One more battery question

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Nov 10, 2006
Threads
18
Messages
228
Location
Crime-free Southwest-Houston
Gonna get a battery soon...been reading on some marine batteries that y'all are running. Got some suggestions before a purchase. Optima yellow top? Not real sure. Don't mind paying a little extra for a little more in the long run. Any help would be more than welcome before the funds flow out my pocket.

:beer:
 
I had heard of some problems with the optimas (abruptly ceasing to function). I went with an Odyssey 1500. You could do a 1700 with minor battery tray trimming. Other folks love the deep cycle yellow top though.
 
Trojan marine batteries are available at most marine stores, and even dick's sporting goods. a type 27 dual purpose (starting/deep cycle) runs about $80.00 or so.

Wal-Mart's everstart batteries are made by exide. The car batteries have a 3 year replacement warranty, and prorate after that. A group 27 runs about 59.00 plus core. Their Everstart group 27 marine batteries (deep cycle, starting or combo) have a 12-18 month replacement warranty. they run about $60.00 plus core. I went with a walmart group 78 (it was lsited as a maxx-1n) dual terminal auto battery for my primary(was listed at 975CCA), and a group 27 deep cycle for my secondary. On my primary, I use the top posts for my factory connections, and the side posts for my feed to my circuit breaker/battery seperator. I use the large terminal posts on my secondary battery.

Walmart also carries the exide orbitals for about $130.00 or so (price may have gone up). They are group 75, and group 78 batteries. They are compact

I went with the walmart's because they were inexpensive, had a good warranty, and have a ton of places to exchange a bad one. I was torn on going with the exide orbitals, but couldnt justify the extra cost for two batteries.
 
my Optima's just failed.


They were eight years old.


so r u saying the optimas sucked or were awsome, i figured 8 years was good?...i'm not that mech... inclined so i dont know?
 
My first set of optima batteries were blue top marine deep cycle. They lasted 7+ years and then failed. I figured 5 years was great, so I was very happy.

Happy enough to go out and purchase two more optima blue tops - I hope to get another 7+ years, but would still be happy with 5 years.

FWIW, only one of the original two failed, but I figured it was best to replace both for equal charging purposes.
 
so r u saying the optimas sucked or were awsome, i figured 8 years was good?...i'm not that mech... inclined so i dont know?

Take it however you like.

Personally I think 8 years is excellent. Probably would have lasted longer but the rig sat for about a month and a half during the hottest part of the summer. Went out to start it and give her a run the other day and nothing. So yes I think I got more than my money out of them and if it had been run during the heat they would probably still be ok but after that many years I would prefer to have them die sitting at the house than out in the middle of nowhere.
 
That don't sound to bad to me. Texas heat kills batteries pretty damn quick...so 8 years ain't to bad to me. Like you said hoping for 5 and got 8. Uh, may not be a bad way to go. Thanks for y'alls help on this.

:beer:
 
Like I previously stated I don't think mine would have died if I had run the truck. So it was probably my fault, however the fact that they did die tells me the end was near anyhow. Heat is hell on batteries but gel's are worth it IMHO.
 
Cool...thanks again...yellow or blue top? Are both for marine apps?

The yellow and the blue are the exact same battery internally. The difference is the posts. The yellow had top posts and "GM" side posts, the blue has top posts with additional 5/16" studs for wing nuts.

They are both very good batteries. Optima started to develop a bad rap due to their red top batteries failing. The red and yellow are not the same battery. The red is for starting and should never be deep cycled.

Odissey's are good too but for the record I have seen them fail prematurely as well. Any batery will fail prematurely when abused.
 
Thanks 619toy,..gonna do some homework before i make a purchase. Gonna look at all of my options...I think (agree) that the red tops are not gonna work for what we use them for. I think I need just a little more...


:beer:
 
I have been in Houston 2+years and was in DFW before that. I have run Optimas in these trucks since 1994 and only had one puke (and it was a blem in an FJ-40.) My write up on the dual batt setup is here: https://forum.ih8mud.com/showthread.php?t=85505&highlight=dual+batteries

Notice I am running the 34R Red, which has reverse poles for the 80. Not sure about 619Toy's comment above, but the so called "side posts" Yellows I have owned weren't sideposts, they are thin tabs/connections for attaching light duty electronics. I wouldn't run a Yellow as a primary.
 
So, elmariachi, you HAVE had good luck with the reds, reversed of course? I'm still tring to figure out which would be the best one for the money...?..?

To everyone...thanks...any more input would, and can be helpful..

:beer::beer:
 
Yep, no problems. I had bad luck with Exide in my boat, but they took a pounding. Odysseys are cool too, but were pricey and hard to find last time I looked. Batteries Plus stores around Houston have treated me good on my Optima prices.
 
I have a Optima Blue Top D34M its 900CC and fits perfectly in the stock tray. The top terminals are offset so the positive fits without modification but I replaced the neg. battery cable with a longer one to make it fit. This was easier than modifying the positive. However if you want to save money you can buy the Yellow Top D34 its the same battery without the extra aux. terminals on top but you will need to modify both sets of cables.

http://www.dcbattery.com/optimacatalog.pdf
 
Not sure about 619Toy's comment above, but the so called "side posts" Yellows I have owned weren't sideposts, they are thin tabs/connections for attaching light duty electronics. I wouldn't run a Yellow as a primary.


You are correct, the side posts do not have the current capability of top posts but they are designed to perform every function on a stock vehicle (specifically a GM). They are definately not designed to run a winch for example. But you can definately run your winch off of the top posts on the same battery.

Is your argument for not using a yellowtop because of the post's or the fact that it is considered to be a deep cycle? They do perform quite well as a primary battery or as the only battery.

I have had first hand experience with hundreds of yellowtop batteries. They are the number one replacement battery for emergency vehicles. As a matter of fact, the San Diego County Sheriff's Department buys over a hundered a year for new vehicles. While I have seen many fail over the years, it still amazes me the amount of abuse they can take and still keep going strong.
 
Back
Top Bottom