Spindle bearing failure

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

There is no grease conspiracy here. Look at the tapered roller bearings and that spindle! The amount of rust on them tells a very clear story that there wasn’t enough grease. Water got inside and then the truck sat.
The outer wheel bearing looks nothing like the inner one so maybe the seal was no good by the inner bearing. The truck only gets used for off roading so does sit in the garage for long periods between use

20191214_143858.webp
 
Check the grease every time you go through a deep (2’ water crossing)

The bearings if set correctly could be checked every 6 months and should be fine.

What would be the recommended time interval for checking the bearings
 
Read once a long time ago in a Toyota tech manual (I forget which one) that said anytime the axle/hubs are submerged in water that the bearings/hubs should be serviced completely: pulled apart, cleaned, and repacked. FWIW.
 
Last edited:
Check the grease every time you go through a deep (2’ water crossing)

The bearings if set correctly could be checked every 6 months and should be fine.

I'd agree with this, but would also say if you're doing regular water crossings, you should extend the diff breather tubes, and look at renewing the felt wiper seals on the back of the knuckle. They'll never be water tight, but if the housing is well vented, and seals are good, and everything is adequately packed with grease you can reduce the chance of water getting in.
 
Yes, there is a comment in the FSM (and maybe the owner's manual in glovebox as well) that the chassis grease needs to be tended to for water crossings. That's a whole different scenario compared to even heavy offroad use. Water intrusion kills stuff quickly. On my axle shaft alignment comment there is no way of knowing if it contributed here, but if in the future you conduct proper hub/bearing maintenance and that spindle bearing fails, someone should be checking the axle alignment (which unfortunately there is no tool for) to see if the shims were misplaced.
 
I'd agree with this, but would also say if you're doing regular water crossings, you should extend the diff breather tubes, and look at renewing the felt wiper seals on the back of the knuckle. They'll never be water tight, but if the housing is well vented, and seals are good, and everything is adequately packed with grease you can reduce the chance of water getting in.
I already have extended diff breather tubes, I am stripping the knuckle down and replacing the felt seals just in case some of the bearing material is sitting in there
 
Yes, there is a comment in the FSM (and maybe the owner's manual in glovebox as well) that the chassis grease needs to be tended to for water crossings. That's a whole different scenario compared to even heavy offroad use. Water intrusion kills stuff quickly. On my axle shaft alignment comment there is no way of knowing if it contributed here, but if in the future you conduct proper hub/bearing maintenance and that spindle bearing fails, someone should be checking the axle alignment (which unfortunately there is no tool for) to see if the shims were misplaced.
I am stripping the knuckle down just in case bearing material got in there. The knuckle got rebuilt 6 years ago at the local garage so one would hope they got the shims/rebuild done correctly
 
Only other suggestion I have is make sure to pack the spindle bearing thoroughly and grease the axle shaft as well before assembly, 1/2 to 3/4 fill the centre of the hub, and 1/2 to 3/4 fill the knuckle too.
 
Only other suggestion I have is make sure to pack the spindle bearing thoroughly and grease the axle shaft as well before assembly, 1/2 to 3/4 fill the centre of the hub, and 1/2 to 3/4 fill the knuckle too.
Yes thanks got some valvoline valplex m grease for the birf and some timken red bearing grease and a new Trail Safe axle seal
 
For your use you might consider going back to the brass bushing instead of the roller bearings. I know there are some vendors (@cruiseroutfit?) that carry the parts.
 
OK, well pay attention here then if you worry your shims did not get replaced right. Your inner axle seal will have a wear pattern that may tell you something. So when you pull the axle out of the axle housing, support its weight and do your level best to not do additional damage to the seal. Once the axle is out, take quality detailed photos of it before removing it so you can see if the axle has been riding in the center (correct), or too high or too low. The latter two would indicate the local garage was careless with the shims. the rubber lips will show wear. If you can then get it out without destroying it you will have additional opportunity to see if the axle has been wearing at the 12 O'clock or 6 position which will then guide you in properly centering that axle. When you remove it, find a way (sharpie?) to mark it so you are certain how it was oriented when examining it closely on the bench.
 
OK, well pay attention here then if you worry your shims did not get replaced right. Your inner axle seal will have a wear pattern that may tell you something. So when you pull the axle out of the axle housing, support its weight and do your level best to not do additional damage to the seal. Once the axle is out, take quality detailed photos of it before removing it so you can see if the axle has been riding in the center (correct), or too high or too low. The latter two would indicate the local garage was careless with the shims. the rubber lips will show wear. If you can then get it out without destroying it you will have additional opportunity to see if the axle has been wearing at the 12 O'clock or 6 position which will then guide you in properly centering that axle. When you remove it, find a way (sharpie?) to mark it so you are certain how it was oriented when examining it closely on the bench.
Have pulled apart and there is 1 old shim at the top so I presume it was the original and has gone back in
 
Read once a long time ago in a Toyota tech manual (I forget which one) that said anytime the axle/hubs are submerged in water that the bearings/hubs should be serviced completely: pulled apart, cleaned, and repacked. FWIW.

What most people don't understand, rubber lip seals are made to keep oil inside axles, engines, and transmissions, they are not made to keep water out. When you are driving through deep water the only thing keeping water from bypassing a lip seal, is that seals garter spring.

I use to work on US Military trucks that were made to cross DEEP WATER, I'm talking water 6 to 8 feet deep or more. One of the first things we were instructed to do after any deep water crossing was a complete service on all systems.

Now one of the things you need to understand about these military trucks. They were built with systems to enable them to cross deep water that our trucks don't have. They used low pressure (under 3 PSI) bleed air off of the air brakes to pressurize all the axles, the transfer case, transmission along with the engine to prevent water from getting pass the oil seals. Plus they had a plug that you installed in the bell housing to keep water from getting in around the torque converter when crossing deep water.

Now even with all these systems in place to prevent water from getting in, we still had to change all the fluids after every water crossing. This is one of the main reasons i avoid deep water in my truck, at my age i just don't want to do this kind of PM everytime i cross deep water.

 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom