my old starter, when it would have a problem, I would shift through the gears and usually it would start. I thought maybe the slight shift in position of the ring gear was causing the starter to engage on a different spot, so I assumed it was the commuter or brushes that were worn. It only happened a handful of times, but I figured it was a good time to upgrade to a GR starter anyway. When it just happened last week, the usual trick of shifting gears didn't work and I started rocking the truck a little. Afterwards I noticed my fusible link was slightly warm, but didn't think much of it, but maybe that's due to the solenoid drawing too much power.

Assuming the starter solenoid doesn't bridge the contact to the starter motor until the pinion gear is fully engaged with the flywheel teeth, I imagine it's possible the ignition switch + anything else could limit current to the solenoid. If the solenoid isn't able to draw enough current it may not be strong enough to mesh the pinion gear with the flywheel teeth when they aren't well enough aligned.

I'm not familiar with the gear reduction starter you have, or the OEM starters really - this is just my theory. You can test the starter & solenoid pretty easily by jumping the connection from your battery straight to your starter solenoid. If you can't duplicate the "click, no start" scenario that way, move on to making sure you can measure 12V at both the ignition switch and ignition terminal (small wire) of your starter solenoid when turning the key. If you can do that, use your multimeter to check continuity on your grounds: battery > frame > engine > starter motor. If you're confident the grounds are good you can dive into the wiring between your ignition switch and starter solenoid looking for anything non-OEM or damaged.

I'm hesitant to recommend just hooking up a relay like I did because in stock configuration it *should* work without any additional mess.
 
How did you know the contacts were not installed properly? Did you have to replace them or just reinstall? I just installed the new gear reduction starter about 3 weeks ago, so haven't really had much time to test it.

when we opened the starter up it became obvious that the contacts weren't making all that much contact, and hence, the starter would not fire when the engine was hot - when cold, the starter had been working just fine
 
And don't forget Mark's test in post #4. Simple & effective.
 
Haven’t been able to do much to the cruiser due to it raining recently, but the problem hasn’t happened again so I can’t really do any troubleshooting. I did notice the battery terminals were a little loose so I tightened them up, hopefully that fixed the problem. Thanks for the help
 
Back
Top Bottom