Short block engine rebuild, need some advice

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jan 1, 2014
Threads
27
Messages
219
Location
San Diego
So the cause of my coolant leak turned out to be a cracked short block. It was leaking coolant into the crankcase. So I'm in for a rebuild right now and I am waiting to hear my mechanic's recommendations and concrete cost numbers.

Can you guys give me some advice on the following:

If he can get a new short block should I go with that, or have them put in a used block with new pistons, rods, bearings, rings?

I've got about another $1000 budgeted for the ancillary "while your in there" jobs. Keeping in mind that all of the work is being done by the shop, what should I look at replacing either due to age or ease of access?

It's a 97 LX450 with 147,000 miles

Thanks,
 
Sorry wrong terminology I guess. The short block is being replaced, then rebuilt with the existing head. The crack is somewhere in the rear, but I haven't visited the shop yet to see in person. I'll try to take some photos when I do.
 
I believe it, as I also have a cracked short block on my new-to-me last summer 3x locked LX450. Mine is at the bottom if the freeze plug just aft of the oil filter. I noticed the freeze plug was moving out of its hole and weeping during a trip to the White Mountains in CA. I pulled the freeze plug out and confirmed the crack goes all the way through the casting. I sealed the new freeze plug with some 3M 1300L and have been keeping an eye on it since. Now it doesn't move; it just weeps slightly. I discovered this a month after I bought the truck with 149xxx on my first trip out of town :-(

When it finally lets go, I'm sure it will take the engine out. I'm a professional pilot and aircraft mechanic so I hate the idea of running it to failure, so I'm looking for a 1hd-ft to drop in there.

Off to the Orocopia mtns. to do some exploring this weekend in the 80...
 
I'd make damn sure I laid eyes on this "crack" before I made any decisions. Too many shade tree mechanics out there who don't care about you or your budget. If you only have $1000 left then you are probably going to be stuck buying a complete engine and salvaging the block. I wouldn't plan on any while your in there's because I'm sure it will cost more than you have. You might try @2fpower and see if he still has his short block with the bad bearing. Its possible, you could mix and match the non scored crank and bearings from your rig with his block and come out with a working motor.
 
Thanks @half k cruiser . I already scrapped the short block. I have a high miles running driving motor, with a bad head gasket I want to part ways with.

PM me if your interested; however I agree, let's see that crack.
 
Dang dude, that sucks. I totally feel your pain as I am undergoing an engine rebuild due to a cracked block myself.
Although as far as I can tell mine wasn't cracked internally.

It ain't going to be cheap. That's for sure.

Replace heater hoses that are hard to access with the engine installed.
Great time to rebuild/replace the starter.
Vacuum lines.
Really just look for stuff that is difficult to access when the engine is in place and that may need to be replaced soon. (I am kind of a "If it ain't broke, don't fix it" guy, but I can't refute the ease of working in an empty engine bay).
 
Newbie question here but can't any cracks on an iron block be welded? Maybe I'm over simplifying it here, but drill holes at each end of the crack then weld. If it's a cracked cylinder liner than all bets are off but other than that, everything else is a low pressure zone, right? Well, the oil pressure runs in the 50psi range so an oil passage maybe harder to weld close, I dunno.
 
Newbie question here but can't any cracks on an iron block be welded? Maybe I'm over simplifying it here, but drill holes at each end of the crack then weld. If it's a cracked cylinder liner than all bets are off but other than that, everything else is a low pressure zone, right? Well, the oil pressure runs in the 50psi range so an oil passage maybe harder to weld close, I dunno.
Yes, cracks can be welded. Unless you can't get to where it is cracked.

In my case I tried the welding option first, it was a really long crack along the outside of the block on the DS of the engine. The welding definitely slowed the leaking, but I was not able to fully seal the crack (mainly due to the awkwardness of welding it in the engine bay). I then cleaned the block up really good and applied a good coat of JB Weld on top of that, but even then it was still weeping. It must have been cracked somewhere else I couldn't see. That was a year ago, and in that time I have driven it while saving up $$$ for a rebuild.
 
Welding cast iron is problematic. Stitching pins or brazing is a more reliable way of repairing cracks in cast iron.

A new Toyota short block is an attractive option at about $2,700 or a complete rebuilt engine at $3,700. If it was my problem I would put a can of Bars leak cracked block repair in it and see what happens. You don't ever want to buy a car from me.
 
Thanks @slow95z for the offer but im keepin it to a stock rebuild.
 
Back
Top Bottom